Machine Proofs for Adams Differentials and Extension Problems Among CW Spectra

Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang and Zhouli Xu · 2024

Read Machine Proofs for Adams Differentials and Extension Problems Among CW Spectra by Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang and Zhouli Xu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10876.txt.

Introduction

Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang, and Zhouli Xu report machine proofs for Adams differentials in two thousand twenty-four. Adams computations decide deep facts about stable homotopy groups. Their dataset covers forty nine CW spectra and many maps. Sixty one cofiber sequences enter the records as well.

The document explains how the machine results were obtained. Detailed proofs back the computed differentials and extensions. Human insight adds ad hoc steps where the machine stops. Together they settled the Last Kervaire Invariant Problem in dimension one two six. The dataset sits on Zenodo for others to inspect.

Catalog record

CREATORWeinan Lin, Guozhen Wang and Zhouli Xu
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10876

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Machine Proofs for Adams Differentials and Extension Problems Among CW Spectra Weinan Lin, Guozhen Wang and Zhouli Xu Abstract . In this document, we describe the process of obtaining numerous Adams differentials and extensions using computational methods, as well as how to interpret the dataset uploaded to Zenodo [ 6 ] . Detailed proofs of the machine-generated results are also provided. The dataset includes information on 49 CW spectra, 180 maps, and 61 cofiber sequences. Leveraging these results, and with the addition of some ad hoc arguments derived through human insight, we successfully resolved the Last Kervaire Invariant Problem in dimension 126 [ 7 ] . 1. Introduction In this project, we first compute the Adams E_{2} -pages and maps for many CW spectra using the computer program ./Adams , developed by the first author [ 4 ] . All relevant spectra and maps have been uploaded to the Zenodo repository [ 6 ] and are described in detail in Section 2 . Additionally, another program, ./ss , also developed by the first author [ 4 ] , computes Adams differentials and extensions. The resulting data are included in the Zenodo repository and described in Section 3 . The program ./ss also generates proofs for all computed results, which are organized into a comprehensive resource we refer to as the Table of Proofs. This program partially employs the Generalized Leibniz Rule and the Generalized Mahowald Trick—two theorems established in the paper [ 7 ] addressing the Last Kervaire Invariant Problem. These theorems enable the program to derive new differentials and extensions from previously computed ones. Detailed instructions on how to interpret and navigate the Table of Proofs are provided in Section 4 . In Section 5 , we present several charts and tables of machine-generated Adams differentials that are particularly relevant to the solution of the Last Kervaire Invariant Problem. 2. Adams E_{2} data 2.1. Adams E_{2} -pages Tables 1 provides a list of 49 CW spectra considered in this work, along with the maximum internal degrees computed for the Adams E_{2} -pages of the corresponding spectra. CW spectra max(t) S0 261 tmf 261 C2 200 Ceta 200 Cnu 200 Csigma 200 CW_2_eta 200 CW_eta_2 200 CW_eta_nu 200 CW_nu_eta 200 CW_sigma_nu 200 CW_nu_sigma 200 CW_2_eta_nu 200 CW_nu_eta_2 200 CW_sigma_nu_eta 200 CW_eta_nu_sigma 200 CW_sigma_nu_eta_2 200 CW_2_eta_nu_sigma 200 Csigmasq 200 C2h4 200 DC2h4 198 Ctheta4 200 C2h5 200 DC2h5 200 Ctheta5 200 CW spectra max(t) C2h6 200 DC2h6 200 C2_C2 180 Ceta_Ceta 160 Cnu_Cnu 180 Csigma_Csigma 180 CW_2sigma_sigma 180 CW_sigma_2sigma 180 C2sigma 200 CW_2_V_eta 200 CW_2_A_eta 180 Joker 200 CW_eta_2_eta_Eq_2_nu 200 CW_eta_2_eta_Eq_nu_2 200 C2_Ceta 200 RP3_6 199 Fphi 200 RP1_4 200 RP1_6 183 RP1_8 180 RP1_10 180 RP1_12 178 RP1_256 200 RP3_256 160 Table 1. CW spectra For a CW spectrum X , the Adams E_{2} -page data for X is available in the database file X_AdamsSS.db within kervaire_database.zip . Alternatively, the data can be accessed as three plain-text table files: • X_AdamsE2_generators.csv (for generators), • X_AdamsE2_relations.csv (for relations), • X_AdamsE2_basis.csv (for {\mathbb{F}}_{2} -basis). These files are included in kervaire_csv.rar , available in the Zenodo repository. We illustrate these tables with examples. Tables 2 – 4 present the first few rows of the corresponding files for the spectrum C2 (the naming convention will be explained later). id name stem s 0 [0] 0 0 1 (h_1[1]) 2 1 2 (h_2^2[1]) 7 2 3 (h_0^3 h_3[1]) 8 4 4 (c_0[1]) 9 3 5 ((Ph_1)[1]) 10 5 Table 2. C2_AdamsE2_generators.csv rel stem s 0,1,0 0 1 0,1,1;1,2,0 2 2 2,1,1 5 2 0,1,2 7 3 1,1,2;4,1,0 8 3 Table 3. C2_AdamsE2_relations.csv index mon stem s d2 0 0 0 0 0 1,1,0 1 1 0 1 2 1 0 1,2,0 2 2 0 2,1,0 3 1 Table 4. C2_AdamsE2_basis.csv Notation 2.1 . In the table of generators, a row with id=i is the i ’th generator of the E_{2} -page of X . In this section we will denote this generator by x_{i} if X is a ring spectrum or v_{i} if X is a module over some ring spectrum (in our dataset there are only two ring spectra S0 and tmf ). The columns stem,s are the degrees of the generators. The column name is the latex name we give to the i ’th generator. However, currently not all generators have latex names. The column name might be sometimes vacant (filled with [NULL] ). Notation 2.2 . In the table of relations, consider the column rel for relations. If X is a ring spectrum, then 0,1;1,2,5,4 denotes the relation x_{0}^{1}+x_{1}^{2}x_{5}^{4}=0. If X is a module over the ring spectra R , then 0,1,3;1,2,5,4,7 denotes the relation x_{0}^{1}v_{3}+x_{1}^{2}x_{5}^{4}v_{7}=0 where v_{i} is the i ’th generator of X and x_{j} is the j ’th generator of the ring spectrum R . In summary, the semicolon can be parsed as the plus sign and the monomials are sequences of sub- and upper-scripts whose lengths are even if X is a ring or odd if X is a module. The columns stem,s are the degrees of the relations which can be determined by the degrees of the generators. Notation 2.3 . In the table of basis, the column mon is parsed in the same way as we parse rel for relations. The only difference is that each mon is a monomial so there should be no semicolon in the column mon . The columns stem,s are the degrees of the monomials. The column index is important . When there are multiple monomial basis elements in the same bidegree, they will be indexed by 0,1,\dots,k . We write [i]\in\mathrm{Ext}^{\verb|s,stem+s|}(\verb|X|) to denote the monomial basis element with index i in \mathrm{Ext}^{\verb|s,stem+s|}(\verb|X|) . In the Table of Proofs (see Section 4 ), the element will be written as X (stem, s) [i] in the info column. We can also write [i_{1},i_{2},...] to denote the linear combination of monomials with indices i_{1},i_{2},\dots and [] to denote the zero element. The d2 column represents the d_{2} differentials of the basis elements in the format [i_{1},i_{2},...] we just described but in degree (stem-1,s+2) . If it is empty, it means that the d_{2} differential is trivial. If it is filled with [NULL] , it means that the d_{2} differential is not calculated yet by the program ./Adams using the secondary Steenrod operations. Next we explain our naming scheme for the above CW spectra. We chose to use plain text names for these objects because we want to use consistent names for computer codes, command-line arguments for ./Adams and ./ss , the website links of plots and the plain text machine proofs. Table 5 is a list of keywords we use in the name and the corresponding elements in \pi_{*}(S^{0}) the stable homotopy groups of spheres. keyword \pi_{*}(S^{0}) eta \eta nu \nu sigma \sigma 2nu 2\nu 2sigma 2\sigma sigmasq \sigma^{2} theta4 \theta_{4} theta5 \theta_{5} Table 5. Keywords in the names of CW spectra Notation 2.4 . Let a,b,c,... be keywords, a,b,c,\dots be the corresponding elements in \pi_{*}(S^{0}) and |a|,|b|,|c| be the topological degrees of a,b,c,\dots . The following examples demonstrate our naming for the CW spectra. • S0 is the sphere spectrum S^{0} . tmf is the topological modular form tmf . • Ca

Read the complete text