Separation of measurement uncertainty into quantum and classical parts based on Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability and generalized entropy
Agung Budiyono · 2024
Read Separation of measurement uncertainty into quantum and classical parts based on Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability and generalized entropy by Agung Budiyono (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10619.txt.
Introduction
Agung Budiyono splits measurement uncertainty in quantum mechanics into quantum and classical parts in a 2024 paper. A measurement's outcome can be unsure for two reasons: the state and the measurement may clash in a purely quantum way, or the observer may simply lack knowledge. Telling the two apart matters for both foundations and lab practice.
Budiyono gives two additive splits of total uncertainty, each tied to a generalized entropy of the outcomes. The quantum part is captured through a quasiprobability tool that exposes nonreality and negativity, maximized over a chosen sharp measurement. What remains counts as classical. Both splits meet a list of sanity checks, and the least total uncertainty over all measurements turns out to be purely classical.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Agung Budiyono |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10619
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Separation of measurement uncertainty into quantum and classical parts based on Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability and generalized entropy Agung Budiyono Abstract Measurement in quantum mechanics is notoriously unpredictable. The uncertainty in quantum measurement can arise from the noncommutativity between the state and the measurement basis which is intrinsically quantum, but it may also be of classical origin due to the agent’s ignorance. It is of fundamental as well as practical importance to cleanly separate the two contributions which can be directly accessed using laboratory operations. Here, we propose two ways of decomposition of the total measurement uncertainty additively into quantum and classical parts. In the two decompositions, the total uncertainty of a measurement described by a POVM (positive-operator-valued measure) over a quantum state is quantified respectively by two generalized nonadditive entropies of the measurement outcomes; the quantum parts are identified, respectively, by the nonreality and the nonclassicality — which captures simultaneously both the nonreality and negativity — of the associated generalized Kirkwood-Dirac quasiprobability relative to the POVM of interest and a PVM (projection-valued measure) and maximized over all possible choices of the latter; and, the remaining uncertainties are identified as the classical parts. Both decompositions are shown to satisfy a few plausible requirements. The minimum of the total measurement uncertainties in the two decompositions over all POVM measurements are given by the impurity of the quantum state quantified by certain generalized quantum entropies, and are entirely classical. We argue that nonvanishing genuine quantum uncertainty in the two decompositions are sufficient and necessary to prove quantum contextuality via weak measurement with postselection. Finally, we suggest that the genuine quantum uncertainty is a manifestation of a specific measurement disturbance. pacs Valid PACS appear here I Introduction The advent of quantum information theory in the last decades has promoted the fundamental unpredictability of measurement in quantum mechanics from being the source of the long-standing conceptual problems about the meaning of the theory, to a key resource in a variety of schemes of quantum technology. In quantum mechanics, state and measurement are represented by operators, and their noncommutativity formally underlies the uncertainty of the measurement outcomes. But measurement uncertainty may also stem from the agent’s ignorance about the preparation of the state and/or the meausurement, i.e., when there is an uncontrollable classical noise, or, when there is a lack of access to another system entangled with the system of interest, leading to the preparation of a mixed state and/or an unsharp measurement. It is therefore reasonable to regard the measurement uncertainty due to the noncommutativity between the state and the measurement basis as genuine quantum uncertainty, while those due to the agent’s ignorance as classical uncertainty Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty1 ; Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty2 ; Korzekwa quantum-classical decomposition ; Hall quantum-classical decomposition . To better understand the conceptual problem of quantum-classical correspondence and contrast, and for its practical application in quantum information science and technology, it is crucial to have a framework which cleanly separates the genuine quantum uncertainty from the classical uncertainty, in terms of well-defined laboratory operations. In particular, it is