Symmetric instability in a Boussinesq fluid on a rotating planet

Yaoxuan Zeng, Malte F. Jansen · 2024

Read Symmetric instability in a Boussinesq fluid on a rotating planet by Yaoxuan Zeng, Malte F. Jansen (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-11027.txt.

Introduction

Yaoxuan Zeng and Malte F Jansen analyze a fluid instability that matters from Earth's weather to icy moon oceans. Their 2024 paper treats symmetric instability in a rotating, layered fluid on a spherical planet. It helps form rainbands, stirs the ocean surface layer, and may drive slanted convection inside gas giants and moon oceans.

Linear analysis splits the instability into three types: sinking from bad layering, spinning from momentum shear, and a mixed form flagged by a vorticity sign. A standard test used in ocean models, they show, is neither needed nor enough to catch it. A simpler condition on layering along the rotation axis does the job. In the limit that fits icy moon seas, the fastest mode is slanted convection along the axis, not along gravity. Convection schemes in global models need rework before facing those oceans.

Catalog record

CREATORYaoxuan Zeng, Malte F. Jansen
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE69 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-11027

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Symmetric instability in a Boussinesq fluid on a rotating planet Yaoxuan Zeng, Malte F. Jansen Abstract Symmetric instability has broad applications in geophysical and planetary fluid dynamics. It plays a crucial role in the formation of mesoscale rainbands at mid-latitudes on Earth, instability in the ocean’s mixed layer, and slantwise convection on gas giants and icy moon oceans. Here, we apply linear instability analysis to an arbitrary zonally symmetric Boussinesq flow on a rotating spherical planet, with applicability to icy moon oceans. We divide the instabilities into three types: (1) gravitational instability, occurring when stratification is unstable along angular momentum surfaces, (2) inertial instability, occurring when angular momentum shear is unstable along buoyancy surfaces, and (3) a mixed symmetric instability, occurring when neither of the previous conditions are fulfilled, but the potential vorticity has the opposite sign to planetary rotation. We note that N 2 < 0 N^{2}<0 where N N is the Brunt–Väisälä frequency—a typical criterion used to trigger convective adjustment in global ocean models—is neither necessary nor sufficient for instability. Instead, b z sin θ 0 < 0 b_{z}\sin{\theta_{0}}<0 , where b z b_{z} is the stratification along the planetary rotation axis and θ 0 \theta_{0} is the local latitude, is always sufficient for instability and also necessary in the low Rossby number limit. In this limit, relevant for deep convection in icy moon oceans, the most unstable mode is slantwise convection parallel to the planetary rotation axis. This slantwise convection differs from the parameterized convection in existing general circulation models, whose convection schemes parameterize convection in the direction of gravity. Our results suggest that convection schemes in global ocean models must be revised before being applied to icy moon oceans. † † journal: JGR: Planets † † corresponding: Yaoxuan Zeng, [email protected] keypoints Symmetric instability with arbitrary background shear and stratification is studied with linear instability analysis Three types of instability criteria are explored with theoretical analysis and numerical simulations In icy moon oceans with low Rossby number flows slantwise convection occurs if and only if stratification is unstable along rotation axis Plain Language Summary Flows on rotating planets can become unstable because of the combined effects of rotation and density stratification, a phenomenon known as symmetric instability. This instability shapes the flow patterns seen in planetary atmospheres and oceans. In our study, we use theoretical analysis and numerical simulations to study the instability criteria and the most unstable modes for axisymmetric flows on rotating planets. For flows strongly affected by rotation—typical of icy moon oceans—instability occurs if and only if the stratification is unstable along the rotation axis, leading to slantwise convection that aligns with the planetary rotation axis. This result is consistent with the rotation-aligned structures in global numerical simulations for the icy moon oceans. Additionally, it suggests that the traditional convection parameterization in ocean models, which only considers unstable stratification and heat transport in the direction of gravity, is not applicable for the icy moon oceans. 