Point Cloud to Mesh Reconstruction: Methods, Trade-offs, and Implementation Guide

Fatima Zahra Iguenfer, Achraf Hsain, Hiba Amissa, Yousra Chtouki · 2024

Read Point Cloud to Mesh Reconstruction: Methods, Trade-offs, and Implementation Guide by Fatima Zahra Iguenfer, Achraf Hsain, Hiba Amissa, Yousra Chtouki (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10977.txt.

Introduction

Fatima Zahra Iguenfer and three co-authors write a field guide to turning clouds of points back into surfaces, in this 2024 survey. Scanners and depth cameras deliver point clouds; robots, self-driving systems, and medical software need meshes, connected surfaces they can reason about. Learning-based reconstruction has exploded into a thicket of methods, and newcomers face a bewildering first choice.

The guide sorts more than fifteen methods into five families: PointNet-style networks, autoencoders, deformation methods that stretch a template, point-moving methods, and primitive-based approaches that assemble shapes from parts. Four contributions structure the help. A decision framework maps a project's inputs and outputs to the right family. A failure mode analysis teaches debugging. Standardized comparisons on the ShapeNet benchmark keep claims honest. And a curated list of maintained codebases points to working implementations. Theory and shop practice, the authors insist, belong in the same book.

Catalog record

CREATORFatima Zahra Iguenfer, Achraf Hsain, Hiba Amissa, Yousra Chtouki
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE50 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10977

