The geometry of simplicial distributions on suspension scenarios
Aziz Kharoof · 2024
Read The geometry of simplicial distributions on suspension scenarios by Aziz Kharoof (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10963.txt.
Introduction
Aziz Kharoof studies the shape of simplicial distributions on suspension scenarios in quantum theory, in work from twenty twenty-four. Quantum measures can show contextuality, a non-classic trait that aids computing. Simplicial distributions are a fresh frame for capturing that trait. In that frame, measures and outcomes are treated as spaces themselves. Shape and topology thus become tools for reading quantum oddness.
Kharoof applies a cone build to the measure space and tracks the effect. The no-signalling shape then equals a join of copies of the base shape. Two cone spaces are glued to form a suspension space for study. Splits found for the cone case unlock the suspension case as well. New Bell-type bounds fall out of the geometry for local cases. Known odd vertices from past work gain a clean maths account. Contextuality reads as topology in this telling.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aziz Kharoof |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 100 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10963
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The geometry of simplicial distributions on suspension scenarios Aziz Kharoof Abstract Quantum measurements often exhibit non-classical features, such as contextuality, which generalizes Bell’s non-locality and serves as a resource in various quantum computation models. Existing frameworks have rigorously captured these phenomena, and recently, simplicial distributions have been introduced to deepen this understanding. The geometrical structure of simplicial distributions can be seen as a resource for applications in quantum information theory. In this work, we use topological foundations to study this geometrical structure, leveraging the fact that, in this simplicial framework, measurements and outcomes are represented as spaces. This allows us to depict contextuality as a topological phenomenon. We show that applying the cone construction to the measurement space makes the corresponding non-signaling polytope equal to the join of m m copies of the original polytope, where m m is the number of possible outcomes per measurement. Then we glue two copies of cone measurement spaces to obtain a suspension measurement space. The decomposition done for simplicial distributions on a cone measurement space provides deeper insights into the geometry of simplicial distributions on a suspension measurement space and aids in characterizing the contextuality there. Additionally, we apply these results to derive a new type of Bell inequalities (inequalities that determine the set of local joint probabilities/non-contextual simplicial distributions) and to offer a mathematical explanation for certain contextual vertices from the literature. 1 Introduction Probability distributions obtained from quantum measurements exhibit non-classical features. One such feature is contextuality, which generalizes Bell non-locality. Contextuality is recognized as a computational resource in various quantum computation schemes [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] , and numerous frameworks have been developed to rigorously capture this concept. The sheaf-theoretic framework introduced by Abramsky and Brandenburger has proven to be particularly effective in formulating contextuality [ 5 ] . Any scenario can be described in this language and studied using advanced tools such as cohomology [ 6 ] . On the other hand, topological tools to study contextuality are first introduced in [ 7 ] . This formalism is based on chain complexes and applies to state-independent contextuality – a stronger form of contextuality. Recently, an approach based on simplicial distributions [ 8 ] was introduced, unifying the earlier two methods. In this approach, simplicial distributions provide a new framework for studying contextuality, where measurements and outcomes are represented by spaces instead of discrete sets of labels. The notion of a space is captured using combinatorial objects known as simplicial sets. These objects, while similar to simplicial complexes, are more expressive and form the foundational tools of modern homotopy theory [ 9 ] . The theory of simplicial distributions not only captures contextuality in an innovative way but also introduces new topological ideas and tools for studying it and other fundamental principles in quantum foundations; see [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . A simplicial set X consists of a sequence of sets X_{n} , which represent the n -simplices, along with simplicial structure maps (most importantly, the face maps) that relate simplices of various dimensions. A simplicial distribution on a simplicial scenario, consisting of a measurement space X and an outcome space Y , is given by a simplicial set map p:X\to D(Y) where D(Y) is the simplicial set whose simplices are distributions on the set of simplices of Y . More concretely, a simplicial distribution p consists of a family of distributions \{p_{\sigma}:~\text{$\sigma$ is an $n$-simplex in $X$ and $p_{\sigma}$ is a distribution on $Y_{n}$}\} satisfying compatibility conditions induced by the simplicial structure relations. Typically, the outcome space is chosen to be \Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}} whose n -simplices are given by n -tuples of elements in \mathbb{Z}_{m} , and the face maps are given by deleting. This corresponds to the scenario in which each measurement has m possible outcomes. Meanwhile, an n -simplex of X represents a measurement context (an n-tuple of measurements that can be performed simultaneously). The set of simplicial distributions on a simplicial scenario (X,Y) , denoted by \operatorname{sDist}(X,Y) , forms a polytope. Additionally, there exists a natural convex map: \Theta_{X,Y}:D(s\mathbf{Set}(X,Y))\to\operatorname{sDist}(X,Y) where D(s\mathbf{Set}(X,Y)) is the set of distributions on the set of simplicial maps from X to Y . The noncontextual simplicial distributions on (X,Y) are defined to be the images of \Theta_{X,Y} , forming a subpolytope of \operatorname{sDist}(X,Y) . The facets of this subpolytope correspond to Bell inequalities [ 14 , 15 ] . Finding Bell inequalities and detecting extremal simplicial distributions [ 16 , 17 ] are of fundamental importance with applications to quantum computing. The goal of this paper is to characterize the geometric structure for the set of simplicial distributions, including the identification of extreme distributions and Bell inequalities, in scenarios where the measurement space is a cone space or a suspension space. (a) (b) (c) Figure 1 : (a) A measurement space X . (b) The cone of the space X . (c) The suspension of the space X . In a typical Bell-type experiment, several observers perform measurements on a shared physical system. Each observer has a choice of different measurements to perform on his system. Each measurement can yield some possible outcomes. A natural question arises: what happens if an additional party, with just one measurement, joins the experiment? In terms of the simplicial approach described above, this situation requires modifying the measurement space X by adding a new vertex and a set of simplices connecting each simplex in X to the new vertex. This construction is known as the cone of X , denoted by CX (see Figure 1(b) ). Abstractly, this leads to a more general question: what is the relation between the simplicial distributions on (CX,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) and those on (X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) ? The answer is (1) \operatorname{sDist}(CX,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\cong\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\star\dots\star\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) where the right-hand side in ( 1 ) is the join of m copies of \operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) . Moreover, we have: Theorem 1.1 . Let X be a connected simplicial set. A simplicial distribution p on (CX,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) can be uniquely decomposed as follows: (2) \left(\langle{\lambda_{1},p^{(1)}}\rangle,\dots,\langle{\lambda_{m},p^{(m)}}\rangle\right) where \sum_{i=1}^{m}\lambda_{i}=1 , \lambda_{j}\in[0,1] , and p^{(j)}\in\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) for every 1\leq j\leq m . In addition, we have the following: 1. p is noncontextual if and only if p^{(j)} is noncontextual for every 1\leq j\leq m . 2. p is a vertex in \operatorname{sDist}(CX,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) if and only if there is 1\leq j\leq m such that \lambda_{j}=1 and p^{(j)} is a vertex in \operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) . In homotopy theory, any map from a cone space is trivial (i.e., homotopic to a constant map). However, in certain higher homotopical constructions, such as Toda brackets [ 18 , 19 ] , interactions between maps from the cone can induce non-trivial maps from the suspension. The suspension \Sigma X of a space X is obtained by gluing two copies of cones CX along X (see Figure 1(c) ). The decomposition in ( 2 ) (for simplicial distributions on a cone measurement space) leads to the second main result concerning simplicial distributions on a suspension measurement space: Proposition 1.2 . If X is a connected simplicial set, then we have the following pullback square \textstyle{\operatorname{sDist}(\Sigma X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \textstyle{\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\star\dots\star\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\operatorname{Id}\star\dots\star\operatorname{Id}} \textstyle{\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\star\dots\star\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces\ignorespaces} \scriptstyle{\operatorname{Id}\star\dots\star\operatorname{Id}} \textstyle{\operatorname{sDist}(X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}})} In addition, a simplicial distribution \left(\langle{\lambda_{1},p^{up,1}}\rangle,\dots,\langle{\lambda_{m},p^{up,m}}\rangle;\langle{\mu_{1},p^{down,1}}\rangle,\dots,\langle{\mu_{m},p^{down,m}}\rangle\right) on (\Sigma X,\Delta_{\mathbb{Z}_{m}}) is noncontextual if and only if