Efficiency and Mechanism of heat flux rectification with non-reciprocal surface waves in Weyl-Semi-Metals

A. Naeimi, S.-A. Biehs · 2024

Read Efficiency and Mechanism of heat flux rectification with non-reciprocal surface waves in Weyl-Semi-Metals by A. Naeimi, S.-A. Biehs (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-10026.txt.

Introduction

Naeimi and Biehs reinvestigate, in 2024, how one-way surface waves can make heat flow easier in one direction than the other. The setup pairs two tiny particles of a special semimetal with a flat surface of the same kind. Earlier work had reported a strong rectification effect for this near-field heat transfer.

The authors first correct that earlier figure, then show the effect can be far larger at some spacings. A range of strong backward rectification was also found that others had missed. They trace the mechanism and test how it responds to material traits and heat. Some materials could reach very high ratios, marking them as strong candidates.

Catalog record

CREATORA. Naeimi, S.-A. Biehs
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-10026

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Efficiency and Mechanism of heat flux rectification with non-reciprocal surface waves in Weyl-Semi-Metals A. Naeimi, S.-A. Biehs Abstract We reinvestigate the mechanism of near-field heat transfer rectification between two Weyl semimetal nanoparticles and a planar Weyl semimetal substrate via the coupling to non-reciprocal surface modes. We first show that the previously predicted rectification ratio of 2673 is incorrect and should rather be 1502. Furthermore we show that depending on the distance between the nanoparticles there can be a much more efficient heat flux rectification with ratios of about 6000. Furthermore, we identify a previously overlooked range of forward rectification and a range of strong backward rectification with rectification ratios larger than 8000 for relatively small Weyl node separations. We investigate the mechanism behind this large heat flux rectification and study its sensitivity with respect to certain material parameters and temperature showing that even larger rectification ratios up to 15000 are possible highlighting that certain Weyl semimetals are strong candidates for highly efficient heat flux rectification. I Introduction Different thermal rectification mechanisms for heat radiation in the nanoscale regime have been studied which of course also, in general, work in far-field setups. One mechanism is to use the intrinsic temperature dependence of the material properties of the involved materials FanRectification2010 ; Iizuka2012 ; BasuEtAl2011 ; WangEtAl2013 which can lead to a very large heat flux rectification, i.e. a diode-like effect, when the involved elements undergo a phase transition as superconductors Nefzaoui2014 ; OrdonezEtAl2017 or phase change materials like VO 2 as studied theoretically and experimentally in Refs. PBASAB2013 ; Yangetal2013 ; ItoEtAl ; FiorinoEtAl2018 . Such diode like elements can also function as thermal transistors for heat radiation PBASABtransistor as experimentally verified in a far-field setup Yungui . Interestingly, also asymmetric many-body systems can show a thermal rectification Ivan . Another possibility to achieve thermal rectification for heat radiation is to employ magneto-opcial materials which have a non-reciprocal material response when an external magnetic field is applied. This non-reciprocal property results in interesting properties of near- and far-field thermal radiation. For example it could be shown that in thermal equilibrium there is a persistent heat current Zhu2016 , spin and angular momentum Silveirinha ; Ottcircular2018 , a Hall effect for heat radiation PBAHall2016 , spin-directional thermal emission DongEtAl2021 , a giant magneto-resistance Latella2017 ; Cuevas , a Berry phase of thermal radiation SABPBABerry2022 as well as a non-reciprocal version of the Green-Kubo relation Herz . Also the impact on the heat radiation between planar films and multilayers with an applied magnetic field has been studied MoncadaEtAl2015 ; FanEtAl2020 ; QuEtAl2024 as well as the heat flux between a magneto-optical nanoparticle and planar substrate Raul2 . Finally, the coupling to non-reciprocal surface modes allows for a strong heat flux rectification Ottdiode2019 due to the spin-spin coupling OttSpin2020 to the non-reciprocal surface waves which are spin-momentum locked Mechelen ; Zubin2019 . All those works show that the magnetic field provides a mean to control the magnitude and direction of the radiative