Utilizing Multi-Step Loss for Single Image Reflection Removal
Abdelrahman Elnenaey, Marwan Torki · 2024
Read Utilizing Multi-Step Loss for Single Image Reflection Removal by Abdelrahman Elnenaey, Marwan Torki (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-08582.txt.
Introduction
Abdelrahman Elnenaey and Marwan Torki improve reflection removal from a single photo with a new training loss. Their twenty twenty-four paper skips architecture tweaks and attacks the training itself. Reflections off glass can wreck object detection and scene splitting downstream.
Their multi-step loss grades the cleanup at several stages, not just the end. It should transfer to other image-to-image tasks where input and output look alike. Training data for this task is scarce, so they built a synthetic set with a generative model. A depth map of the scene joins as a helper signal. Together the tricks teach the model finer patterns of glass glare.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Abdelrahman Elnenaey, Marwan Torki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-08582
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Utilizing Multi-Step Loss for Single Image Reflection Removal Abdelrahman Elnenaey, Marwan Torki Abstract Image reflection removal is crucial for restoring image quality. Distorted images can negatively impact tasks like object detection and image segmentation. In this paper, we present a novel approach for image reflection removal using a single image. Instead of focusing on model architecture, we introduce a new training technique that can be generalized to image-to-image problems, with input and output being similar in nature. This technique is embodied in our multi-step loss mechanism, which has proven effective in the reflection removal task. Additionally, we address the scarcity of reflection removal training data by synthesizing a high-quality, non-linear synthetic dataset called RefGAN using Pix2Pix GAN. This dataset significantly enhances the model’s ability to learn better patterns for reflection removal. We also utilize a ranged depth map, extracted from the depth estimation of the ambient image, as an auxiliary feature, leveraging its property of lacking depth estimations for reflections. Our approach demonstrates superior performance on the S I R 2 SIR^{2} benchmark and other real-world datasets, proving its effectiveness by outperforming other state-of-the-art models. † † address: Department of Computer and Systems Engineering Faculty of Engineering, Alexandria University Alexandria, Egypt Knights Lab [email protected], [email protected] 1 Introduction In the realm of computer vision, unwanted reflections in images present significant challenges for applications such as object recognition, image segmentation, scene understanding, and augmented reality. Reflections, which occur due to light interactions with various surfaces, distort visual content and degrade the performance of algorithms that rely on clear images. For example, reflections can obscure features crucial for object detection, introduce ambiguities in scene layout interpretation, and cause misalignment in augmented reality overlays. Traditional reflection removal methods often require multiple images or sophisticated hardware, making them impractical in scenarios where only a single image is available. This paper proposes a novel approach to single-image reflection removal, first introducing a multi-step loss mechanism that offers a more representative training loss and can be generalized to other image-to-image translation tasks with similar input and output characteristics. This mechanism significantly improves model performance and generalization. To address the lack of diverse datasets for training, the paper introduces the RefGAN dataset, synthesized using Pix2Pix GAN, which provides a wide range of reflection patterns and intensities to enhance model robustness. Finally, the approach is further enhanced by using a Ranged Depth Map that excludes reflections from depth estimation, focusing solely on the actual scene content (see Figure 1 ). The dataset is now available at our GitHub repository. github.com/SIRR_MSloss_RefGAN_RDM . Figure 1: (c) is the estimated depth map for the ambient image –(a)–, (d) is the ranged depth map with k=4. The main contributions of this paper can be distilled into three key points: • We introduce a multi-step loss mechanism, which enhances the learning process by accumulating losses over multiple steps, resulting in improved performance and generalization. • We synthesize the RefGAN dataset, which significantly augments the diversity and complexity of the training data, further boosting the robustness and effectiveness of our proposed method. • We propose the utilization of a Ranged Depth Map for guiding the reflection removal process, effectively excluding reflections and focusing on the actual scene content. The structure of the paper is as follows: Section 2 reviews related work, Section 3 details the proposed approach and dataset synthesis, Section 4 presents experiments and results, and Section 5 concludes with future research directions. Figure 2: The architecture of our method. The Depth module estimates the depth of the ambient image. The RDepth module extracts the ranged depth map from the generated depth map. The R-CNN network predicts the reflection. The T-CNN predicts the target. The blue arrows resembles the multi-step loss mechanism during training. 2 Related Work Non-machine learning based methods Non-machine learning methods include region-aware techniques combining content and gradient information for enhanced precision, as seen in [ 1 ] , and methods that remove reflections and artifacts using non-flash ambient images [ 2 ] . Another approach leverages depth of field guidance to distinguish in-focus and reflective regions [ 3 ] . Single image reflection removal methods Single image reflection removal methods began with CeilNet [ 4 ] utilizing deep learning to predict reflection-free images without handcrafted features. Perceptual losses were later introduced to improve the quality of reflection removal [ 5 ] . Other advancements include convolutional encoder-decoder networks [ 6 ] , and ERRNet [ 7 ] , which improved performance on misaligned real-world data. Further developments include cascaded refinement methods [ 8 ] , semantic-guided prediction [ 9 ] , and novel architectures with reflection detection and recurrent modules [ 10 ] . Recent work introduced self-attention mechanisms and local discrimination loss for more effective reflection separation [ 11 ] . In [ 12 ] , a screen-blur combination technique is used for better simulation of reflection characteristics, with SRNet developed to disentangle the reflection and transmission layers. The paper [ 13 ] introduces a deep variational inference reflection removal (VIRR) method, which is the first to use this approach, focusing on learning latent distributions for better interpretability. Flash/no-Flash image reflection removal methods Flash/no-Flash methods utilize pairs of flash and ambient images, extracting flash-only images to estimate transmission images without reflections, as demonstrated in [ 14 ] . 3 Approach Understanding the critical impact of loss functions on the training process, our approach emphasizes the employment of a multi-step loss mechanism to address the shortcomings of conventional loss functions in Single Image Reflection Removal (SIRR). SIRR models often struggle with accurately removing reflections due to the lack of a precise loss function, where the loss function may output a small loss even if the model outputs the input image unchanged. To overcome this, we introduce a multi-step loss function, which iteratively takes the output as input for successive steps, accumulating the loss at each step. Unlike averaging or smoothing the loss across multiple steps, this approach amplifies the loss for incorrectly removed reflections, providing a more representative measure of the model’s performance in challenging cases. The model’s ability to handle varied reflection intensities is significantly enhanced by observing different reflection ratios in each step for each image, leading to improved overall performance. Our proposed architecture comprises two main modules: the Ranged Map Estimation Module and the Reflection Removal Module. The Ranged Map Estimation Module is responsible for deriving the Ranged Depth Map from the ambient image. We employed a pretrained Midas Small [ 15 ] model to calculate the initial depth map, and subsequently, each pixel in this map is assigned a specific range, forming the Ranged Depth Map. It is important to note that the values in the Ranged Depth Map are non-trainable, ensuring consistent depth estimation throughout the process. Each pixel in the estimated depth map is mapped to a previously constructed range of pixels. The number of ranges is a hyperparameter. Referring to Table 4 , the ideal number of ranges is inferred to be four. The intuition behind using the Ranged Depth Map is that it lacks any estimations for reflections, which helps the model effectively extract the target scene from the ambient image. Moreover, the Ranged Depth Map helps the model to