Entropy as a Design Principle in the Photosystem II Supercomplex
Johanna L. Hall a,b,c , Shiun-Jr Yang a,b,c,f , David T. Limmer a,c,d,e , and Graham R. Fleming a,b,c, · 2024
Read Entropy as a Design Principle in the Photosystem II Supercomplex by Johanna L. Hall a,b,c , Shiun-Jr Yang a,b,c,f , David T. Limmer a,c,d,e , and Graham R. Fleming a,b,c, (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-12418.txt.
Introduction
Johanna Hall and co-authors argue that entropy is a design rule in the plant's light harvester. Their 2024 paper studies Photosystem II, a pigment-protein machine that can trap light with near-perfect yield, yet dump excess as heat under stress. Most past work read this balance through energy alone. Their model tracks both heat-form and disorder terms over time.
Each protein subunit blends the two forces differently, giving it a distinct job. One traps energy at the core, another sheds it at the edge, and a spare core stands ready if the first closes. Entropy, they show, can be tuned by how antenna parts bind. The findings offer design rules for artificial solar harvesters.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Johanna L. Hall a,b,c , Shiun-Jr Yang a,b,c,f , David T. Limmer a,c,d,e , and Graham R. Fleming a,b,c, |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-12418
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Entropy as a Design Principle in the Photosystem II Supercomplex Preprint: APS/123-QED Johanna L. Hall a,b,c , Shiun-Jr Yang a,b,c,f , David T. Limmer a,c,d,e , and Graham R. Fleming a,b,c, Abstract Photosystem II (PSII) can achieve near-unity quantum efficiency of light harvesting in ideal conditions and can dissipate excess light energy as heat to prevent formation of reactive oxygen species under light stress. Understanding how this pigment-protein complex accomplishes these opposing goals is a topic of great interest that has so far been explored primarily through the lens of the system energetics. Despite PSII’s known flat energy landscape, a thorough consideration of the entropic effects on energy transfer in PSII is lacking. In this work, we aim to discern the free energetic design principles underlying the PSII energy transfer network. To accomplish this goal, we employ a structure-based rate matrix and compute the free energy terms in time following a specific initial excitation to discern how entropy and enthalpy drive ensemble system dynamics. We find that the interplay between the entropy and enthalpy components differs among each protein subunit, which allows each subunit to fulfill a unique role in the energy transfer network. This individuality ensures PSII can accomplish efficient energy trapping in the RC, effective NPQ in the periphery, and robust energy trapping in the other-monomer RC if the same-monomer RC is closed. We also show that entropy, in particular, is a dynamically tunable feature of the PSII free energy landscape accomplished through regulation of LHCII binding. These findings help rationalize natural photosynthesis and provide design principles for novel, more efficient solar energy harvesting technologies. I Introduction Photosystem II of land plants and other oxygenic photosynthetic organisms possesses the unique ability to split water and generate molecular oxygen. The reaction center (RC), where charge separation is initiated, is coupled to an antenna containing several hundred chlorophyll (Chl) molecules to optimize photosynthetic yield in varying light levels. This pigment-protein supercomplex can convert harvested light energy into a charge separation with near perfect quantum efficiency Blankenship 2022 ; Wientjes et al. 2013 ; Van Mieghem et al. 1995 . In light stress conditions, Photosystem II (PSII) is able to dissipate excess light energy as heat to prevent the formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) via reaction of molecular oxygen with the chlorophyll triplet excited state M”uller et al. 2001 ; Durrant et al. 1990 ; Krieger-Liszkay 2004 . Many of the photoprotective capabilities are hypothesized to take place in the periphery of PSII because of the high oxidative potential of the RC components Ruban 2016 ; Ishikita et al. 2005 ; Genty et al. 1989 ; Ruban and Wilson 2021 , which limits the ability to place photoprotective molecules close to the RC. In this study, we explore how entropic driving forces