Do Λ C C \Lambda_{CC} and G G run?
John F. Donoghue · 2024
Read Do Λ C C \Lambda_{CC} and G G run? by John F. Donoghue (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-08773.txt.
Introduction
John Donoghue answers a short question in a brief 2024 note: do the cosmological constant and Newton's constant run in real reactions? Running would mean changing with energy. His answer is no. The note is written as a teaching piece. It lays out in plain terms why these two constants should not be treated as running parameters when physicists compute what actually happens in a physical process.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | John F. Donoghue |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-08773
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Do Λ C C \Lambda_{CC} and G G run? John F. Donoghue Abstract No I Introduction When renormalizing coupling constants, one often finds a scale dependence such that the coupling constant measured at one energy scale will have large corrections when used in reactions at a different scale. The use of a running coupling will capture this scale dependence and will describe the correct coupling constant to be used at all energy scales. In the gravitational interactions there are often attempts to make G and \Lambda_{CC} into running couplings and to use the running versions in phenomenology 1 1 1 A representative but incomplete set of examples in favor of running behavior is [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] , and arguments against running are found in [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] . . That is the topic of this short note. The one word abstract used above is meant to capture the essential point of this discussion. By itself it does not capture the full nuances of the discussion, which is the goal of the rest of this paper. One can always make theoretical constructs which look like running couplings, and these may have some utility in certain contexts. But the question of the title, and the answer of the abstract, is meant to refer to running in the same sense that we use running couplings such as the QCD coupling in the Standard Model - as running couplings describing the changes with the energy scale of physical amplitudes induced by quantum corrections. As usual, energy and distance scales are inversely related, so this would apply to distance dependent couplings in gravity. II Varieties of running There are various techniques used when describing running coupling constants, and in the most familiar settings these give the same results. This similarity leads to a lack of focus on the physics when dealing with somewhat non-standard settings. In this section, I give a review of these techniques with a focus on their differences, using a conventional example. I will distinguish physical running which refers to running of physical amplitudes with the energy scale of the problem, cutoff running when using dimensional cutoffs for regularization and \mu running when using dimensional regularization. I will also use the Passarino-Veltman reduction to highlight the differences of scalar tadpole and scalar bubble diagrams, and will describe non-local effective actions as the way to describe running parameters. II.1 Example - chiral perturbation theory A sample theory which is useful to use as an example is chiral perturbation theory - the low energy limit of QCD describing the interactions of spin-zero particles called pions. It is a non-linear effective field theory which has many similarities to general relativity. It has also been studied theoretically and experimentally for decades, so that we know exactly how it works. The theory satisfies a chiral symmetry, which need not be described here (see for example [ 15 , 16 , 17 ] ) but leads to an effective Lagrangian which can be described in a derivative expansion. For massless pions, this has the form \displaystyle{\cal L} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\cal L}_{2}+{\cal L}_{4}+{\cal L}_{6}+{\cal L}_{8}+\ldots (1) \displaystyle= \displaystyle{F^{2}\over 4}\mathop{\rm Tr}\left(\partial_{\mu}U\partial^{\mu}U^{\dagger}\right)+\ell_{1}[\mathop{\rm Tr}\left(\partial_{\mu}U\partial^{\mu}U^{\dagger}\right)]^{2} \displaystyle+\ell_{2}\mathop{\rm Tr}\left(\partial_{\mu}U\partial_{\nu}U^{\dagger}\right)\cdot\mathop{\rm Tr}\left(\partial^{\mu}U\partial^{\nu}U^{\dagger}\right)+\ldots\ \ . Here the pion fields are described by an exponential function U(x)=\exp\left(i\frac{\tau\cdot\phi}{F}\right)\ \ . (2) The constant F is called the pion decay constant, F\sim 93 MeV. Because it multiplies the two derivative Lagrangian, it plays the role that the Planck mass does in general relativity with F^{2} being roughly identified with 1/G\sim M_{P}^{2} . The coefficients \ell_{1},~\ell_{2} multiply terms of order 4 derivatives, in analogy with the curvature squared terms of general relativity. This effective field theory of pions behaves similarly to the effective field theory of general relativity [ 18 , 19 ] . Physical processes are independent of the method regularizing the divergences of the theory. The functional form can depend on the ways that we chose to define and measure the coupling constants - i.e. the renormalization scheme - but the content of the resulting formulas are the same. For example, using a particular renormalization scheme defining the couplings at s=t=u=\mu_{R}^{2} all regularization methods would yield the amplitude for \pi^{+}+\pi^{0}\to\pi^{+}+\pi^{0} as [ 17 ] \displaystyle{\cal M} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{t\over F^{2}}+\left[8\ell^{r}_{1}(\mu_{R})+2\ell_{2}^{r}(\mu_{R})\right]{t^{2}\over F^{4}} (3) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle 2\ell_{2}^{r}(\mu_{R})\frac{s(s-u)+u(u-s)}{F^{4}} \displaystyle- \displaystyle{1\over 96\pi^{2}F^{4}}\left[3t^{2}\ln{-t\over\mu_{R}^{2}}+s(s-u)\ln{-s\over\mu_{R}^{2}}+u(u-s)\ln{-u\over\mu_{R}^{2}}\right]\ \ , with s,~t,~u being the usual Mandelstam variables. However, there will be differences on how different regularization methods arrive at this result, and I will describe these differences in the following subsections. The scattering amplitude contains the visible results of a power counting theorem of Weinberg [ 20 ] . Higher loops renormalize higher order operators in the effective Lagrangian. In particular one loop corrections renormalize the operators of order (\rm energy)^{4} but not the leading term of order E^{2} . We see this in the amplitude because the divergences and the logs appear at order E^{4} . The gravitational effective field theory has a similar power counting theorem, and we will see that it is relevant to the topic of this paper. Weinberg’s theorem uses dimensional regularization in its proof, because that method does not introduce any powers of dimensionful parameters. We will see that cutoff regularization violates this. But because all physical quantities are independent of regularization method, powers of the cutoff must be absorbed into renormalized constants without leaving behind any physical remnant in amplitudes. II.2 Physical running In particle physics, the use of running couplings refers to the dependence of physical processes on the energy scale. When a reaction is observed at some energy scale, one uses a running coupling appropriate for that energy. This captures the quantum processes relevant for that energy and avoids the appearance of large logarithms which could spoil perturbation theory. This use is visible in the amplitude of Eq. 3 . The coefficients \ell_{1},~\ell_{2} could have been measured to be particular values near some renormalization scale \mu_{R} , but when applied at energies which are far different one should use different values determined by the renormalization group in order to avoid the appearance of large logarithms. The physical invariance of the scattering amplitude leads to the beta functions \displaystyle\beta_{\ell_{1}}=\mu_{R}\frac{\partial}{\partial\mu_{R}}\ell_{1}=-\frac{1}{96\pi^{2}} \displaystyle\beta_{\ell_{2}}=\mu_{R}\frac{\partial}{\partial\mu_{R}}\ell_{2}=-\frac{1}{192\pi^{2}} (4) These are typical running couplings. The running of yet higher order chiral logarithms is also well understood in chiral perturbation theory [ 21 ] . However, one can also see that F does not run. The portion of the amplitude which is governed by F has no energy dependence. If we measure F at one energy scale, the same value can be used at all energies. The beta function for the leading order coupling is \beta_{F}=\mu_{R}\frac{\partial}{\partial\mu_{R}}F=0 (5) II.3 Cutoff running If one uses an energy cutoff in describing quantum corrections, the results for any observable will depend on the cutoff for any finite value of the cutoff. One can consider lattice calculations within QCD as an archetype for this. The lattice spacing a provides a UV cutoff of order \Lambda\sim 1/a . The calculation of F or any other parameter will depend on a when calculated at finite values of a . The physical value is obtained by