Adaptation of Wallace’s approach to the specific heat of elemental solids with significant intrinsic anharmonicity, particularly the light actinide metals
Christopher A. Mizzi, W. Adam Phelan, Matthew S. Cook, Greta L. Chappell, Paul H. Tobash, David C. Arellano, Derek V. Prada, Boris Maiorov, and Neil Harrison · 2024
Read Adaptation of Wallace’s approach to the specific heat of elemental solids with significant intrinsic anharmonicity, particularly the light actinide metals by Christopher A. Mizzi, W. Adam Phelan, Matthew S. Cook, Greta L. Chappell, Paul H. Tobash, David C. Arellano, Derek V. Prada, Boris Maiorov, and Neil Harrison (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07857.txt.
Introduction
Christopher Mizzi and co-authors present a 2024 paper on how solids store heat, with a focus on light metals used in nuclear work. The standard model for heat in solids works well for many materials. It fails, though, when the vibrations inside a solid soften in a strong, built-in way as heat rises.
Their method tracks how softening changes the disorder in the solid as heat climbs. A key result links that softening rate to a known measure of how a material stretches sideways when pulled. Tests across many pure solids, from diamond to lead, followed the same trend. The method gives a new way to model tough cases.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher A. Mizzi, W. Adam Phelan, Matthew S. Cook, Greta L. Chappell, Paul H. Tobash, David C. Arellano, Derek V. Prada, Boris Maiorov, and Neil Harrison |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 67 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07857
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Adaptation of Wallace’s approach to the specific heat of elemental solids with significant intrinsic anharmonicity, particularly the light actinide metals Christopher A. Mizzi, W. Adam Phelan, Matthew S. Cook, Greta L. Chappell, Paul H. Tobash, David C. Arellano, Derek V. Prada, Boris Maiorov, and Neil Harrison Abstract The quasiharmonic approximation is the most common method for modeling the specific heat of solids; however, it fails to capture the effects of intrinsic anharmonicity. In this study, we introduce the “elastic softening approximation,” an alternative approach to modeling intrinsic anharmonic effects on thermodynamic quantities, which is grounded in Wallace’s thermodynamic framework that tracks entropy changes resulting from the continuous change (e.g., softening) of phonons as a function of temperature. A key finding of our study is a direct correlation between Poisson’s ratio and the differential rate of phonon softening at finite frequencies, compared to lower frequencies relevant to elastic moduli measurements. We observe that elemental solids such as α \alpha -Be, diamond, Al, Cu, In, W, Au, and Pb, which span a wide range of Poisson’s ratios and exhibit varying degrees of intrinsic anharmonicity, consistently follow this trend. When applied to α \alpha -U, α \alpha -Pu, and δ \delta -Pu, our method reveals unusually large anharmonic phonon contributions at elevated temperatures across all three light actinide metals. These findings are attributed to the unique combination of enhanced covalency and softer elastic moduli inherent in the actinides, potentially influenced by their 5 f 5f -electron bonding. I Introduction To understand how materials behave under extreme conditions, it is crucial to know how entropy changes with temperature [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ] . One method to assess the predictability of phonons involves the quasiharmonic approximation [ 5 ] , which extends the harmonic model to consider the impact of thermal expansion and contraction against a bulk modulus. The quasiharmonic approach models the specific heat of phonons, C_{p,{\rm ph}}(T) , as a function of temperature at constant pressure, starting with the specific heat at constant volume, C_{v,{\rm ph}}(T) , calculated from the phonon density of states as in a harmonic crystal [ 6 ] . It then incorporates a term that factors in thermal expansivity and the isothermal bulk modulus [ 5 ] . Such an approach proves to be especially useful in systems exhibiting small shifts in phonon frequencies with temperature attributable to intrinsic anharmonicity, such as solid Al [ 7 ] . Problems arise with the quasiharmonic approximation when intrinsic anharmonicity effects become significant, as these effects are neglected in this approach. By “intrinsic anharmonicity,” we refer to systems where notable changes in phonon