Creating Pileups of Eccentric Planet Pairs Wide of MMRs Through Divergent Migration

Jessica Lin, Ivan Dudiak, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo · 2024

Read Creating Pileups of Eccentric Planet Pairs Wide of MMRs Through Divergent Migration by Jessica Lin, Ivan Dudiak, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-12415.txt.

Introduction

Jessica Lin and co-authors explain how pairs of planets can end up parked just wide of a neat orbital rhythm, in a 2024 paper. Surveys find many pairs with period ratios a bit above strong resonances. Older models needed slow loss of orbital stretch, but that clashes with the stretch seen in timing data.

The authors argue that any slow drift apart will do the job. As a pair meets a resonance while drifting, it jumps past it and gains free stretch in its orbits. Those jumps are often large enough, or too large, to match what is seen. The paper suggests that non-slow crossings or some leftover damping can bring the model in line with the data.

Catalog record

CREATORJessica Lin, Ivan Dudiak, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-12415

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Creating Pileups of Eccentric Planet Pairs Wide of MMRs Through Divergent Migration Jessica Lin, Ivan Dudiak, Samuel Hadden, Daniel Tamayo Abstract Observed pileups of planets with period ratios ≈ 1 % \approx 1\% wide of strong mean motion resonances (MMRs) pose an important puzzle. Early models showed that they can be created through sustained eccentricity damping driving a slow separation of the orbits, but this picture is inconsistent with elevated eccentricities measured through Transit Timing Variations. We argue that any source of divergent migration (tides, planet-disk interactions etc.) will cause planets that encounter an MMR to both jump over it (piling up wide of resonance) and get a kick to their free eccentricity. We find that the jumps in eccentricity expected from slow MMR crossings are sufficient (but mostly too large) to explain the free eccentricities measured through TTVs. We argue that this mechanism can be brought in line with observations if MMR crossings are not adiabatic and/or through residual eccentricity damping. I Introduction Whether protoplanets grow primarily through the accretion of planetesimals [ 21 , e.g.,] or through pebble accretion [ 19 , see review by] , planet formation theory typically converges on a final phase of giant impacts and gravitational scatterings that sets the final masses and orbital configurations of the exoplanets we observe today [ 7 , 17 , 18 , 32 , e.g.,] . [ 36 ] proposed that if this phase is sufficiently chaotic, memory of initial conditions should be lost, and the phase space of possible orbital configurations that are dynamically stable should be approximately uniformly filled. This explains the roughly uniform distribution of period ratios observed between adjacent planet-pairs (Fig. 1 , corresponding to effectively random separations between neighboring bodies. Two exceptions are at the closest separations (period ratios \lesssim 1.5 ), where dynamical instabilities have likely eliminated planet-pairs and significantly carved out the distribution (Chen et al., submitted ), as well as the pileups of planet-pairs wide of integer ratios corresponding to strong mean motion resonances (MMRs), which were first noted by [ 24 ] ; Fabrycky et al. 5 and have been a point of research interest. Figure 1: The distribution of period ratios between adjacent planets in the NASA Exoplanet Archive. Dash-dotted lines at strong MMRs are labeled with their corresponding integer ratio. An early explanation for these pileups was through an external source of eccentricity damping, which [ 25 ] and [ 1 ] showed would naturally cause the orbits of planet pairs in or near MMRs to diverge and move toward period ratios wide of resonance. While plausible physical mechanisms [ 27 , e.g., obliquity tides] have been identified that could provide the significant eccentricity damping that would be required to create the observed period ratio pileups [ 25 , 1 ] , such models would also predict that eccentricities would be strongly damped to their equilibrium values. However, precise measurements of free eccentricities (i.e., deviations from equilibrium eccentricities) extracted from transit-timing variations (TTVs) have