Improving the predictive power of empirical shell-model Hamiltonians
J. A. Purcell, B. A. Brown, B. C. He, S. R. Stroberg, W. B. Walters · 2024
Read Improving the predictive power of empirical shell-model Hamiltonians by J. A. Purcell, B. A. Brown, B. C. He, S. R. Stroberg, W. B. Walters (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-09917.txt.
Introduction
Purcell, Brown, He, Stroberg, and Walters improve empirical shell model Hamiltonians in two thousand twenty-four. The shell model predicts nuclear traits from a fitted Hamiltonian. Sparse calibration data can blunt those predictions for rare nuclei. Two upgrades here sharpen the fit for such lean cases.
A better ab initio start point lifts the whole optimization. That start comes from a fresh route to effective Hamiltonians. A protocol against overfitting guards the fit as well. Extrapolation past known data thus rests on firmer ground. Exotic isotopes at rare beam sites and in stars are the prize.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. A. Purcell, B. A. Brown, B. C. He, S. R. Stroberg, W. B. Walters |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-09917
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Improving the predictive power of empirical shell-model Hamiltonians J. A. Purcell, B. A. Brown, B. C. He, S. R. Stroberg, W. B. Walters Abstract We present two developments which enhance the predictive power of empirical shell model Hamiltonians for cases in which calibration data is sparse. A recent improvement in the 𝑎𝑏𝑖𝑛𝑖𝑡𝑖𝑜 {\it abinitio} derivation of effective Hamiltonians leads to a much better starting point for the optimization procedure. In addition, we introduce a protocol to avoid over-fitting, enabling a more reliable extrapolation beyond available data. These developments will enable more robust predictions for exotic isotopes produced at rare isotope beam facilities and in astrophysical environments. I Introduction The nuclear shell model is a ubiquitous framework for interpreting nuclear structure data. In particular, the interacting shell model, or configuration interaction (CI) approach quantitatively reproduces and explains a vast amount of spectroscopic data. These CI calculations require the specification of an effective Hamiltonian. While ab initio methods have made great progress recently in deriving these Hamiltonians from the underlying inter-nucleon interactions, they have not yet achieved the precision obtained with phenomenological Hamiltonians adjusted to data. The gold standard for the phenomenological CI paradigm is the Universal- sd (USD) family of Hamiltonians sd06 ; mag20 , which reproduce spectra with a root-mean-squared deviation of better than 200 keV. In this relatively small model space, the vast amount of available data is more than sufficient to constrain the parameters of the Hamiltonian. In contrast, many of the nuclei that will be studied in the coming decades at rare isotope facilities, including the majority of nuclei relevant for r -process nucleosynthesis, will live in larger model spaces where data are sparse. This increases the importance of maximizing predictive power with minimal data. In addition, the information content of various experimental data is often redundant, in terms of which parameters are constrained; in order to reliably extrapolate beyond the available data it is critical to avoid over-fitting. In this paper, we (1) demonstrate that an improved ab initio calculation He24 provides a starting point which requires fewer phenomenological adjustments, and (2) utilize a training/testing partitioning scheme to avoid over-fitting. In section II we discuss the goals and methodology of this work, including the form of our Hamiltonian constructed from {\it abinitio} methods, and the singular-value decomposition (SVD) method for improving the Hamiltonian by constraints to experimental data. Section III presents the mathematical methods used for the \chi^{2} minimization and the SVD fitting algorithm. Section IV is concerned with the experimental data that was used, including a discussion justifying the inclusion and exclusion of certain observed energy levels. Our results are presented in section V, and conclusions are given in section VI. Section VII (Appendix) presents a collection of all spectra obtained with our final Hamiltonian in comparison to experimental data. II Methods Microscopic configuration-interaction (CI) calculations for specific regions of nuclei are based on a description in terms of a selected set of shell-model orbitals (the model space) with a Hamiltonian operator