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Point Cloud to Mesh Reconstruction: Methods, Trade-offs, and Implementation Guide Fatima Zahra Iguenfer, Achraf Hsain, Hiba Amissa, Yousra Chtouki Abstract Reconstructing meshes from point clouds is a fundamental task in computer vision with applications spanning robotics, autonomous systems, and medical imaging. Selecting an appropriate learning-based method requires understanding trade-offs between computational efficiency, geometric accuracy, and output constraints. This paper categorizes over fifteen methods into five paradigms—PointNet family, autoencoder architectures, deformation-based methods, point-move techniques, and primitive-based approaches—and provides practical guidance for method selection. We contribute: (1) a decision framework mapping input/output requirements to suitable paradigms, (2) a failure mode analysis to assist practitioners in debugging implementations, (3) standardized comparisons on ShapeNet benchmarks, and (4) a curated list of maintained codebases with implementation resources. By synthesizing both theoretical foundations and practical considerations, this work serves as an entry point for practitioners and researchers new to learning-based 3D mesh reconstruction. I Introduction Point clouds represent three-dimensional spatial data created by sampling points from object surfaces. These digital collections offer adaptive storage and visualization capabilities across multiple levels of detail [ 9 , 24 ] . Characterized by their flexibility, point clouds can be generated through various technologies, including 3D scanners, Light Detection and Ranging (LIDAR), structure-from-motion (SFM) techniques, and depth sensors such as Kinect and Xtion. Depending on the acquisition method, point clouds exhibit distinct characteristics in point density: SFM and photogrammetry-based approaches typically produce sparse point clouds, whereas 3D scanners, LIDAR, and depth sensors create more densely sampled representations [ 28 ] . This versatility, originating from the lack of topological and connectivity constraints characteristic of mesh-based models, renders point clouds particularly suitable for real-time applications [ 8 ] . Three-dimensional meshes represent a prevalent discrete method for virtual surface and volume representation. Their inherent simplicity has led to widespread adoption, such that graphics processing units (GPUs) specialized in rendering images from 3D meshes are now integrated into personal computing devices including computers, tablets, and smartphones [ 30 ] . Triangular meshes offer an effective approach to 3D model representation, typically characterized by three fundamental data types: connectivity, geometry, and properties. Connectivity data define the adjacency relationships between vertices, providing the structural framework of the mesh. Geometry data precisely specify the spatial location of each vertex, while property data encompass additional attributes such as normal vectors, material reflectance, and texture coordinates [ 36 ] . Mesh reconstruction can therefore be defined as the transformation of point cloud data into 3D meshes. This technique finds applications in diverse domains, including 3D modeling and computer graphics, autonomous vehicles and robotics, architecture and urban planning, medical imaging, geospatial mapping, and augmented reality. Although prior studies, such as [ 58 , 10 , 61 ] , explore surface reconstruction from point clouds, they mainly focus on different representations, such as voxel grids, implicit surfaces, and volumetric representations. In addition, these studies often examine broader three-dimensional reconstruction methods or emphasize classical optimization-based approaches rather than learning-based techniques. Our work addresses this gap by specifically focusing on reconstructing mesh surfaces from point clouds using machine learning techniques. We organize these methods into five categories: PointNet Family, Autoencoder-based Architectures, Deformation-based Methods, Point-Move, and Primitive-based approaches. II Method Selection Framework Before examining specific paradigms, practitioners must understand how to select an appropriate method based on their requirements. This section provides a structured decision framework to guide method selection. II-A Input Characteristics The choice of reconstruction method depends on input data properties: Point Density: Sparse point clouds (fewer than 1,000 points) benefit from completion-oriented methods like PCN [ 59 ] , while dense clouds (10,000+ points) can leverage direct triangulation approaches like PointTriNet [ 42 ] . Noise Level: Methods with robust encoders (PointNet-based architectures) handle moderate noise effectively. For high-noise scenarios, regression-based approaches [ 22 ] that aggregate local features provide better resilience. Completeness: Partial point clouds require completion capabilities. The PCN family addresses this challenge, while direct triangulation methods assume relatively complete inputs. Single Object vs. Scene: Most learning-based methods target single objects. Scene-level reconstruction typically requires segmentation preprocessing or specialized architectures. II-B Output Requirements Watertight Mesh Required: If watertight (closed, manifold) meshes are essential, consider BSP-Net [ 12 ] which guarantees watertight outputs, or deformation-based methods starting from closed templates. AtlasNet [ 17 ] with sphere templates also produces closed surfaces. Sharp Feature Preservation: For CAD-like models with sharp edges, primitive-based methods [ 27 ] excel. Implicit methods and folding-based approaches tend to smooth sharp features. Real-time Constraints: The Real-NVP deformation approach [ 31 ] achieves 58Hz on 3,000-vertex meshes. Regression forests [ 22 ] offer millisecond-level reconstruction. Most deep learning methods require more substantial inference time. Topology Constraints: Deformation-based methods preserve template topology. If arbitrary topology is needed, consider point-move or primitive assembly approaches. II-C Decision Guidelines Based on common use cases, we recommend: • General-purpose reconstruction: AtlasNet provides a balance of quality and flexibility with multiple parameterizations. • Incomplete/partial data: PCN family methods handle missing regions through learned completion. • CAD/mechanical parts: Primitive-based methods preserve sharp geometric features better than implicit approaches. • Real-time robotics: Deformation-based methods with template meshes offer fast inference when topology is known. • Direct triangulation: PointTriNet when connectivity among existing points is needed without adding or removing vertices. III The PointNet Family The PointNet-based algorithms represent an important advancement in 3D point cloud processing, providing scalable solutions for tasks such as 3D classification and segmentation. The original PointNet architecture [ 37 ] , introduced in 2017, directly processes point clouds using a symmetric function to ensure permutation invariance. This ability to handle raw point clouds without transformation into regular grids makes PointNet suitable for real-world 3D data processing, particularly in applications like autonomous driving, object detection, and robotics. Building on this foundation, PointNet++ [ 38 ] , introduced in the same year, extends PointNet by incorporating hierarchical feature learning to better capture local structures within point clouds. By processing the point cloud at multiple scales, PointNet++ improves performance on complex datasets where local geometric features are important. Subsequent developments, such as Generative PointNet [ 53 ] , introduce energy-based models for point cloud generation, reconstruction, and classification. Other works, like KNN-based Feature Learning Network [ 29 ] , explore semantic segmentation by leveraging K-nearest neighbors for feature learning, while PointNet++ for 3D Classification [ 43 ] introduces improved local geometry capture through ellipsoid querying around centroids. The PointNet family has established a foundation for advancements in point-cloud processing, which we explore further in subsequent sections. We begin with the original PointNet architecture, as it directly relates to mesh reconstruction from point clouds. III-A PointNet The paper [ 37 ] presents a deep learning architecture designed to consume unordered point sets for tasks including object classification, part segmentation, and scene semantic parsing. Traditional deep learning approaches for 3D data typically transform point clouds into regular grid-based representations, such as 3D voxel grids, which introduce inefficiencies and quantization artifacts. PointNet operates directly on raw point cloud data, addressing the challenges of its unordered nature and ensuring permutation invariance through a symmetric function, specifically max pooling. The PointNet architecture, presented in Figure 1 , consists of three core components: • A symmetric function to process unordered inputs. • A combination of local and global

Read the complete text