F F -extremization determines certain large- N N CFTs
Ludo Fraser-Taliente, and John Wheater · 2024
Read F F -extremization determines certain large- N N CFTs by Ludo Fraser-Taliente, and John Wheater (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10499.txt.
Introduction
Ludo Fraser-Taliente and John Wheater show that for a wide family of quantum field theories, one number's extreme value fixes the whole theory. The family is the melonic large-N theories, including generalized SYK models, vector models, and tensor theories. The number is the universal part of the sphere free energy, called F-tilde.
Extremizing it, subject to constraints, yields the theories' conformal data. The proof runs two ways, through an effective action method and through resumming Feynman diagrams. Older maximization rules for supersymmetric theories thus extend to plain ones, in any dimension. The authors read the result as the count of infrared degrees of freedom being driven to an extreme, a satisfying unity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ludo Fraser-Taliente, and John Wheater |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 123 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10499
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
F F -extremization determines certain large- N N CFTs Ludo Fraser-Taliente, and John Wheater Abstract We show that the conformal data of a range of large- N N CFTs, the melonic CFTs, are specified by constrained extremization of the universal part of the sphere free energy F = − log Z S d F=-\log Z_{S^{d}} . This family includes the generalized SYK models, the vector models (O ( N ) (N) , Gross-Neveu, etc.), and the tensor field theories. The known F F and a a -maximization procedures in SCFTs are therefore extended to these non-supersymmetric CFTs in continuous d d . We establish our result using the two-particle irreducible (2PI) effective action, and, equivalently, by Feynman diagram resummation. The universal part of F F interpolates in continuous dimension between the known C C -functions, so we can interpret this result as an extremization of the number of IR degrees of freedom, in the spirit of the generalized c , F , a c,F,a -theorems. The outcome is a complete classification of the melonic CFTs: they are the conformal mean field theories which extremize the universal part of the sphere free energy, subject to an IR marginality condition on the interaction Lagrangian. 1 Introduction In this paper, we show that the conformal data of a particular family of large- N CFTs, the melonic CFTs, are determined by constrained extremization of \tilde{F} , the universal part of the sphere free energy of a collection of generalized free fields. The constraints arise directly from the interaction terms, and are linear in the conformal scaling dimensions of the fields. Put another way, the melonic CFTs are precisely the conformal mean field theories with constrained extremal \tilde{F} . Notably, this procedure turns out to be identical to the F and a -maximization principles used to determine the R -charges and scaling dimensions of SCFTs with four supercharges [ 1 , 2 ] . The melonic CFTs arise as the conformal vacua of the melonic quantum field theories, which are a family of large- N QFTs that have a resummable diagrammatic expansion. Recently discovered, they have a structure that is simpler than that of the matrix models, but nonetheless lead to exactly solvable large- N CFTs [ 3 ] . It is useful to distinguish three principal types of melonic QFTs, all of which occur in the strict large- N limit: • the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model and its generalizations [ 4 ] ; • the tensor models \phi_{a_{1}\cdots a_{r}} with \mathrm{O}(M)^{r} symmetry for rank r\geq 3 and M^{r}=N [ 5 , 6 ] ; • the vector models, such as the \mathrm{O}(N) \phi^{4} model [ 7 ] . The solvability of each of these models arises from the exact resummation of their Feynman-diagrammatic expansions at leading order in N . Using this, all the known melonic CFTs can and have been solved individually, whether in the SYK-like [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] , tensor [ 5 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 ] , vector [ 7 , 32 ] , or other [ 33 ] cases. The resummability occurs for a slightly different (albeit related) reason in each case: for SYK-like theories, a disorder average over the coupling; for the vector and tensor models, the tuned combinatorics. However, for our purposes, the particular mechanism used is irrelevant -- the solvable CFT found in the IR is not sensitive to those details 1 1 1 Of course, the N -subleading dynamics of these mechanisms will certainly differ [ 25 , 23 ] . . In this paper, we show that for any melonic QFT d , regardless of the individual complexities of the model in question, the IR CFT d is determined by a universal principle: extremization of \tilde{F} , where \tilde{F} is defined for a mean field theory with the same field content as the QFT but arbitrary conformal scaling dimensions. This reflects our expectation that in the large- N limit, factorization means that the leading order in N is essentially Gaussian, i.e. mean field. Since \tilde{F} is thought to count the effective number of degrees of freedom of a CFT d [ 1 , 34 ] (being a candidate weak C -function in the sense of Zamolodchikov [ 35 , 36 ] ), this has an appealing simplicity. In outline, the \tilde{F} -extremization procedure is as follows. In arbitrary dimension d , we define a UV theory of order \sim N free fields \{\phi\} in arbitrary Lorentz and global symmetry representations. We perturb by a particular relevant interaction and follow the renormalization group flow to the deep IR, where we reach the melonic CFT of interest. There, the conformal symmetry means that the fields have some conformal scaling dimensions \Delta_{\phi} . Thanks to the simplifications of the melonic limit, we can compute the universal part of the sphere free energy as a function of the unknown \Delta_{\phi} s, \displaystyle\tilde{F}\equiv\sum_{\text{fields }\phi}\tilde{F}_{\phi}(\Delta_{\phi}). (1) This is interpreted as \tilde{F} for a mean field theory that has the same field content as the original theory, but each field \phi has an arbitrary trial dimension \Delta_{\phi} . Then, the actual IR scaling dimensions are precisely those that extremize this \tilde{F}(\{\Delta_{\phi}\}) , subject only to the constraint that the potential evaluated in the IR is marginal (i.e. of dimension d ). Generically, this procedure leads to a finite number of vacua in the IR for each d . Explicitly, for a perturbing melonic interaction of schematic form 2 2 2 We have suppressed the details that ensure the melonic resummability. \displaystyle S_{\mathrm{int}}\supset\sum_{m}g_{m}\int\differential^{d}x\prod_{\text{fields }\phi}\phi^{q_{\phi}^{m}}, (2) the constraints are IR marginality of the integrated operator that each g_{m} multiplies: \displaystyle+\sum_{\text{fields }\phi}q^{m}_{\phi}\Delta_{\phi}=0,\quad[\differential^{d}x]=-d; (3) we call these the melonic constraints . However, we must allow for the possibility that any given g_{m} runs to zero, in which case the associated constraint is not applied. Remarkably, this formulation makes manifest that any apparent dependence on the details of the global symmetry representations, or any particular complicated form for the interaction (especially for non-scalar Lorentz representations) is washed out by the conformal melonic limit. The only pieces of data that matter are: 1. the monomial form of the relevant melonic interactions (given by the integers \{q^{m}_{\phi}\} ); 2. and the dimensions of the global symmetry representations of the fields. In the conformal large- N limit, any non-Gaussian behaviour in the correlation functions of the CFT is subleading in N . Therefore, the melonic CFTs are the conformal mean field theories, with some given field content, that extremize \tilde{F} , subject to the constraints ( 3 ). Because the universal part of the sphere free energy ( \tilde{F} ) interpolates between the Weyl anomaly in even d and the free energy in odd d , this procedure is identical to the mechanisms of a - and F -extremization in superconformal field theories (SCFTs) with four supercharges, without the large- N limit 3 3 3 If the SCFTs are unitary, it can be shown that the extrema are