Cavitation Onset in an Impulsively Accelerated Liquid Column

T. Sobral, J. Kokkalis, K. Romann, J. Nedić, A. J. Higgins · 2024

Read Cavitation Onset in an Impulsively Accelerated Liquid Column by T. Sobral, J. Kokkalis, K. Romann, J. Nedić, A. J. Higgins (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10332.txt.

Introduction

A liquid slammed upward into a trapped gas pocket can tear itself apart into bubbles, a process called cavitation. Taj Sobral and co-authors built a piston rig to catch that moment in a 2024 paper. Fast cameras and pressure sensors watch the liquid column as it hits the gas. The column slows hard, and its pressure plunges below zero into tension.

A new model treats the column as a spring and mass, which captures how squeeze waves run inside it. Waves bouncing between the column's ends build the tension that starts the bubbles. Old single-number rules failed to predict the onset in their rig. The spring model called it right across test settings. The team maps the mechanism in both lab and model runs.

Catalog record

CREATORT. Sobral, J. Kokkalis, K. Romann, J. Nedić, A. J. Higgins
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10332

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cavitation Onset in an Impulsively Accelerated Liquid Column Preprint: AIP/123-QED T. Sobral, J. Kokkalis, K. Romann, J. Nedić, A. J. Higgins Abstract This paper introduces a novel piston-driven apparatus to study the onset of cavitation in an impulsively accelerated liquid column as it compresses a closed gas volume. The experiment is monitored using high-speed videography and piezoelectric pressure transducers. Cavitation onset is observed in the liquid column as it undergoes an abrupt deceleration and is associated with a sudden drop in pressure in the liquid that leads to negative pressure (tension). A novel numerical modeling approach is introduced where the liquid column is treated as a spring-mass system. This approach can reproduce compressibility effects in the liquid column and is used to investigate the wave dynamics responsible for the onset of tension and cavitation in the liquid column. The model is formulated as a coupled set of non-linear differential equations that reproduce the dynamics of an experiment while capturing the pressure wave activity in the liquid column. A parametric study is conducted experimentally and numerically to investigate the behavior behind the onset of cavitation. The mechanism for the onset of cavitation is identified as a series of wave reflections at the boundaries of the liquid column, and this mechanism is found to be well reproduced by the model. While a traditional cavitation number criterion is shown to be unable to predict cavitation onset in our experiment, our numerical model is found to correctly predict the onset of cavitation for a wide range of experimental parameters. I Introduction Liquids can vaporize through two distinct physical processes: increasing the temperature above the saturation vapor/liquid temperature or decreasing the pressure below the vapor pressure Brennen 2013 . While the former is the commonly known phenomenon of boiling , the latter is common only in particular engineering applications and some natural phenomena and is known as cavitation . From a thermodynamic point of view, these two processes are almost equivalent. However, most research has been focused specifically on understanding cavitation due to its ubiquity in many hydrodynamic phenomena. Applications include hydraulic propellers and pumps Brennen 2011 , underwater explosions Cole 1965 , medical imagery and treatment Roovers et al. 2019 , and auto-injector devices Veilleux and Shepherd 2018 . Early research on cavitation dates back to the late 1800s, with cavitation in the wake of ship propellers causing a drop in performance and significant damage to the propeller Trevena 1984 ; Brennen 2013 . It is now well known that cavitation may occur in any liquid flow where the speed is such that the local static pressure drops below the vapor pressure Brennen 2011 ; Brennen 2013 ; Knapp 1958 . In practice, this can occur in the wake of propellers, behind any fast-moving underwater object, and in Venturi tubes Knapp 1958 . In such flows, it is common to introduce the following cavitation number Brennen 2011 ; Brennen 2013 ; Pan et al. 