1 Introduction Symmetric instability describes the instability of axisymmetric flow. In an axisymmetric rotating fluid with background density stratification and angular momentum gradient, if a fluid parcel is perturbed from its origin, two restoring forces come into play: the buoyancy force and the inertial acceleration (Coriolis and centrifugal forces). These forces individually may result in gravitational instability or inertial instability. Moreover, even when the fluid is both gravitationally and inertially stable, the combined effects of the two force anomalies may result in symmetric instability ( Solberg, (1936) ; Høiland, (1941) ; Hoskins, (1974) ; Haine & Marshall, (1998) ) . Symmetric instability has broad applications in geophysical fluid dynamics. On Earth, it is relevant to the formation of mesoscale rainbands in the midlatitude atmosphere ( Emanuel, (1983) ; Emanuel, (1985) , e.g.,) and instability in the ocean’s mixed layer ( Straneo et al., (2002) ; Callies & Ferrari, (2018) , e.g., ) . Beyond Earth, symmetric instability is closely tied to slantwise convection in the atmospheres of gas giants ( Stone, (1967) ; Busse, (1970) ; Stone, (1971) ; Walton, (1975) ; O’Neill & Kaspi, (2016) , e.g.,) and in the oceans of their icy satellites ( Soderlund, (2019) ; Ashkenazy & Tziperman, (2021) ; Kang, Mittal et al., (2022) ; Bire et al., (2022) ; Zeng & Jansen, (2024) , e.g.,) , where convection is tilted along angular momentum surfaces. Symmetric instability is often studied under certain assumptions about the background field. In most literature, it is examined in inertially stable ( \eta/f>0 ) fluids with stable gravitational stratification ( N^{2}>0 ), where N^{2}=-(g/\rho)(\partial\rho/\partial R) , \eta=f-(1/R)(\partial u/\partial\theta) is the absolute vorticity, g is gravity, \rho is density, u is the zonal component of the velocity, f=2\Omega\sin{\theta} is the component of planetary rotation parallel to gravity, \theta\in(-\pi/2,\pi/2] is the latitude, R is the planetary radius, and \partial/\partial R denotes the derivative along the gravitational direction. Under these assumptions, instability occurs when the planetary vorticity has the opposite sign to the potential vorticity. In the Northern Hemisphere, symmetric instability arises when the potential vorticity, defined as q=\nabla b\cdot(2\mathbf{\Omega}+\nabla\times\mathbf{v}) , is negative, where \mathbf{\Omega} represents planetary rotation, \mathbf{v} is the three-dimensional (3-D) relative velocity in the rotating frame, and b is the buoyancy ( Eliassen, (1951) ; Ooyama, (1966) ; Hoskins, (1974) ; Stevens, (1983) ) . Although assuming N^{2}>0 is reasonable for most regions of Earth’s atmosphere and ocean, this condition may not hold on other planetary bodies such as icy moon oceans and gas giant atmospheres. Studies on rotating convective instability have examined scenarios with N^{2}<0 , and have found that rotating systems can remain stable even when N^{2}<0 ( Flasar & Gierasch, (1978) ; Hathaway et al., (1979) ) . In Flasar & Gierasch ((1978)) and Hathaway et al. ((1979)) , the background zonal shear is assumed to be purely vertical. However, meridional shears resulting from eddy angular momentum transport ( Busse, (1970) ; Aurnou et al., (2007) ; Soderlund, (2019) ; Zeng & Jansen, (2021) , e.g.,) are likely significant in the oceans of icy moons and the atmospheres of gas giants, thereby influencing the instability criteria. Beyond the background field, various approximations have been employed in studies of symmetric instability. In early studies, the traditional approximation ( Gerkema et al., (2008) ) has been commonly applied, wherein the problem is examined on an f -plane that considers only the component of planetary rotation parallel to gravity. In this framework, the instability criteria for gravitationally and inertially stable fluids can be expressed as \mathrm{Ri}<\eta/f , the same as negative PV in the Northern Hemisphere ( Hoskins, (1974) ; Haine & Marshall, (1998) , c.f.) , where \mathrm{Ri}=N^{2}/(\partial u/\partial R)^{2} is the Richardson number. However, the traditional approximation is not valid for planets with deep fluid layers, such as the atmospheres of gas giants and the oceans of icy moons, for flows with strong vertical motion, or for near-equatorial flows where f\to 0 ( Gerkema et al., (2008) ) . Later studies have considered a “tilted f -plane” that takes into account both vertical and horizontal components of the planetary rotation, \mathbf{f}=f\mathbf{e_{R}}+\tilde{f}\mathbf{e_{\theta}} where \tilde{f}=2\Omega\cos{\theta} , \mathbf{e_{R}} denotes the upwards direction parallel to gravity, and \mathbf{e_{\theta}} denotes the latitudinal direction defined to point northward ( Sun, (1995) ;

Read the complete text