Superradiant Neutrino Lasers from Radioactive Condensates
B.J.P. Jones, J. A. Formaggio · 2024
Read Superradiant Neutrino Lasers from Radioactive Condensates by B.J.P. Jones, J. A. Formaggio (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-11765.txt.
Introduction
Jones and Formaggio proposed a neutrino laser built on superradiance in 2024. Superradiance is a burst of emission from a group of atoms that act together, far stronger than single atoms could give. It is known for light; the authors ask whether a like effect can work for neutrinos, which are fermions.
Their concept uses a Bose-Einstein condensate of a radioactive isotope that captures electrons. In a condensate of about a million such atoms, the effective decay time could shrink from about eighty-six days to minutes. That speed-up comes from correlations in the decay medium, not from stimulated emission as in a normal laser. The paper lays out the idea as a basis for a future device.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | B.J.P. Jones, J. A. Formaggio |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-11765
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Superradiant Neutrino Lasers from Radioactive Condensates B.J.P. Jones, J. A. Formaggio Abstract Superradiance emerges from collective spontaneous emission in optically pumped gases, and is characterized by photon emission enhancements of up to 1 4 N 2 \frac{1}{4}N^{2} in an N N atom system. The gain mechanism derives from correlations developed within the decay medium rather than from stimulated emission as in lasing, so an analog of this process should be possible for fermionic final states. We introduce here the concept of superradiant neutrino emission from a radioactive Bose Einstein condensate, which can form the basis for a superradiant neutrino laser. A plausible experimental realization based on a condensate of electron-capture isotope 83 Rb could exhibit effective radioactive decay rates accelerated from 82 days to minutes in viably sized rubidium condensates of 10 6 10^{6} atoms. Many analogies exist between neutrino physics and optics, because the neutrino is a nearly massless particle whose feeble environmental interactions permit coherent quantum effects. The interferences between neutrino mass states with different de Brogile wavelengths (oscillations), for example, have a direct optical analog in the propagation and recombination of differently polarized photons through birefringent media weinheimer2010neutrino . Optical analogies to the MSW effect kuo1989neutrino and neutrino matter resonances mikheyev1989resonant can be readily concocted. And, the basic physics governing neutrino production and detection was originally inferred by Fermi through analogy to quantum electrodynamics wilson1968fermi . There are also several identified effects in neutrino physics whereby coherent quantum enhancements emerge from multi-particle behavior. Within the high neutrino density of supernovae, entanglement through elastic scattering is expected to lead to collective neutrino oscillations duan2010collective ; and the large cross-section enhancement associated with coherent elastic neutrino nucleus scattering akimov2017observation is a result of in-phase summation of scattering amplitudes from many nucleons. Some optical phenomena do not have straightfoward analogies in neutrino physics, one example being lasing. Lasers rely on coherent amplification by stimulated emission (SE), only admissible for bosons. While stimulation of neutrino pairs by photons is possible, and has been invoked as a way to measure the mass of the neutrino song2016conditions ; zhang2016improved ; yoshimura2014radiative ; yoshimura2007neutrino ; ge2023unique , their laser amplification is prohibited because the allowed occupancy of any fermionic mode is limited to zero or one. A different coherent amplification effect that has been observed with photons is superradiance (SR) rehler1971superradiance . Originally proposed by Dicke dicke1954coherence , in SR the collective spontaneous emission of many atoms separated by less than one wavelength of light contribute coherently to enhance the radiative decay rates. Following the first observation in optically pumped HF gas skribanowitz1973observation , SR has also been observed in several other contexts. Unlike in lasing, whereby each photon reinteracts with another atom in a cavity to induce SE, derivations of SR stipulate that “any photon, once produced, escapes from the active volume so fast that it does not have a chance to feed itself back into atomic excitation” bonifacio1971quantum . Devices exploiting SR as their primary optical gain mechanism have been realized haake1993superradiant ; weiner2017phase , and dubbed “superradiant lasers” (admittedly a misnomer, given the absence of SE in these devices). Ref. bohnet2012steady operates such a device with \leq 1 photon in the cavity at a time, a strong demonstration that SE is not involved. SR