Geometric monotones of violations of quantum realism

Alexandre C. Orthey Jr, Alexander Streltsov · 2024

Read Geometric monotones of violations of quantum realism by Alexandre C. Orthey Jr, Alexander Streltsov (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-11633.txt.

Introduction

Alexandre Orthey and Alexander Streltsov extend the theory of quantum realism, an idea about when a measurement makes a property of a quantum system real. In that framework, a property can be real even if nobody reads the outcome, which separates quantum from classical ideas of reality. Earlier work measured violations of this realism with entropy-based distances.

The authors rebuild those measures using geometric distances between quantum states instead. They test several candidates, including trace, Bures, and Hellinger distances, against the basic rules a good measure must obey. Only the Bures and Hellinger versions pass every test. Geometry thus gives the young theory a firmer yardstick. The result helps sharpen debates about what quantum measurements really do.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexandre C. Orthey Jr, Alexander Streltsov
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-11633

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Geometric monotones of violations of quantum realism Alexandre C. Orthey Jr, Alexander Streltsov Abstract Quantum realism, as introduced by Bilobran and Angelo [EPL 112, 40005 (2015)], states that projective measurements in quantum systems establish the reality of physical properties, even in the absence of a revealed outcome. This framework provides a nuanced perspective on the distinction between classical and quantum notions of realism, emphasizing the contextuality and complementarity inherent to quantum systems. While prior works have quantified violations of quantum realism (VQR) using measures based on entropic distances, here we extend the theoretical framework to geometric distances. Building on an informational approach, we derive geometric monotones of VQR using trace distance, Hilbert-Schmidt distance, Schatten p p -distances, Bures, and Hellinger distances. We identify Bures and Hellinger distances as uniquely satisfying all minimal criteria for a bona fide VQR monotone. Remarkably, these distances can be expressed in terms of symmetric Rényi and Sandwiched Rényi divergences, aligning geometric and entropic approaches. Our findings suggest that the realism-information relation implies a deep connection between geometric and entropic frameworks, with only those geometric distances expressible as entropic quantities qualifying as valid monotones of VQR. This work highlights the theoretical and practical advantages of geometric distances, particularly in contexts where computational simplicity or symmetry is important. I Introduction The concept of quantum realism of observables, as proposed by Bilobran and Angelo Bilobran and Angelo 2015 , can be summarized as follows. After the projective measurement of a physical property in a quantum system, we can assert that the property is now well-defined, i.e., it is real for the state of the system. Any subsequent projective measurement of the same property will yield the same outcome because the new measurement merely reveals a pre-existing state of affairs —or reality. This reasoning also holds for non-selective (or non-revealed) projective measurements. Even if the experimentalist is not present in the lab when the measurement occurs or forgets the result, the measurement still takes place, establishing the property as real. Thus, a projective measurement, even without a revealed outcome, serves as the mechanism by which realism emerges in a quantum system. Consider, for instance, the measurement of the observable \sigma_{z}={|{0}\rangle}{\langle{0}|}-{|{1}\rangle}{\langle{1}|} on the state {|{\psi}\rangle}=({|{0}\rangle}+{|{1}\rangle})/\sqrt{2} . After the measurement, the system’s state will collapse to either {|{0}\rangle} or {|{1}\rangle} . At this point, the realism (or reality) of \sigma_{z} is established, meaning that any subsequent measurement of \sigma_{z} will yield the same outcome. In the case of a non-selective measurement, however, the post-measurement state of the system would be the mixed state {|{0}\rangle}{\langle{0}|}+{|{1}\rangle}{\langle{1}|} . This mixed state indicates that the system is definitely in either {|{0}\rangle} or {|{1}\rangle} , but the observer lacks knowledge of which one. This lack of knowledge is subjective and classical—it reflects the observer’s ignorance rather than an intrinsic uncertainty in the quantum state, as is the case with superpositions. By contrast, the observable \sigma_{x} is real for the initial state {|{\psi}\rangle} because the state is an eigenstate of \sigma_{x} , with a well-defined eigenvalue. This highlights the fundamental difference between realism in quantum mechanics and classical realism. Classical realism assumes that every physical property of a system is well-defined at all times, independent of observation or the presence of an observer. In contrast, quantum realism recognizes that certain pairs of incompatible observables, such as \sigma_{x} and \sigma_{z} , cannot always be simultaneously well-defined. This limitation is intrinsic to the nature of quantum systems and reflects the contextuality and complementarity that are hallmarks of quantum theory. The situation changes dramatically when we consider bipartite systems. If Alice and Bob share a maximally entangled pair of spin- 1/2 particles, their local states are maximally mixed. Consequently, the spin observable for, say, Alice’s particle is locally an element of physical reality, as a non-selective measurement of the identity operator does not alter the state. However, when considering the global description of the pair, any local non-selective measurement perturbs the global state. This demonstrates that the state of the pair violates quantum realism for the observable associated with either particle. This phenomenon diverges sharply from the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) notion of elements of physical reality Einstein et al. 1935 , as applied to bipartite entangled states. According to EPR, local measurements should not influence the state of affairs at remote locations. A method to quantify violations of quantum realism (VQR) was proposed in Bilobran and Angelo 2015 , where the authors referred to VQR as irrealism . They introduced an entropic distance between the measured state and the original state as a means of quantification. These measures of VQR were largely explored in theoretical Dieguez and Angelo 2018 ; Rudnicki 2018 ; Orthey and Angelo 2019 ; Engelbert and Angelo 2020 ; Costa and Angelo 2020 ; Lustosa et al. 2020 ; Basso and Maziero 2021 ; Paiva et al. 2023 ; Engelbert and Angelo 2023 ; Caetano and Angelo 2024 and experimental Mancino et al. 2018 ; Dieguez et al. 2021 ; Chrysosthemos et al. 2023 ; Basso and Maziero 2022 ; Araújo et al. 2024 approaches. Building on the informational framework of Dieguez and Angelo 2018 and the experimental findings of Mancino et al. 2018 ; Dieguez et al. 2021 , Orthey and Angelo 2022 presented a set of physically motivated axioms for monotones and measures of VQR, where the later requires more conditions than the former. In their work, they define a notion of conditional quantum information—the complement of quantum conditional entropy—using general relative entropies, also called divergences. They further show how variations in conditional information can be used to derive expressions for VQR measures. Their argument relies on a realism-information relation : since non-selective projective measurements are responsible for the emergence of realism, the increase in conditional information about the system, as encoded in the environment, could serve as a monotone of VQR. This connection is formalized using the Stinespring dilation theorem Nielsen and Chuang 2010 . I.1 Contributions In this work, we extended the concept of conditional information based on relative entropies from Orthey and Angelo 2022 to geometric distances and successfully derived geometric monotones of VQR. Geometric distances, or simply distances , share properties with relative entropies, such as contraction under completely positive trace-preserving (CPTP) maps, invariance under unitary transformations, and joint convexity. Additionally, distances are inherently symmetric and satisfy the triangle inequality, making them advantageous in certain contexts. Moreover, some distances are computationally simpler to evaluate, offering a practical benefit over entropic measures. Although none of the distances we studied are additive, making them not good candidates for measures of VQR, some of them can still be classified as monotones of VQR. Among the distances we explore, we have trace distance, Hilbert-Schmidt distance Nielsen and Chuang 2010 , Schatten p -distances Bhatia 2013 ; Spehner et al. 2017 , and Bures Bures 1969 ; Spehner et al. 2017 and Hellinger Roga et al. 2016 ; Spehner et al. 2017 distances. We found out that, among these distances, Bures and Hellinger distances are the only candidates that satisfy all the minimal requirements for a bona-fide monotone of VQR. Trace distance, for instance, provides a quantifier that fails to identify VQR for some states. The Hilbert-Schmidt distance, on the other way, provides a quantifier of

Read the complete text