User Personas Improve Social Sustainability by Encouraging Software Developers to Deprioritize Antisocial Features

Bimpe Ayoola, Miikka Kuutila, Rina R. Wehbe and Paul Ralph · 2024

Read User Personas Improve Social Sustainability by Encouraging Software Developers to Deprioritize Antisocial Features by Bimpe Ayoola, Miikka Kuutila, Rina R. Wehbe and Paul Ralph (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10672.txt.

Introduction

Ayoola, Kuutila, Wehbe, and Ralph present a 2024 experiment on whether user personas make software developers drop antisocial features. The social side of lasting software is barely studied, and no lab-tested interventions existed. The team ran a randomized trial with 79 computing students. Each ranked a backlog of prosocial, neutral, and antisocial features for a mall's screens and face-scanning system. Groups received personas, a stakeholder map, both, or neither.

Students given personas ranked the antisocial items much lower. Prosocial rankings did not move, and the map showed no clear effect. The authors say well-crafted personas steer builders away from harmful features. They call for a rerun with seasoned professionals. They also note backlog ranking proved a workable lab measure of the social side of software.

Catalog record

CREATORBimpe Ayoola, Miikka Kuutila, Rina R. Wehbe and Paul Ralph
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10672

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

User Personas Improve Social Sustainability by Encouraging Software Developers to Deprioritize Antisocial Features Bimpe Ayoola, Miikka Kuutila, Rina R. Wehbe and Paul Ralph Abstract Background : Sustainable software development involves creating software in a manner that meets present goals without undermining our ability to meet future goals. In a software engineering context, sustainability has at least four dimensions: ecological, economic, social, and technical. No interventions for improving social sustainability in software engineering have been tested in rigorous lab-based experiments, and little evidence-based guidance is available. Objective : The purpose of this study is to evaluate the effectiveness of two interventions—stakeholder maps and persona models—for improving social sustainability through software feature prioritization. Method : We conducted a randomized controlled factorial experiment with 79 undergraduate computer science students. Participants were randomly assigned to one of four groups and asked to prioritize a backlog of prosocial, neutral, and antisocial user stories for a shopping mall’s digital screen display and facial recognition software. Participants received either persona models, a stakeholder map, both, or neither. We compared the differences in prioritization levels assigned to prosocial and antisocial user stories using Cumulative Link Mixed Model regression. Results : Participants who received persona models gave significantly lower priorities to antisocial user stories but no significant difference was evident for prosocial user stories. The effects of the stakeholder map were not significant. The interaction effects were not significant. Conclusion : Providing aspiring software professionals with well-crafted persona models causes them to de-prioritize antisocial software features. The impact of persona modelling on sustainable software development therefore warrants further study with more experience professionals. Moreover, the novel methodological strategy of assessing social sustainability behavior through backlog prioritization appears feasible in lab-based settings. I Introduction Sustainable Development refers to meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs [ 1 ] . Sustainable software engineering, analogously refers to creating and maintaining software in a way that meets present needs without undermining our collective capacity to meet our future needs [ 2 ] . Sustainable software development therefore involves minimizing negative impacts on the economy, society, human beings, and the environment during software development, deployment, and usage [ 3 ] . Put another way, sustainable software development means allowing technology to improve our daily lives while mitigating social risks (e.g. cybercrime, surveillance capitalism, social isolation) [ 4 ] . Software sustainability encompasses four dimensions: economic sustainability concerns wealth creation and profitability; environmental (or ecological ) sustainability relates to the responsible use of natural resources; technical sustainability involves designing quality software for adaptability [ 5 ] ; social sustainability relates to impacts on the wellbeing of individuals, organizations, communities, and society [ 2 ] . The social dimensions is the most complex and difficult to define of the four. Sustainability is rarely addressed holistically [ 6 ] . Researchers and practitioners often focus on environmental or technical sustainability of software [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] , but rarely address social sustainability despite sometimes being considered as important [ 6 , 2 ] . This gap exists partly because social sustainability is qualitatively complex and lacks clear criteria, practical guidance, or tools for integrating it into software development processes [ 2 ] . For instance, a software development team may address environmental sustainability by enhancing energy efficiency, technical sustainability through refactoring, and economic sustainability through market research and user-centered design (emphasizing a feasible revenue model). However, integrating social sustainability is more challenging. Development is socially sustainable when it meets present needs while improving, or at least not undermining, human wellbeing. Social sustainability involves creating software that benefits society, intersecting social issues such as equity, social justice, privacy, security, human well-being [ 14 ] . It takes different forms at different levels; for example, individual physical and mental health; group cohesion; organizational inclusiveness, community resilience, national social justice, or world peace. Therefore, development may be unsustainable in many ways; for instance, by deleteriously affecting safety, equity, tolerance, democratic participation, human rights, the rule of law, education, or sustainability awareness. Socially sustainable software development requires not only understanding the societal impact of software products but also embedding principles that support social well-being and ethical responsibilities into the development process. This aspect of sustainability, often overshadowed by its environmental and technical counterparts, demands a more nuanced approach—delving into social values and impacts such as equality, diversity, community building, and belongingness. The challenges in incorporating sustainability into software development are further highlighted by a recent meta-analysis of sustainable software engineering research [ 2 ] . This analysis revealed a critical gap: only a few studies have evaluated sustainability-promoting interventions [ 15 , 11 , 16 , 17 ] , and none of these studies used controlled experiments. While controlled experiments are not the only way to evaluate an intervention, the absence of any controlled experiments is a red flag. This underscores the need for more research to develop effective strategies for integrating social sustainability in software. This study begins to address this gap by evaluating the role of stakeholder mapping and personas in contributing towards social sustainability. WE pose the following research question. Research Question: To what extent do stakeholder maps and personas affect how software professionals’ prioritize social sustainability? Stakeholder mapping is the process of identifying and categorizing stakeholders by considering their needs, their concerns, and how a product or project might affect them [ 18 , 19 ] . Personas, on the other hand, are fictional characters created based on research to represent different user types. They help developers represent intended users to understand their needs, goals, characteristics and diversity [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] . They can also be used as a tool to facilitate sustainable user behaviour in software design [ 23 ] . II Related Work II-A Social Sustainability Social sustainability focuses on maintaining social capital and preserving the solidarity of communities [ 5 ] , as well as ensuring equal or improved access to social resources for future generations, highlighting the importance of generational equity [ 24 , 25 ] . This concept is critical in the context of software development, where socially sustainable software should aim for digital inclusion by eliminating barriers, promoting multicultural awareness, and making systems more accessible to a diverse user base. This includes improving accessibility for the elderly, people with disabilities, non-English speakers, and low-literacy users to provide equal opportunities to the users [ 26 ] . However, accounting for the social dimension of sustainability is challenging for practitioners [ 27 ] due to its intangible, qualitative nature and lack of consensus on relevant criteria [ 28 , 29 ] . There is no clear method or comprehensive set of metrics for evaluating the social sustainability of a software product [ 30 ] . Existing guidelines assessing social sustainability are often vague and inadequate [ 31 ] . In a recent survey, zero of 178 software professionals reported considering social sustainability in their development process or being guided by an explicit sustainability policy [ 32 ] . Significant attention has been directed towards the societal impacts of technology, particularly how AI technologies can affect marginalized and

Read the complete text