frequencies occur under conditions of near constant volume [ 5 , 8 ] . While intrinsic anharmonic effects become important in most solids at sufficiently high temperatures, it dominates over a larger temperature range in materials that simultaneously exhibit phonon softening with increasing temperature and a small or negative thermal expansion [ 9 ] . Such effects are especially pronounced in the actinide metal \delta -Pu [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . In addition to exhibiting a negative thermal expansivity at high temperatures [ 15 , 13 , 14 ] —a rare trait for an elemental solid—it also exhibits an anomalously large phonon softening with increasing temperature, as documented by elastic moduli measurements [ 16 ] and temperature-dependent neutron scattering measurements of the phonon density of states [ 17 ] . Figure 1 : The phonon density of states, D_{\rm ph}(\omega,T_{0}) , measured at temperature T_{0} for the elemental solids \alpha -Be [ 37 , 38 ] , diamond [ 39 ] , Al [ 40 ] , Cu [ 41 ] , In [ 42 ] , W [ 42 ] , Au [ 43 ] , Pb [ 44 ] , \alpha -U [ 45 ] , \alpha -Pu [ 46 ] , and \delta -Pu [ 47 ] . Values for T_{0} are given in Table 1 . In this paper, we introduce an alternative to the quasiharmonic approximation for modeling the specific heat of elemental solids at high temperatures, which we term the ‘elastic softening approximation.’ Based on Wallace’s approach [ 18 ] , this method is designed to address the limitations of the quasiharmonic approximation and considers the effect of a continuous softening of phonon frequencies on the entropy as a function of temperature [ 18 , 19 , 8 ] . Rather than tracking the entire phonon spectrum as a function of temperature (the most accurate approach to modeling thermodynamic quantities [ 20 ] ), our method uses elastic moduli measurements, making it significantly simpler to implement. Crucially, we find that it still captures important intrinsic anharmonic phonon effects arising from frequency changes not driven by thermal expansion, as observed in \delta -Pu [ 17 , 16 ] . We first test our approach on a variety of regular elemental solids with different crystal and electronic structures, namely \alpha -Be, diamond (C), Al, Cu, In, W, Au, and Pb. To fully capture the phonon contribution to specific heat at high temperatures, we introduce what we refer to as a differential softening parameter, \eta . This parameter accounts for the differences in the rate of phonon softening at finite frequencies compared to the vanishing frequency limit, which is relevant to elastic moduli measurements. In the few systems where the phonon density of states has been measured at multiple temperatures [ 7 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 17 ] , we find that \eta accurately predicts the softening of prominent features in the phonon density of states. We also find that \eta is closely correlated with Poisson’s ratio [ 24 , 26 , 25 ] , suggesting a link between \eta and bonding. A larger \eta (indicating increased phonon softening at finite frequencies relative to ultrasound measurements) is linked to brittleness and more covalent bonding character. Conversely, a smaller \eta (indicating suppressed softening at finite frequencies) is associated with ductility and more metallic bonding character. We observe that the actinide metals \alpha -U, \alpha -Pu, and \delta -Pu follow the same trend as other solids, once we account for their anomalous electronic contribution [ 27 ] to the specific heat at low temperatures. However, because the phonon softening in these actinides is much more dramatic than in other elemental solids, their intrinsic anharmonic contribution to the total specific heat is anomalously large, especially in \delta -Pu [ 29 , 28 , 10 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] . II Approximations to the Specific Heat The phonon contribution to the specific heat C_{{V,p},{\rm ph}}(T) is related to the phononic entropy S_{\rm ph}(T) via [ 33 ] C_{{V,p},{\rm ph}}(T)=T~\frac{\partial S_{\rm ph}(T)}{\partial T}\bigg|_{V,p}~, (1) where T is temperature and the subscripts V and p refer to constant volume and constant pressure conditions, respectively. While it is sometimes possible to achieve exceptionally good fits to the specific heat and other thermodynamic quantities using methods based on the Debye or Einstein models [ 6 ] , particularly for modeling the equation of state [ 36 , 34 , 2 , 35 ] , such methods often require multiple adjustable parameters. This reliance on adjustable parameters can obscure the