lasers store optical coherence and phase correlations in the gain medium rather than the electromagnetic field, and enhancement occurs through collective spontaneous emission akkermans2008photon ; bonifacio1971quantum ; gross1982superradiance ; haake1993superradiant ; rehler1971superradiance ; schuurmans1982superfluorescence . This mechanism does not rely intrinsically on the bosonic nature of light and so should also be admissible for fermions. In this Letter we discuss application of SR to produce coherent, amplified neutrino sources. Decays by electron capture (EC) provide a particularly close analogy to the model two-state systems previously invoked in discussions of SR dicke1954coherence ; gross1982superradiance . SR \beta decay also appears to be viable, with cold atomic T being one possible candidate isotope. Finally, the superradiant state also exhibits amplified neutrino interaction rates through enhanced collective neutrino absorption. One challenge for realizing SR with neutrinos is that the lowest energy detectable neutrinos are produced in \beta or EC decays with energies of at least a few keV. A requirement for ordinary SR is that the atom originating any photon (neutrino) should not be distinguishable based measurements that can be made upon that photon (neutrino), typically interpreted as a statement that the emitters must be closer together than the DeBrogile wavelength \lambda . This is one way to achieve such indiscernibility, but there are others. For example, if all initial atoms are prepared in an identical spatial wave function, as in a Bose Einstein Condensate (BEC) griffin1996bose ; pethick2008bose ; schneble2003onset , coherent spontaneous radioactive emission of the daughter particles should also be enabled. This is a proposed method for formation of a gamma ray laser avetissian2014self , and related forms of collective emission from a BEC have been discussed as mechanisms to achieve implementations based on trapped positronium- avetissian2015gamma gamma-decaying nuclear isomers marmugi2018coherent . Here we investigate the applicability of SR from a BEC to coherently amplified neutrino production. I Enhancement Mechanism The phenomenon of Dicke SR rehler1971superradiance or superfluorescence schuurmans1982superfluorescence occurs through the accumulation of quantum correlations between decayed and undecayed atoms in an ensemble. Consider a collection of N identical two-level atoms with upper and lower states labeled |g_{i}\rangle and |e_{i}\rangle . We can define raising and lowering operators for atom i , as well as the D_{i}^{3} operator, \displaystyle D_{i}^{+} \displaystyle= \displaystyle|e_{i}\rangle\langle g_{i}|.\quad D_{i}^{-}=|g_{i}\rangle\langle e_{i}|, (1) \displaystyle D_{i}^{3} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{1}{2}\left[|e_{i}\rangle\langle e_{i}|-|g_{i}\rangle\langle g_{i}|\right], (2) The D operators have commutation rules, [D_{i}^{3},D_{j}^{\pm}]=\pm\delta_{ij}D_{i}^{\pm},\quad[D_{i}^{+},D_{j}^{-}]=2\delta_{ij}D_{i}^{3}, (3) and the rate of decay to a photon is driven by interaction Hamiltonian H_{int} , which under the rotating wave approximation (RWA) is, H_{int,i}=-id_{a}E_{l}(D_{i}^{+}\hat{a_{l}}+D_{i}^{-}\hat{a_{l}}^{\dagger}). (4) E_{l} is the electric field strength associated with one photon and d_{a}=\langle e|\hat{x}|g\rangle is the dipole matrix element that controls the rate of optical transitions. In a sufficiently optically pumped gas we can consider the initial state to be fully excited, |\psi(0)\rangle=|e_{1}e_{2}...e_{N}\rangle . Despite all atoms being in |e\rangle we emphasize that this is not a BEC, since we are labeling only the excitation level of each atom; each also posses a position-space wave function, which for traditional SR can be assumed to be distinct and non-overlapping. The simplest SR condition is that all atoms are motionless and contained in a small volume compared to the transition wavelength \lambda=hc/(E_{e}-E_{g}) . In this case we can express the full interaction Hamiltonian as H_{int}=\sum_{i}H_{int,i}=-id_{a}E_{l}(D^{+}\hat{a_{l}}+D^{-}\hat{a_{l}}^{\dagger}), (5) where we have identified the “D-spin” of the entire system D\equiv\sum_{i}D_{i} . The eigenstates of D are constructed by analogy to coupling many spin-1/2 angular momenta. The largest J -plet is comprised of N states with quantum number M ranging between \pm\frac{1}{2}N , obtained via the lowering operation on |\psi(0)\rangle |JM\rangle=\sqrt{\frac{\left(J+M\right)!}{N!(J-M)!}}\left(D^{-}\right)^{J-M}|eeee...e\rangle. (6) The |JM\rangle state has J+M atoms in |e\rangle and J-M atoms in |g\rangle , appropriately symmetrized. Photon emission is generated by the D^{-} in H_{int} , so each emission ladders downwards between elements of the same J -multiplet. The rate of emission W_{N} is found via Fermi’s golden rule, W_{N}\propto|\langle J,M-1|H_{int}|J,M\rangle|^{2}. (7) Only one final state has a non-zero amplitude given this initial one,