Outcome-guided spike-and-slab Lasso Biclustering: A Novel Approach for Enhancing Biclustering Techniques for Gene Expression Analysis

Luis A. Vargas-Mieles, Paul D. W. Kirk, Chris Wallace · 2024

Read Outcome-guided spike-and-slab Lasso Biclustering: A Novel Approach for Enhancing Biclustering Techniques for Gene Expression Analysis by Luis A. Vargas-Mieles, Paul D. W. Kirk, Chris Wallace (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-08416.txt.

Introduction

Luis Vargas-Mieles, Paul Kirk, and Chris Wallace improve a method that finds gene groups and patient groups at the same time in a 2024 biostatistics study. Biclustering spots samples that behave alike on a subset of genes, a pattern plain clustering misses because it judges samples on every gene. Their base method uses a spike-and-slab prior with a lasso penalty to switch genes in or out cleanly.

The outcome-guided extension lets a clinical outcome steer which biclusters are worth finding. Patterns tied to prognosis or treatment response matter more than patterns that merely exist, so guidance focuses the search on biology clinicians can use.

Catalog record

CREATORLuis A. Vargas-Mieles, Paul D. W. Kirk, Chris Wallace
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-08416

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Outcome-guided spike-and-slab Lasso Biclustering: A Novel Approach for Enhancing Biclustering Techniques for Gene Expression Analysis Thanks: Cambridge Institute for Therapeutic Immunology and Infectious Disease. Luis A. Vargas-Mieles, Paul D. W. Kirk, Chris Wallace Abstract Biclustering has gained interest in gene expression data analysis due to its ability to identify groups of samples that exhibit similar behaviour in specific subsets of genes (or vice versa), in contrast to traditional clustering methods that classify samples based on all genes. Despite advances, biclustering remains a challenging problem, even with cutting-edge methodologies. This paper introduces an extension of the recently proposed Spike-and-Slab Lasso Biclustering (SSLB) algorithm, termed Outcome-Guided SSLB (OG-SSLB), aimed at enhancing the identification of biclusters in gene expression analysis. Our proposed approach integrates disease outcomes into the biclustering framework through Bayesian profile regression. By leveraging additional clinical information, OG-SSLB improves the interpretability and relevance of the resulting biclusters. Comprehensive simulations and numerical experiments demonstrate that OG-SSLB achieves superior performance, with improved accuracy in estimating the number of clusters and higher consensus scores compared to the original SSLB method. Furthermore, OG-SSLB effectively identifies meaningful patterns and associations between gene expression profiles and disease states. These promising results demonstrate the effectiveness of OG-SSLB in advancing biclustering techniques, providing a powerful tool for uncovering biologically relevant insights. The OGSSLB software can be found as an R/C++ package at https://github.com/luisvargasmieles/OGSSLB . A Preprint 1 Introduction Over the last few decades, the identification of groups that share interesting common characteristics has been a key objective in various real-world applications. Clustering has proven to be a crucial method for discovering these groups that exhibit patterns within high-dimensional data, particularly in the context of large omics datasets [ 46 ] . This technique enables the detection of associations between related entities based on shared features or attributes. One domain of omics in which clustering techniques have been widely employed has been the examination of transcriptomic data, which captures patterns of gene expression levels within biological entities such as tissues or cells [ 17 ] . The need to understand shared transcriptional patterns embedded in gene expression data has led to extensive development of clustering methodologies. Although clustering has been beneficial in revealing hidden patterns within these large-scale datasets, it is not without drawbacks. Among its disadvantages, traditional clustering models assume that samples within a cluster behave similarly across all genes and vice versa. Additionally, clustering often results in a partition of the samples or genes into disjoint subsets. These assumptions may oversimplify the biological system under analysis. Owing to these limitations, biclustering, a methodology that clusters genes and samples simultaneously, has gained more attention in recent years [ 35 ] . This approach allows flexibility in capturing subsets of genes that may behave differently across conditions or subsets of samples that differ according to specific sets of