Characterizing the Networks Sending Enterprise Phishing Emails
Elisa Luo, Liane Young, Grant Ho, M. H. Afifi, Marco Schweighauser, Ethan Katz-Bassett, Asaf Cidon · 2024
Read Characterizing the Networks Sending Enterprise Phishing Emails by Elisa Luo, Liane Young, Grant Ho, M. H. Afifi, Marco Schweighauser, Ethan Katz-Bassett, Asaf Cidon (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-12403.txt.
Introduction
Elisa Luo and co-authors map the networks that deliver phishing email into real companies. Their paper appeared in 2024. The data cover a year, thousands of enterprises, billions of messages, and over 800,000 phishing mails that got through. The surprise: more than a third of the phishing came from highly reputable networks, including Amazon and Microsoft, month after month, even though nearly all their traffic is benign.
Another large share came from networks whose traffic is mostly phishing but erratic over time. That mix explains why simple blocklists fail: blocking the reputable giants is impossible, and the dirty networks churn too fast. The authors say defenses must weigh reputation and behavior together, not rely on static lists.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Elisa Luo, Liane Young, Grant Ho, M. H. Afifi, Marco Schweighauser, Ethan Katz-Bassett, Asaf Cidon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-12403
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Characterizing the Networks Sending Enterprise Phishing Emails Elisa Luo, Liane Young, Grant Ho, M. H. Afifi, Marco Schweighauser, Ethan Katz-Bassett, Asaf Cidon Abstract Phishing attacks on enterprise employees present one of the most costly and potent threats to organizations. We explore an understudied facet of enterprise phishing attacks: the email relay infrastructure behind successfully delivered phishing emails. We draw on a dataset spanning one year across thousands of enterprises, billions of emails, and over 800,000 delivered phishing attacks. Our work sheds light on the network origins of phishing emails received by real-world enterprises, differences in email traffic we observe from networks sending phishing emails, and how these characteristics change over time. Surprisingly, we find that over one-third of the phishing email in our dataset originates from highly reputable networks, including Amazon and Microsoft. Their total volume of phishing email is consistently high across multiple months in our dataset, even though the overwhelming majority of email sent by these networks is benign. In contrast, we observe that a large portion of phishing emails originate from networks where the vast majority of emails they send are phishing, but their email traffic is not consistent over time. Taken together, our results explain why no singular defense strategy, such as static blocklists (which are commonly used in email security filters deployed by organizations in our dataset), is effective at blocking enterprise phishing. Based on our offline analysis, we partnered with a large email security company to deploy a classifier that uses dynamically updated network-based features. In a production environment over a period of 4.5 months, our new detector was able to identify 3-5% more enterprise email attacks that were previously undetected by the company’s existing classifiers. 1 Introduction Phishing attacks remain one of the most costly threats to enterprises, resulting in billions of dollars in losses [ 11 ] , disrupting critical infrastructure [ 5 ] , and imperiling national security [ 35 , 51 ] . Although a substantial body of research has proposed various countermeasures [ 46 , 44 , 49 , 1 , 21 , 28 ] , the continued and widespread success of phishing illustrates the need for better defenses. Prior work on spam and mass phishing campaigns have proposed simple blocklists as a defense [ 46 , 38 , 17 ] , with an implicit premise that phishing emails will emanate from stable and predominantly malicious servers. In practice, many organizations do use IP address-based blocklists, including many of the ones in our email dataset ( section 3.3 ). However, these methods have limited efficacy against enterprise phishing; in our dataset alone, they fail to block hundreds of thousands of phishing emails. This limitation arises because blocklists often grow stale and can suffer from slow updating delays as they tend to rely on user reports [ 48 ] . Given the evolving web and cloud landscape – where IP addresses and servers frequently change ownership, host multiple independent tenants in parallel, and/or host legitimate services that have been compromised by attackers – the efficacy of such methods against modern enterprise phishing remains unclear. Our work seeks to better understand the network characteristics of modern enterprise phishing attacks, with the aim of identifying more nuanced and effective defenses that go beyond static blocklisting. Performing this analysis, which explores and characterizes the email infrastructure responsible for routing phishing emails, requires a large-scale dataset of both phishing and clean emails from many enterprises. Although some studies have involved large corpora of phishing emails [ 18 , 7 , 49 ] , they focus on the content in email messages, the infrastructure used to host phishing websites , or involve attacks targeted primarily at consumers (as opposed to enterprise organizations), leaving questions about the email delivery infrastructure unexplored. To this end, we present the first large-scale study of the email delivery infrastructure used for enterprise phishing emails. This paper involves a collaboration between academic researchers and Barracuda Networks, a large email security provider. We analyze the email delivery path information (from the email headers) across emails received by thousands of organizations. Our dataset consists of over 800,000 successfully delivered phishing emails and 4 billion non-phishing emails, across three different months (Jan 2020, Oct 2020, and Jan 2021). Importantly, the emails captured in our dataset have not been already blocked by any pre-filtering services (e.g., Mimecast, Proofpoint) that organizations may employ, providing a representative view of real-world enterprise inboxes. Using this data, our paper investigates the following questions: 1. What networks do enterprise phishing emails originate from? 2. How does the email delivery infrastructure used in enterprise phishing attacks evolve over time? 3. Can we use the delivery origin of an email to improve phishing detection? Our analysis reveals several insights relevant to designing defenses. First, networks can be categorized by how much email sent from their servers is benign vs. phishing (§ 4.1 ). On one end of the spectrum, the infrastructure of several prominent hosting companies (including Microsoft Azure and Amazon AWS) send a large volume of phishing emails, even though the vast majority of their outbound email is benign. These “low-phishing-concentration" networks remain stable throughout the three months in our data. On the other hand, a small number of IP addresses and networks send a large amount of phishing emails and only a small volume of benign emails. In contrast, this set of “high-phishing-concentration” networks is not stable over time (§ 4.3 ), suggesting that some subset of attackers actively switch to different networks to evade detection. We apply the results of our empirical analysis in Barracuda’s production environment, where we monitor the rate and proportion of phishing emails coming from each network in an online fashion and demonstrate that we can use these dynamically updated features to detect previously undetected phishing attacks with a low false positive rate ( section 6 ). Ultimately, the analysis and experiment results from our work suggest that we can better combat modern enterprise phishing by targeting the email delivery infrastructure they abuse through a diverse set of technical and policy-based defenses. 2 Background Our paper studies the network characteristics of phishing emails received by enterprises. We focus on emails sent from outside the recipient’s organization, and make no assumptions about the kind of infrastructure or tools used by the attacker (e.g., the emails might come from a compromised external account or reflect spoofing from an attacker-controlled server). Below, we review the key networking-related information contained within email headers and provide an overview of related work. Figure 1 : Example of email delivery with multiple mail servers. Barracuda collects and analyzes emails from the recipient’s mail servers. 2.1 Email Headers In addition to their message content, emails contain a set of headers specified by the Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP). When Alice sends an email, her mail client attaches envelope headers that specify the recipients’ email addresses ( RCPT TO ) and a return address for the sender ( MAIL FROM ). The email also contains human-readable headers that a recipient’s email client will display as the email’s sender and recipient ( FROM and TO headers respectively). For each recipient, a copy of Alice’s email will get routed through a series of mail servers (relays)