A New Method to Derive an Empirical Lower Limit on the Mass Density of a UFO
Abraham Loeb · 2024
Read A New Method to Derive an Empirical Lower Limit on the Mass Density of a UFO by Abraham Loeb (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-12142.txt.
Introduction
Abraham Loeb wrote this paper in two thousand twenty-four as the sole author. It gives a fresh way to bound the mass density of an unidentified flying object from things a sensor can in fact measure.
The bound uses the object's speed and acceleration, plus the infrared glow of the air around it. If the speed toward or away from the viewer can be set aside, the mass bound does not rest on the distance at all. With the distance and angular size known, a floor on the density itself falls out. The Galileo Project plans to gather just this data on vast counts of sky objects in the year ahead.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abraham Loeb |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 5 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-12142
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A New Method to Derive an Empirical Lower Limit on the Mass Density of a UFO
Abraham Loeb
Abstract
I derive a lower limit on the mass of an Unidentified Flying Object (UFO) based on measurements of its speed and acceleration, as well as the infrared luminosity of the airglow around it. If the object’s radial velocity can be neglected, the mass limit is independent of distance. Measuring the distance and angular size of the object allows to infer its minimum mass density. The Galileo Project will be collecting the necessary data on millions of objects in the sky over the coming year.
I
Introduction
Any object moving through air radiates excess heat in the form of
infrared airglow luminosity,
L
. The airglow luminosity is a fraction
of the total power dissipated by the object’s speed,
v
, times the
frictional force of air acting on the object. The radiative efficiency
depends on the specific shape of the object and the turbulence and
thermodynamic conditions in the atmosphere around it
(
Zel’dovich & Raizer 1967
)
. If the
object accelerates, then this friction force must be smaller than the
force provided by the engine which propels the object. The net
force equals the object’s mass,
M
, times its acceleration,
a
.
In conclusion, one gets an unavoidable lower limit on the mass of an
accelerating object. The object’s mass must be larger than the
infrared luminosity from heated air around it, divided by the product
of the object’s acceleration and speed. In other words:
M>{L\over|v\times a|}~~.
(1)
This limit provides an elegant way to constrain the minimum mass of
Unidentified Flying Objects (UFOs), also labeled as Unidentified
Anomalous Phenomena (UAPs; see
Watters et al. 2023
for an overview). To
turn the inequality into an equality, one needs to know the detailed
object shape and atmospheric conditions around the
object.
The first
Galileo Project
Observatory at Harvard
University
(
Loeb & Laukien 2023
)
collects data on
\sim 10^{5}
objects in the sky
every month. A comprehensive description of its commissioning data on
\sim 5\times 10^{5}
objects was provided in a recent
paper
(
Dominé et al. 2024
)
. The data includes infrared images captured by an
all-sky
Dalek
array of eight uncooled infrared cameras placed on
half a sphere
(
Loeb & Laukien 2023
;
Watters et al. 2023
)
.
II
Method
Within the coming month, the
Galileo Project
’s research team plans to
employ multiple
Dalek
s separated by a few miles, in order to measure
distances to objects through the method of triangulation.
The heated air’s infrared flux,
f
, and distance,
R
, can
be combined to infer the luminosity,
L
, through the relation:
L=4\pi fR^{2}~~.
(2)
The angular velocity,
(d\theta/dt)
, times the distance,
R
, provides
the transverse component of the full velocity vector,
{\bf v}
, which can
be combined with the time derivative of the distance,
(dR/dt)
, to get
the total speed,
v=\left\{\left[R\left({d\theta\over dt}\right)\right]^{2}+\left({dR\over dt}\right)^{2}\right\}^{1/2}~~.
(3)
The time derivative of the velocity vector provides the acceleration
vector,
{\bf a}=(d{\bf v}/dt)
.
Remarkably, in the special case where the radial speed is negligible,
|dR/dt|\ll R|d\theta/dt|
, I find that the lower
limit on the object’s mass is independent of distance,
M>{4\pi f\over|({d\theta/dt})\times(d^{2}\theta/dt^{2})|}~~.
(4)
The physical size of the object can be derived as the product of its
angular size times its distance,
(\Delta\theta)R
. The minimum mass
could then be used to derive the minimum mass per unit volume, or mass
density
\rho
, of the object.
III
Discussion
If the measured velocity and acceleration of a technological object
are outside the flight characteristics and performance envelopes of
drones or airplanes, then the object would be classified by the
Galileo Project
’s research team as an outlier. In such a case, it
would be interesting to calculate the minimum mass density of the
object. If the result exceeds normal solid densities, then the object
would qualify as anomalous, a UAP. Infrared emission by the object
would be a source of confusion, unless the object is resolved and the
emission from it can be separated from the heated air around it.
All flying objects made by humans have a volume-averaged mass density
\langle\rho\rangle
which is orders of magnitude below
22.6~{\rm g~cm^{-3}}
, the density of Osmium - which is the densest metal
known on Earth. A UFO with a higher mass density than Osmium would
have to carry exotic material, not found on Earth.
By summer 2025, there will be three
Galileo Project
observatories operating in three different states within the U.S. and
collecting data on a few million objects per year. With new
quantitative data on infrared luminosities, velocities and
accelerations of technological objects, it would be possible to check