H=E_{0}+\sum_{\alpha}\epsilon_{\alpha}\hat{n}_{\alpha}+\sum_{\alpha\leq\beta,\gamma\leq\delta}\sum_{J}V_{J}(\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta)\hat{T}_{J}(\alpha\beta;\delta\gamma) that is represented by the energy of the closed core E_{0} , single-particle energies (SPE) \epsilon_{\alpha} , and two-body matrix elements (TBME) V_{J}(\alpha\beta;\gamma\delta) : In principle, three-body matrix elements could be included, but they dramatically increase the complexity of the problem, and their main effect is to modify the SPE and TBME, so they are generally not treated explicitly. The SPE and TBME can be obtained from a realistic NN (possibly with 3N) interaction, renormalized to the valence space in some way, for example using many-body perturbation theory Hjorth-Jensen1995 , shell model coupled cluster Sun2018 , or the valence-space in-medium similarity renormalization group (VS-IMSRG) sr19 . We use the latter approach in this work, including the effects of 3N interactions via the normal-ordered two-body (NO2B) approximation. This leads to values for E_{0} , \epsilon and V_{J} which are nucleus-dependent sr19 . A commonly applied approximation when optimizing empirical Hamiltonians is to use a nucleus-independent set of SPE and TBME. The TBME may include some smooth mass dependence, e.g. A^{-0.3} sd06 ; mag20 ; fp04 ; jun45 ; jj44b . Within this approximation the SPE and TBME can be used as parameters to achieve an improved description of measured binding energies and excitation energies (energy data) with the goal of obtaining improved wavefunctions and improved predictions for new energy data and for other observables. The singular-value decomposition (SVD) method provides a systematic approach for finding the most important linear combinations of the N_{p} SPE and TBME parameters which can be determined by the data Arima1968 ; Wildenthal1984 ; mag20 . One starts with wavefunctions obtained from a Hamiltonian derived from the best available ab-initio input. With these wavefunctions, the expectation value of the Hamiltonian provides a linear combination of SPE and TBME for each of the N_{d} energy data. The SVD amounts to a diagonalization of the N_{p}\times N_{p} fit matrix solution to \chi^{2} minimization, and provides singular values and associated eigenvectors (linear combinations of SPE and TBME). The largest singular values are associated with the most well-determined linear combinations, and smallest singular values are associated with the least well-determined combinations. The TBME associated with these least well-determined combinations will have some influence on the extrapolations to new energy data and to the calculations of other observables. One must choose a singular value cut-off N_{c} . Below the cut-off one can use TBME obtained from the best available ab-initio input. This provides a new set of SPE and TBME that can be used to obtain an improved set of wavefunctions. One iterates the SVD fits and the wavefunction calculations until convergence. Examples of Hamiltonians obtained in this way with protons and neutrons are, USDA/B sd06 and USDC/I mag20 for the \{0d_{5/2},0d_{3/2},1s_{1/2}\} (sd) model space, GPFX1A fp04 for the \{0f_{7/2},0f_{5/2},1p_{3/2},1p_{1/2}\} ( fp ) model space, and JUN45 jun45 and jj44b (Appendix A of jj44b ) for the \{0f_{5/2},1p_{3/2},1p_{1/2},0g_{9/2}\} ( jj44 ) model space. For all of these Hamiltonians the root-mean-square deviation (RMSD) between the calculated and experimental energy data is 150-200 keV. This is to be compared with the results of {\it abinitio} type calculations over the same regions of nuclei where the RMSD is much larger (see Fig. 9 of sr19 for the sd model space). In all of these cases, there is abundant experimental data to constrain the fitted Hamiltonian across the entire model space. However, for very exotic nuclei relevant for rare isotope beam facilities and r -process nucleosynthesis, the data will be sparse and strongly biased toward the most stable region of the model space. In such cases, it is possible to overfit to the available data, yielding a Hamiltonian that extrapolates poorly to more exotic nuclei. In this paper, we demonstrate that by using an improved ab-initio starting point and by reserving some data for validation, we can improve the predictive power of the resulting Hamiltonian when extrapolating beyond the fit data. For our application, we consider data for low-lying states for all nuclei between 78 Ni and 100 Sn that can be described by protons in \{0f_{5/2},1p_{3/2},1p_{1/2},0g_{9/2}\} (the \pi j4 model space), which requires 4 SPE and 65 TBME with T=1 associated with the valence protons. This space has been considered previously with SVD derived Hamiltonians jun45 ;