facilitate these opposing design requirements of PSII. Perhaps the most intuitive design for an antenna/reaction center system is that of an energy funnel with the reaction center located at the energy minimum. Indeed this is precisely the approach adapted by the purple bacterial B800/B850/RC system, for example Blankenship 2022 ; Mirkovic et al. 2017 . PSII, however, has a multi-subunit construction with the lowest energy levels of all the subunits having very similar energies1 (Figure S1). This has led to descriptions of the PSII antenna system as a flat landscape Yang et al. 2024 ; Leonardo et al. 2024 , as a very shallow funnel Jennings et al. 1993a ; Jennings et al. 1993b , or as lacking a funnel Bennett et al. 2013 ; Shibata et al. 2013 ; Croce and Van Amerongen 2014 . This, in turn, raises the question of the driving force for energy transfer to the RC and the potential role of entropic in addition to enthalpic contributions. The availability of high-resolution structures for the 204 Chl-containing C 2 S 2 -type and 312 Chl C 2 S 2 M 2 -type dimeric supercomplexes Wei et al. 2016 ; Su et al. 2017 , along with quantitative models for the excitation dynamics for both structures Yang et al. 2024 ; Leonardo et al. 2024 , allows us to explore the free energy landscape of the supercomplexes. Here, we use these dynamical models to study the stochastic thermodynamics accompanying photorelaxation and quantify the time-dependent changes to both the energy and entropy. These ensemble-level calculations give insight into the evolution of the initial exciton and we find that, qualitatively, the ensemble evolution can be thought of in two phases. First, an entropic exploration of the landscape distributes population amongst the chromophores with similar energies. Second, a more directed motion takes population down the shallow energy gradient toward the reaction center. We also show that when one of the two RCs is closed through prior excitation, the entropic phase on the side of the dimeric structure with a closed RC is elongated, allowing more time for the excitation to find the second, open, reaction center. We also show how the entropy component of the free energy landscape is a tunable parameter, which PSII can alter by regulating the binding of peripheral antenna complexes Ballottari et al. 2012 ; Boekema et al. 1999a ; Boekema et al. 1999b ; Caffarri et al. 2009 ; Crepin and Caffarri 2018 ; Dekker and Boekema 2005 . These calculations provide insight into how the design of the PSII supercomplex enables the combination of both efficient charge separation and effective photoprotection, and how these design principles can be applied to the construction and characterization of general energy harvesting systems. Figure 1: The pigment arrangement of the C 2 S 2 M 2 PSII supercomplex with protein subunits labeled (PDB: 5XNL) Su et al. 2017 . The solid line marks the separation of the two monomers. II Methods II.1 Rate Matrix Construction We employ a structure-based quantum dynamical rate matrix K , where element k_{ij} describes the energy transfer rate from exciton state j to state i in units of [ps -1 ]. The rate matrix for the C 2 S 2 M 2 PSII supercomplex was constructed from the 5XNL structure of Pisum sativum Su et al. 2017 (Figure 1) and the C 2 S 2 rate matrix was constructed from the 3JCU structure of Spinacia oleracea Wei et al. 2016 (Figure S2), as well as from available Hamiltonians for the protein subunits Raszewski and Renger 2008 ; Raszewski et al. 2005 ; Müh et al. 2012 ; Mascoli et al. 2020 ; Novoderezhkin et al. 2011 . The rates were quantified by organizing the Chl molecules into domains based on coulombic coupling strength and degree of exciton delocalization, then applying Modified Redfield Theory for intra-domain transfer and Generalized Forster Theory for inter-domain transfer Bennett et al. 2013 ; Yang and Fleming 2002 (see SI). Based on the inhomogeneous broadening widths reported in the literature, a random number is added to the site energy of each chlorophyll and 500 sets of site energies are generated to construct 500 rate matrices. The calculation of entropy is based on the averaged rate matrix from these 500 realizations. The rates satisfy detailed balance with respect to a Boltzmann distribution of each excitonic state, which allows for its thermodynamic interpretation Limmer 2024 . Unless otherwise