Recommendation and Temptation
Md Sanzeed Anwar, Paramveer S. Dhillon, Grant Schoenebeck · 2024
Read Recommendation and Temptation by Md Sanzeed Anwar, Paramveer S. Dhillon, Grant Schoenebeck (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10595.txt.
Introduction
Md Sanzeed Anwar and co-authors design recommender systems that respect the pull between lasting value and instant temptation. Standard recommenders read only what users pick. Picks mix real enrichment with momentary appeal.
That mix can trap users in shallow engagement loops. The model here splits choices into both drives. It also accounts for options outside the platform. The goal becomes maximizing the enrichment users actually consume. A locally greedy strategy proves optimal for that goal. Estimation uses both ratings and silent choice data. Tests on synthetic and movie data favor the design. The work argues for recommenders that serve long-term good, not just clicks and watch time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Md Sanzeed Anwar, Paramveer S. Dhillon, Grant Schoenebeck |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10595
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Recommendation and Temptation Md Sanzeed Anwar, Paramveer S. Dhillon, Grant Schoenebeck Abstract . Traditional recommender systems based on utility maximization and revealed preferences often fail to capture users’ dual-self nature, where consumption choices are driven by both long-term benefits (enrichment) and desire for instant gratification (temptation). Consequently, these systems may generate recommendations that fail to provide long-lasting satisfaction to users. To address this issue, we propose a novel user model that accounts for this dual-self behavior and develop an optimal recommendation strategy to maximize enrichment from consumption. We highlight the limitations of historical consumption data in implementing this strategy and present an estimation framework that makes minimal assumptions and leverages explicit user feedback and implicit choice data to overcome these constraints. We evaluate our approach through both synthetic simulations and simulations based on real-world data from the MovieLens dataset. Results demonstrate that our proposed recommender can deliver superior enrichment compared to several competitive baseline algorithms that assume a single utility type and rely solely on revealed preferences. Our work emphasizes the critical importance of optimizing for enrichment in recommender systems, particularly in temptation-laden consumption contexts. Our findings have significant implications for content platforms, user experience design, and the development of responsible AI systems, paving the way for more nuanced and user-centric recommendation approaches. 1. Introduction Consumption of online content has become a central fixture in everyday life, spanning various forms such as articles, videos, films, social media, and more. This consumption accounts for a substantial portion of people’s time, significantly impacting daily routines and leisure activities. For example, according to Statista 1 1 1 https://www.statista.com/statistics/1359403/us-time-spent-per-day-netflix-tiktok-youtube/ , adults in the United States spend an average of 46 minutes on YouTube, 48 minutes on TikTok, and 61 minutes on Netflix every day . These statistics underscore the pervasive nature of digital content in modern life and highlight the importance of efficient content discovery mechanisms. While recommender systems help users navigate this vast sea of content more effectively, there is growing concern that these systems may be hindering users from getting the maximum benefit possible out of consumption. This potential shortcoming raises questions about the fundamental assumptions underlying recommender system design and their impact on user experience. These limitations stem from two core premises of the current recommender design paradigm: (1) Each user has a utility function that represents the benefit they derive from a given option. (2) Users are utility maximizers and, when presented with a set of alternatives, will invariably choose the option with the highest utility. These assumptions, while providing a foundation for many recommender systems, may oversimplify the complex nature of human decision-making in content consumption. As a result, they could lead to recommendations that fail to account for the nuanced ways in which users interact with and benefit from digital content. In this paper, we present a novel approach to recommender design by challenging the second premise : we posit that while users possess a utility function representing derived value or long-term benefit, their decision-making process is influenced by additional content dimensions, resulting in consumption choices that seemingly contradict their utility-maximizing nature. This departure from the traditional utility maximization principle finds strong support in existing literature. For instance, Daniel Kahneman ( Kahneman 2011 ) distinguishes between two types of happiness: experienced happiness, which encompasses immediate emotions, and life satisfaction or evaluative happiness, representing a long-term perspective on well-being. Similarly, several studies ( Thaler and Shefrin 1981 ; Kleinberg et al. 2022 ) conceptualize users as a combination of short-term and long-term selves, with the former prioritizing immediate gratification and the latter optimizing for long-term benefits from consumption. Drawing inspiration from these conceptual frameworks, we identify two distinct dimensions of content that influence consumption choices: (1) Temptation quantifies the instant gratification provided by content, analogous to Kahneman’s experienced happiness or short-term benefits in dual-self models. (2) Enrichment measures the long-term value or benefit offered by content, similar to Kahneman’s life satisfaction or long-term benefits in dual-self models. Empirical observations of online user behavior substantiate the distinction between these concepts. A notable example is the phenomenon observed on platforms like YouTube, where users feel “sucked down a rabbit hole” and engage in prolonged consumption of similar content they themselves acknowledge as mediocre ( Woolley and Kenyon 2023 ) . This behavior exemplifies the tension between temptation and enrichment: users find themselves drawn to and unable to disengage from highly tempting content, despite recognizing its limited long-term value or enrichment potential. The distinction between these concepts identifies a critical blind spot in traditional recommender systems. When temptation influences consumption choices, historical data ceases to be a pure reflection of enrichment. Consequently, recommenders relying solely on this data, without an appropriate user model, struggle to differentiate between enrichment and temptation. Furthermore, recommenders that fail to account for temptation and its impact on consumption choices in their objective cannot ensure high enrichment from consumption. For instance, a recommender driven exclusively by engagement metrics may reinforce temptation, inadvertently preventing users from selecting high-enrichment content both on-platform and off-platform. Conversely, a recommender that simply ranks items by enrichment, without considering actual user decision-making processes, may fail to engage users, potentially driving them towards off-platform options with high temptation but low enrichment. This dichotomy underscores the critical importance of integrating both enrichment and temptation considerations in the design of effective recommender systems. 1.1. Contributions This paper makes several key contributions to the field of recommender systems: (1) First , we introduce a novel consumption model that captures user decision-making by considering both enrichment and temptation, providing a more comprehensive understanding of user behavior. (2) Second , we formulate an appropriate objective function for recommender systems aimed at maximizing user enrichment, and describe the optimal recommendation strategy to achieve this goal. (3) Third , we propose and implement reasonable assumptions to address the limitations of historical data, and develop a basic framework for estimating crucial user and item information, demonstrating the feasibility of a practical implementation of our proposed strategy. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows: Section 2 reviews existing literature on consumption under temptation and recommender systems. Section 3 details our proposed consumption model. Section 3.1 explains our recommendation objective and optimal strategy. Section 4 outlines our estimation framework and necessary assumptions. Section 5 presents an agent-based simulation comparing our approach to baseline recommendations. Finally, Section 6 evaluates our algorithm using the MovieLens dataset, comparing it against ratings-based and behavior-based algorithms. 2. Related Work Our work synthesizes insights from behavioral studies of users under temptation and recommender system design. User Behavior Under Temptation. The prevalence of temptation and the human tendency to prioritize instant gratification over long-term benefits is well-documented across various domains. Experimental studies have examined this phenomenon in contexts ranging from purchase behaviors ( Wertenbroch 1998 ) and appointment compliance ( Trope and Fishbach 2000 ) to smoking cessation ( Giné et al. 2010 ) , savings ( Thaler and Benartzi 2004 ) , and study concentration ( Ariely and Wertenbroch 2002 ) . In the digital content sphere, Milkman et al. ( Milkman et al. 2009 ) provided evidence of temptation-driven behavior in film consumption through a field experiment with QuickFlix users. Economists have proposed several theoretical models to explain