2017 based on the dynamic pressure drop in a flowing liquid: \mathrm{\sigma}=\frac{p_{1}-p_{\mathrm{v}}}{\frac{1}{2}\,\rho_{\ell}\,U^{2}}, (1) where \rho_{\ell} is the density of the liquid, p_{\mathrm{v}} is its vapor pressure, U is the velocity of the flow, and p_{1} is the reference static pressure. Although the threshold value of \sigma below which the flow will cavitate varies across applications, it is generally understood Pan et al. 2017 ; Garcia-Atance Fatjo 2016 that cavitation will occur where \sigma\ll 1 . Beyond these engineering applications, much research has been conducted on the physics of liquids in tension Berthelot 1850 ; Trevena 1978 ; Frenkel 1955 ; Bull 1956 ; Knapp 1958 ; Skripov 1974 ; Couzens and Trevena 1974 ; Trevena 1984 ; Richards, Trevena, and Edwards 1980 ; Joseph 1998 . Theoretical studies Joseph 1998 ; Skripov 1974 ; Frenkel 1955 of pure liquids found that liquids should be able to sustain tensions on the order of 10^{4} bar. This is well beyond what has been seen experimentally, with the first experimental study conducted in 1849 by Berthelot yielding values of up to 50 bar Berthelot 1850 ; Trevena 1978 . Since then, many other experimental studies Trevena 1984 ; Couzens and Trevena 1974 ; Richards, Trevena, and Edwards 1980 ; Bull 1956 ; Williams and Williams 2004 have shown that liquids can undergo values of tension on the order of 1 – 10^{3} bar. This is commonly done experimentally by generating a shock directed toward a free surface that reflects as a rarefaction wave, putting the liquid in a state of tension. This has been done through the use of a detonation tube Richards, Trevena, and Edwards 1980 , a bullet-piston apparatus Bull 1956 ; Trevena 1984 ; Couzens and Trevena 1974 ; Williams and Williams 2004 , and more recently on silicone oils using plate-impact experiments Huneault and Higgins 2019 . Although many studies have been conducted to quantify the tension that liquids can sustain before cavitating, significant discrepancies still exist in the literature Huneault and Higgins 2019 ; Williams and Williams 2004 . This disagreement is generally explained by arguments on the purity of the fluid Brennen 2013 , the adhesive force between the liquid and the wall Trevena 1978 ; Trevena 1984 , or the rate of stress that the liquid is subjected to Trevena 1984 . In particular, solid or gaseous inclusions in the liquid can act as nucleation sites that decrease the threshold tension for the liquid to cavitate Brennen 2013 ; Knapp 1958 ; Trevena 1984 . Figure 1: Experimental apparatus. (a) Schematic of experimental apparatus, (b) schematic representation of the experiment test section showing key behavior and parameters (dimensions not to scale). Recently, some experimental studies have been interested in the onset of cavitation caused by acceleration in liquid columns Garcia-Atance Fatjo 2016 ; Pan et al. 2017 ; Xu et al. 2020 ; Qi-Dai and Long 2004 ; Veilleux and Shepherd 2018 . These experiments, though qualitatively similar to the shock tube and bullet-piston methods, differ from them in that the accelerations involved are too small to generate shock waves. One common method, the tube-arrest method, consists in partially filling a container with liquid and accelerating the container downward by a sharp impact, thus creating tension directly by forcing the bottom wall away from the liquid. Studies using this technique found that cavitation occurs at the bottom interface between the liquid and the solid wall of the container Pan et al. 2017 ; Qi-Dai and Long 2004 . Other methods such as drop-tube and surface piston impact are more analogous to the bullet-piston experiment. They consist in sending a compressive pulse through the liquid that eventually reflects off of a free surface as a rarefaction wave that puts the liquid in a state of tension Veilleux and Shepherd 2018 ; Pan et al. 2017 . Results with these two methods generally show cavitation in the bulk of the liquid, not limited to the liquid-solid interface Veilleux and Shepherd 2018 ; Pan et al. 2017 . For such applications, an alternative cavitation number was introduced by Fatjo Garcia-Atance Fatjo 2016 . It is analogous to the cavitation number \sigma introduced in Eq. 1 but replaces the dynamic pressure in the denominator with the water-hammer pressure obtained from

Read the complete text