heat flux actively(see also reviews OttReview2019 ; SABRMP2021 ). The existence of intrinsically non-reciprocal materials such as the Weyl semimetals (WSM) ChenEtAl2016 ; Kotov2018 allows for realizing the same effects as found for magneto-optical materials but without the need of an externally applied magnetic field. Consequently, it could be shown that there is a photonic spin hall effect DaEtAl2021 , an anomalous Hall effect for thermal radiation OttAnomalous2020 , modulated heat transfer between slabs and multilayers TangEtAl2021 ; XuEtal2020 ; YuEtAlMultilayer2022 ; YuEtAl3B2022 ; Sheng2023 , negative differential thermal conductance SunEtAl , the possibility to enable thermal routing GuoEtAl2020 , non-reciprocal absorption and emission ZhaoEtAl2020 ; ZhangZhu2023 , broadband circularly polarized thermal radiation Zubin , non-reciprocal far-field heat radiation WuEtAl2022 , and coupling to graphene nanoribbons YuEtAl2023 . These and other effects are reviewed in Ref. GuoEtAl2023 ; DidariEtAl2024 , for instance. Of course, there is also a thermal rectification due to the coupling to non-reciprocal surface HuEtAl2023 . The heat flux rectification is predicted to be more efficient for WSM than for magneto-optical materials like InSb HuEtAl2023 . The aim of our work is to provide a detailed study of the thermal rectification of the heat flux between two WSM nanoparticles by the interaction with the non-reciprocal surface waves of a close by planar WSM sample as sketched in Fig. 1 and first studied for InSb in Refs. Ottdiode2019 ; OttSpin2020 and for WSM in Ref. HuEtAl2023 . We explain the underlying mechanism on the basis of the properties of the involved surface modes and show that the thermal rectification ratios found in Ref. HuEtAl2023 and in particular the value of 2673 are incorrect. In the same range of parameters as in Ref. HuEtAl2023 we find much lower values than in the original work HuEtAl2023 . However, by changing the interparticle distance we show that rectification ratios of about 6000 can be obtained. Furthermore, we show that a regime of high rectification for small values of the Weyl node separation has been overlooked previously, which can easily lead to rectification ratios of about 8000. Our results are substantiated with an analysis of the contribution of the surface modes which qualitatively explains our observations. Finally, in a parameter analysis we demonstrate that even rectification ratios of 15000 are realizable in the studied parameter regime underlining, on the one hand, the fact that WSMs are in general strong candidates for heat flux rectification without the necessity of applying external magnetic fields and on the other our analysis helps to identify the best WSM for a strong heat flux rectification. Figure 1: Sketch of our physical system consisting of two spherical nanoparticles with Radius R and temperatures T_{1} , T_{2} placed at -d/2 and d/2 in a height h above a planar substrate. The substrate and the nanoparticles are made of the same WSM and the temperature of the substrate is at temperature T_{s} . In the forward case T_{1}>T_{2} and T_{s}=T_{2} whereas in the backward case T_{2}>T_{1} and T_{s}=T_{1} . The Weyl node separation \mathbf{b}=b\hat{y} is aligned in positive y direction. Our work is structured in the following way: In Sec. II we introduce the heat flux expression for two non-reciprocal nanoparticles above a non-reciprocal planar sample within dipole approximation. In Sec. III we define the used permittivity of WSMs and introduce the parameters used for numerical calculations. The localized resonances in the nanoparticles and the surface waves in the planar sample are discussed in Sec. IV followed by a detailed discussion of the heat flux rectification in Sec. V. Finally, in Sec. VI study the impact of the Weyl nodes separation, the number of Weyl nodes, Fermi energy, dissipation, and temperature on the rectification ratio. II Near-field radiative heat transfer Within the framework of fluctuational electrodynamics the radiative heat flux between dipolar objects each at local thermal equilibrium has been studied intensively and general expressions for the mean power received by each dipolar object have been derived SABRMP2021 . Considering only two dipolar objects having local equilibrium temperatures T_{1} and T_{2}<T_{1} in close vicinity to an interface at temperature T_{s}=T_{2} (see forward case in Fig. 1 ) the power P_{2} received by object 2 has the general form SABRMP2021 P_{2}=3\int_{0}^{\infty}\!\!\frac{{\rm d}\omega}{2\pi}\hbar\omega n_{1}\mathcal{T}_{12}

Read the complete text