revealed values of \approx 0.01-0.02 for planet pairs near MMRs [ 26 , 11 , 13 ] , contradicting the eccentricity damping theory [ 3 , 38 ] . Other mechanisms (that we return to later in the paper) include the idea that MMR widths grow as planets accrete mass, so that the edge (separatrix) of an MMR could reach a planet pair narrow of resonance and force it to jump across wide of resonance [ 29 ] , or that non-resonant third planets could be responsible for the non-zero eccentricities [ 3 ] . In this paper, we instead investigate the consequences of a simpler picture where the entire population of close-in planets experience divergent migration, rather than just the near-resonant planets. This can arise when planets migrate in opposite directions through planetesimal scattering [ 2 , 38 ] , but also when the inner planet migrates inward more than the outer planet, e.g., through tides [ 26 ] or atmospheric mass loss [ 15 ] . [ 26 ] argue that such a migration mechanism affecting the whole population can not work, since an initially uniform distribution of period ratios in Fig. 1 where all planet pairs moved rightward by a comparable amount will still remain approximately uniform and would create neither troughs nor peaks. However, as pointed out by the same authors [ 38 ] , this argument misses the fact that for a pair of planets migrating further apart from one another (divergently), capture into resonance at integer ratios is impossible [ 28 , e.g,] , so the period ratio is forced to jump across the width of the MMR, potentially creating the observed pileups wide of integer ratios. It could also naturally explain the excited eccentricities of planet pairs in the period ratio pileups, since jumps across MMRs due to divergent migration also naturally provide kicks to the orbital eccentricities [ 28 , 38 ] . The size of these eccentricity kicks, as well as the widths of MMRs depend on both planets’ masses and orbital eccentricities, which complicates quantitative tests across a small number of observations. In this paper, we use the analytical MMR model of [ 9 ] to non-dimensionalize the eccentricities and period ratio deviations from resonance. This puts systems with different masses on the same footing, and facilitates both visualization and hypothesis testing. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we define dynamical variables and introduce our dataset. In Sec. III we introduce our model and our normalization of observables. In Sec. IV , we present our results and discuss mechanisms that could modify the predicted distribution. Finally, we conclude in Sec. V . II Transit Timing Variation (TTV) Data II.1 Dynamical Variables In our investigation, we use the masses and eccentricities derived from a uniform TTV analysis for 33 pairs of planets analyzed by [ 13 ] . TTV measurements constrain a particular linear combination of the pair of planets’ orbital eccentricities called the free eccentricity [ 26 ] . For pairs of planets that are not in resonance (the majority), the contribution to the eccentricity that is forced by the resonance is negligible, and the free eccentricity \mathcal{Z} is approximately given by a linear combination of the planets’ complex eccentricities z_{i}\equiv e_{i}\mathrm{e}^{i\varpi_{i}} , which have a magnitude given by their respective orbital eccentricity e_{i} and point toward their respective pericenter \varpi_{i} [ 26 ] \mathcal{Z}=\frac{fz_{1}+gz_{2}}{\sqrt{f^{2}+g^{2}}}\approx\frac{z_{2}-z_{1}}{\sqrt{2}}. (1) The f and g coefficients are specific to each MMR 1 1 1 In the notation of Hadden & Tamayo [14] , f and g are are the disturbing function coefficients f=C^{(0,0,0,0)}_{(j,1-j,-1,0,0,0)}(\alpha) and g=C^{(0,0,0,0)}_{(j,1-j,0,-1,0,0)}(\alpha) , evaluated at the resonant semi-major axis ratio \alpha=\left(\frac{j-1}{j}\right)^{2/3} . In our calculations, we use the celmech code [ 14 ] to evaluate the exact values of f and g . 2 2 2 For closely spaced MMRs (period ratio \lesssim 2:1 , the f and g coefficients are approximately equal and opposite, so the free eccentricity is approximately proportional to the relative eccentricity vector z_{2}-z_{1} [ 33 , for a pedagogical explanation of why this is the physically relevant combination of eccentricity vectors see Sec. 7.1 of] ; for the 2:1 MMR f and g coefficients differ significantly

Read the complete text