features. Furthermore, biclustering permits overlapping patterns, where genes or samples may belong to multiple biclusters, which more closely matches biological systems. For instance, samples may cluster by sex, disease age and disease state simultaneously, and a single gene may be a member of two or more biological pathways. Several approaches have been proposed to estimate these subgroups of genes and samples, and various reviews of the biclustering methods developed over the past decades exist in the literature (see, e.g., [ 22 , 11 , 32 ] ). Building upon the results of [ 29 ] , this work focuses on the adoption of a multiplicative model, which has proven advantageous in this context. Such models have demonstrated effective capture of diverse sources of variability in gene expression data, including the presence of outlier genes or genes with fluctuating expression levels [ 16 ] . Among the existing algorithms using this methodology, we highlight three: Factor analysis for bicluster acquisition (FABIA) [ 16 ] , the BicMix biclustering method [ 12 ] and Spike-and-Slab Lasso Biclustering (SSLB) [ 26 ] . All three are based on a Bayesian factor analysis model with sparsity-inducing priors that have proven to possess a notable ability to recover latent structures in gene expression data. However, a comparative study by [ 29 ] highlights that SSLB has the advantage of allowing different sparsity levels on each bicluster, in comparison to BicMix, which allows only two levels of sparsity (sparse or dense) for each bicluster, and FABIA, which uses the same sparsity level for all biclusters. Furthermore, while FABIA requires setting the number of biclusters in advance, SSLB (and BicMix) automatically estimates the number of biclusters. Although recent approaches, such as the ones mentioned above, have been shown to be capable of revealing these latent structures within gene expression data, biclustering, in general, is recognised as an NP-hard problem [ 41 , 33 ] . The NP-hardness arises from the challenge of simultaneously grouping rows and columns of a matrix to identify coherent submatrices while considering various constraints and optimisation criteria. Added to the fact that biclusters can also overlap, these difficulties pose a substantial challenge to even the most state-of-the-art methods, further complicating the accurate identification of samples and gene groups that share a common characteristic. One promising approach to mitigate this complexity is the integration of informative outcome data into the clustering process, thereby guiding the inference towards biologically relevant clustering structures. Several outcome-guided clustering methods have been developed in recent years, with applications in K-Means clustering [ 23 ] and gene selection based on survival data [ 18 ] , to mention a few. For additional insights, see [ 3 , 2 ] . In light of these developments, Bayesian profile regression has emerged as another outcome-guided, semi-supervised method for clustering that leverages an outcome variable to inform cluster allocations [ 25 , 20 ] . Unlike some of the previously mentioned approaches, it offers a fully model-based framework that can handle a variety of outcome types, making it more versatile. This approach has already shown success in handling binary covariate data [ 4 ] as well as longitudinal or multivariate continuous outcomes [ 38 ] , making it a valuable tool in the context of gene expression analysis. Building on this success, we explore whether such outcome-guided strategies can also enhance biclustering, where the goal is to simultaneously group genes and samples. Since most gene expression studies also include phenotype information such as age, sex, and disease status, we investigate in this work whether integrating disease outcomes would enhance cluster consistency within specific disease groups. To achieve this, we introduce an outcome-guided version of SSLB by incorporating the disease outcome of the samples into the model via Bayesian profile regression, aiming to better guide the biclustering membership of genes and samples. As we show in numerical and real-data experiments, this integration enhances the accuracy of the SSLB model and refines the biological relevance of the estimated biclusters. The remainder of the paper is organised as follows. Section 2 discusses the current state of biclustering models, particularly within the context of factor analysis models, and explains the SSLB model that we aim to improve. Section 3 highlights the potential contributions of additional data available in most gene expression studies and presents the methodology used in our work, which integrates Bayesian profile regression into the SSLB model,

Read the complete text