important to require that the genuine quantum part of the measurement uncertainty is linked to the true nonclassicality such as quantum contextuality Bell on quantum contextuality ; Kochen-Specker theorem ; Spekkens generalized quantum contextuality . Naturally, however, there is no unique way of quantum-classical decomposition of measurement uncertainty; it depends on the quantity we adopt to measure the uncertainty. Nonetheless, one may require all such decompositions to comply with a set of plausible requirements Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty1 ; Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty2 ; Korzekwa quantum-classical decomposition ; Hall quantum-classical decomposition . Different schemes of decomposition have been proposed using quantum information theoretical concepts to isolate the genuine quantum part of the uncertainty, such as Wigner-Yanase skew information Wigner-Yanase skew information as proposed in Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty1 ; Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty2 , and relative entropy of coherence Korzekwa quantum-classical decomposition ; Hall quantum-classical decomposition . The total measurement uncertainty is then obtained as their upper bounds Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty1 ; Luo's genuine quantum uncertainty2 ; Korzekwa quantum-classical decomposition or via purification Hall quantum-classical decomposition , and the classical uncertainty is defined as the difference between the total uncertainty and the quantum part. Here, we shall take yet a different perspective based on a specific representation of quantum state in terms of Kirkwood-Dirac (KD) quasiprobability Kirkwood quasiprobability ; Dirac quasiprobability . KD quasiprobability is a quantum analog of classical phase space probability distribution in classical statistical mechanics, wherein the noncommutativity between the state and the defining measurement bases manifests in its nonclassical values, i.e., the nonreal and/or negative values of its real part. Remarkably, the real and imaginary parts of the KD quasiprobability can be estimated directly (i.e., without resorting to a full quantum state tomography) in experiment Aharonov weak value ; Aharonov-Daniel book ; Wiseman weak value ; Lundeen measurement of KD distribution ; Salvail direct measurement KD distribution ; Bamber measurement of KD distribution ; Thekkadath measurement of density matrix ; Johansen quantum state from successive projective measurement ; Hernandez-Gomez experimental observation of TBMH negativity ; Wagner measuring weak values and KD quasiprobability ; Haapasalo generalized weak value ; Vallone strong measurement to reconstruct quantum wave function ; Cohen estimating of weak value with strong measurements ; Lundeen complex weak value ; Jozsa complex weak value ; Lostaglio KD quasiprobability and quantum fluctuation ; Chiribella estimation of weak value ; Gherardini KD quasiprobability and its application: review ; Suzuki observation of KD quasiprobability for a single photonic qubit 1 ; Linuma observation of KD quasiprobability for a single qubit using entangled photon . This has led, recently, to a flurry of works using the nonclassical values of the KD quasiprobability in different areas of quantum science and technology Halpern quasiprobability and information scrambling ; Lostaglio KD quasiprobability and quantum fluctuation ; Alonso KD quasiprobability witnesses quantum scrambling ; Allahverdyan TBMH as quasiprobability distribution of work ; Lostaglio TBMH quasiprobability fluctuation theorem contextuality ; Lostaglio contextuality in quantum linear response ; Levy quasiprobability distribution for heat fluctuation in quantum regime ; Pusey negative TBMH quasiprobability and contextuality ; Kunjwal contextuality of non-real weak value ; Agung KD-nonreality coherence ; Agung KD general quantum correlation ; Agung KD-nonclassicality coherence ; Arvidsson-Shukur quantum advantage in postselected metrology ; Lupu-Gladstein negativity enhanced quantum phase estimation ; Agung estimation and operational interpretation of trace-norm asymmetry ; Gherardini KD quasiprobability and its application: review . It is thus interesting to ask if the representation based on KD quasiprobability may offer an intuitive and clean separation of the measurement uncertainty into an inherently quantum versus a purely classical uncertainties, which furthermore admits a direct interpretation in terms of laboratory operations. A positive answer is argued in the present work. First, in Section II , given a state and a positive-operator-valued measure (POVM) basis describing a general measurement, we define two quantities capturing the extent of the noncommutatvity between the state and the POVM basis. In the first quantity, called the KD nonreality in a state relative to a POVM basis, the noncommutativity between the state and the POVM basis is quantified in terms of the nonreality in the KD quasiprobability defined relative to the POVM