VAR models with an index structure: A survey with new results
Gianluca Cubadda · 2024
Read VAR models with an index structure: A survey with new results by Gianluca Cubadda (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-11278.txt.
Introduction
Gianluca Cubadda surveys models that join vector autoregression with an index structure for time series, in a 2024 paper. The model, first proposed in the early nineteen eighties, has gained ground recently. It links two popular approaches: autoregression and dynamic factor models.
On one side, it is an autoregression with a special reduced-rank structure. On the other, it identifies common components and common shocks much like a factor model. The survey covers extensions with individual dynamics, stochastic volatility, time-varying parameters, high dimensions, and cointegration. Cubadda also adds new insights and a novel model, with uses in economics and finance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Gianluca Cubadda |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-11278
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
VAR models with an index structure: A survey with new results Gianluca Cubadda Abstract The main aim of this paper is to review recent advances in the multivariate autoregressive index model [MAI], originally proposed by Reinsel, (1983) , and their applications to economic and financial time series. MAI has recently gained momentum because it can be seen as a link between two popular but distinct multivariate time series approaches: vector autoregressive modeling [VAR] and the dynamic factor model [DFM]. Indeed, on the one hand, the MAI is a VAR model with a peculiar reduced-rank structure; on the other hand, it allows for identification of common components and common shocks in a similar way as the DFM. The focus is on recent developments of the MAI, which include extending the original model with individual autoregressive structures, stochastic volatility, time-varying parameters, high-dimensionality, and cointegration. In addition, new insights on previous contributions and a novel model are also provided. Keywords: Multivariate autoregressive index models, vector autoregressive models, dynamic factor models, reduced-rank regression. Previous versions of this paper were presented at the Intermediate workshop on methodological and computational issues in large-scale time series models for economics and finance in Messina, the The Villa Mondragone time series symposium in honour of Marco Lippi in Monte Porzio Catone (Rome), and the 11 {}^{\text{th}} ICEEE in Palermo. The author thanks the participants for their helpful comments and suggestions. The usual disclaimers apply. The financial support of MUR under the 20223725WE (PRIN 2022) grant is gratefully acknowledged. 1 Introduction The Vector Auto-Regressive model [VAR] and the Dynamic Factor Model [DFM] are arguably among the most popular tools for analyzing economic and financial variables over time. Since the seminal contribution of Sims, (1980) , VARs have been theoretically extended and practically implemented to forecast, perform structural analysis, and detect comovements in multivariate time series. DFMs were introduced more recently ( Forni et al., (2000) , Forni and Lippi, (2001) , Stock and Watson, 2002a () , Stock and Watson, 2002b () , Bai and Ng, (2002) , and Bai, (2003) ), but rapidly contested the role of the workhorse in empirical macroeconomics. The main reason for the success of the DFM is two-fold. First, it allows handling a much larger number of variables than those that are generally employed in traditional small-scale VARs, thus potentially boosting forecasting accuracy and solving the informational deficiency problems that arise in structural analyses when the agent’s information set is richer than the econometrician’s information set (see, e.g., Forni and Gambetti, (2014) ). Second, DFM allows one to disentagle the shocks that drive the common components of several time series and recover the structural shocks from those common shocks. Hence, in structural DFMs, the number of shocks is smaller than the number of variables ( Forni et al., (2009) ), which is in line with dynamic stochastic general equilibrium models (see Fernández-Villaverde et al., (2016) and the references therein) and, more generally, with the standard macroeconomic view that a small number of shocks drives aggregate fluctuations. Efforts have recently been made to endow the VAR with the above-mentioned features of the DFM. On the one hand, shrinkage estimators have been proposed for medium-large VARs, both from a Bayesian perspective (e.g., Bańbura et al., (2010) , Koop, (2013) , and Carriero et al., (2015) ) and from a classical standpoint (e.g., Hsu et al., (2008) , Kock and Callot, (2015) , and Hecq et al., (2023) ). On the other hand, the Multivariate Autoregressive Index (MAI) model – originally proposed by Reinsel, (1983) as a convenient approach to dimension reduction in stationary VARs -- has recently gained renewed attention. 1 1 1 At the end of 2024, the annual citation rate of Reinsel, (1983) in Scopus has increased by about 54% in the last 9 years, with the majority of recent citations coming from econometric journals. . Late advances have shown that MAI and its variants allow for both forecasting variables and identifying shocks analogously to the DFM but without encountering some issues in model identification and statistical inference that characterize the latter, such as the requirement that the number of variables diverges at a given rate and the need of specific assumptions on both the correlation structure of the idiosyncratic components and the factor loadings (see, i.a. , Bai, (2003) , and Bai and Ng, (2006) ). Moreover, VARs with index structures have been shown to be able to accommodate features such as stochastic volatility ( Carriero et al., (2022) ) and time-varying parameters ( Cubadda et al., (2025) ), which are not easy to handle within the DFM framework. The MAI falls within reduced-rank VARs, a general class of models that include as special cases both the cointegrated VAR (see Johansen, (1995) and the references therin) and the Common Serial Correlation [CSC] models (see Cubadda and Hecq, 2022b () and the references therin). Although CSC models and MAI have similar mathematical formulations, their respective goals and properties are rather different; whereas the former are based on the existence of (possibly dynamic) linear combinations of autocorrelated time series that are white noise ( Engle and Kozicki, (1993) , Vahid and Engle, (1993) , Cubadda, (2007) , Carriero et al., (2011) , Cubadda and Hecq, (2011) , Bernardini and Cubadda, (2015) ), VARs with an index structure assume that there is a limited number of channels through which information from the past is transmitted to the variables of interest. The main aim of this paper is twofold. First, recent developments in MAI are reviewed, such as the structural MAI ( Carriero et al., (2016) ), the vector heterogeneous index model for realized volatilities ( Cubadda et al., (2017) ), as well as augmentations of the original model with individual autoregressive structures ( Cubadda and Guardabascio, (2019) ), stochastic volatility ( Carriero et al., (2022) ), time-varying parameters ( Cubadda et al., (2025) ), high-dimensionality ( Cubadda and Hecq, 2022a () ), and cointegration ( Cubadda and Mazzali, (2024) ). Second, new results are provided in terms of representation theory for the various models, and a novel modeling is proposed, namely the cointegrated index-augmented autoregressive model, which combines and extends the results in Cubadda and Guardabascio, (2019) and Cubadda and Mazzali, (2024) . This paper is organized as follows. Focusing on representation theory, Section 2 reviews previous contributions and provides new insights into some of them. Section 3 presents the new model and deals with its estimation, whereas some details of the estimation procedure are relegated to the Appendix. Finally, Section 4 provides some conclusions. 2 VAR Models with an Index Structure In this Section we review the models that are rooted from the original MAI formulation and provide new results on representation theory of some of them. Analogies and differences with the DFM are discussed in detail. Estimation and identification issues are also covered. 2.1 The Stuctural Multivariate Autoregressive Index Model Let us assume that the n- vector time series Y_{t}=(y_{1t},...,y_{nt})^{{}^{\prime}} is generated by the following stationary VAR (p) model: \Phi(L)Y_{t}=\varepsilon_{t},\text{ \ \ }t=1...T, (1) where L is the lag operator, \Phi(L)= I_{n}-\sum_{j=1}^{p}\Phi_{j}L^{j} , and \varepsilon_{t} is a vector or n errors with \mathrm{E}(\varepsilon_{t}\varepsilon_{t}^{\prime})=\Sigma (positive definite) and finite fourth moments, \mathrm{E}(\varepsilon_{t}|\digamma_{t-1})=0 , and \digamma_{t} is