Reassessing the Cepheid-based distance ladder: implications for the Hubble constant
Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell · 2024
Read Reassessing the Cepheid-based distance ladder: implications for the Hubble constant by Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07840.txt.
Introduction
Marcus Högås and Edvard Mörtsell recheck the cosmic distance ladder built on Cepheid stars, in a 2024 paper. Cepheids pulse at rates tied to their glow, so they serve as mileposts for measuring the universe's expansion rate. That rate, the Hubble constant, disagrees between early- and late-universe methods, a clash called the Hubble tension.
The pair probe two possible biases: the offset assumed for Milky Way Cepheid distances, and a mismatch in pulse periods between anchor galaxies and supernova host galaxies. Matching the period mixes pulls the rate down to about 72.2, and letting the glow law bend with period gives about 72.4. Both sit roughly one unit below the standard value, easing the tension. The bent law also fits the data far better, which hints the standard ladder needs repair.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07840
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Reassessing the Cepheid-based distance ladder: implications for the Hubble constant Marcus Högås, Edvard Mörtsell Abstract The Hubble constant ( H 0 H_{0} ) is a key parameter in cosmology, yet its precise value remains contentious due to discrepancies between early- and late-universe measurement methods, a problem known as the “Hubble tension.” In this study, we revisit the Cepheid-based distance ladder calibration, focusing on two potential sources of bias in the period-luminosity relation (PLR): (1) the assumed prior for the residual parallax offset of the Milky Way (MW) Cepheids and (2) systematic differences between Cepheid periods in anchor galaxies versus supernova host galaxies. To address the latter, we adopt two different strategies alongside a renewed MW Cepheid calibration. The first strategy involves resampling anchor and host Cepheids from a common distribution of periods. This approach provides a conservative estimate of H 0 = ( 72.18 ± 1.76 ) km / s / Mpc H_{0}=(72.18\pm 1.76)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} , including the renewed MW analysis. The increased uncertainty reflects the reduced sample size—about 700 Cepheids per resampling compared to 3200 in the original dataset. This method reduces the Hubble tension from 5.4 σ 5.4\,\sigma (as reported by the SH0ES collaboration with H 0 = ( 73.17 ± 0.86 ) km / s / Mpc H_{0}=(73.17\pm 0.86)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} ) to 2.4 σ 2.4\,\sigma . The second strategy allows the PLR slope to vary with the period, yielding H 0 = ( 72.35 ± 0.91 ) km / s / Mpc H_{0}=(72.35\pm 0.91)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} , including the renewed MW analysis, and the tension reduced to 4.4 σ 4.4\,\sigma . A statistical comparison of the model with the single-linear PLR shows a significant preference for the broken PLR (p-value < 0.001 <0.001 ). Both strategies consistently indicate a downward shift of approximately − 1 km / s / Mpc -1\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} in H 0 H_{0} . Our findings underscore the importance of careful consideration of Cepheid population characteristics for precise H 0 H_{0} calibrations. I Introduction The measurement of the Hubble constant, H_{0} , the rate at which the universe is expanding, is a cornerstone of modern cosmology. Since its first estimation by Edwin Hubble in 1929 ( Hubble, 1929 ) , it has enabled the scale and age of the Universe to be determined. However, the exact value of H_{0} has remained contentious, with recent advances in observational techniques exacerbating the discrepancies between methods. This discrepancy, known as the “Hubble tension,” has emerged as one of the most significant puzzles in cosmology, particularly between the two main avenues of measurement: the early-universe model-dependent methods (extrapolated from cosmic microwave background radiation) and the late-universe model-independent methods, where the Cepheid-based distance ladder plays a central role. The calibration of the Cepheid-based distance ladder has undergone numerous refinements. In recent years, the SH0ES (Supernova H0 for the Equation of State) team’s work has been instrumental, providing a local-universe measurement of H_{0} through an intricate calibration of Cepheids in anchor galaxies, including the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC), the Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC), the Milky Way (MW), and NGC 4258. Their results for H_{0} have been reported in the range around 73-74\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} ( Riess et al., 2009 , Riess et al., 2011 , Riess et al., 2016 , Riess et al., 2018a , Riess et al., 2018b , Riess et al., 2019b , Riess et al., 2021 , Riess et al., 2022a , Riess et al., 2022b , Murakami et al., 2023 , Breuval et al., 2024 ) with their most updated value H_{0}=(73.17\pm 0.86)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} ( Breuval et al., 2024 ) being 5.4\,\sigma higher than H_{0}=(67.8\pm 0.5)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} , derived from early-universe measurements using the Planck satellite, assuming a \Lambda CDM model ( Aghanim et al., 2020 ) . In this work, we explore two potential sources of unaccounted-for systematic effects in the Cepheid-based distance ladder. The first is reassessing the calibration of the MW Cepheids, in particular the choice of prior for the residual parallax offset, which leads to a -0.6\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} shift of the Hubble constant, compared with the standard SH0ES calibration, or -1.4\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} if the MW is used as the sole anchor. The second is the difference in the distribution of Cepheid periods between anchor and supernova host galaxies. The Cepheids in the anchor galaxies calibrate the zero-point of the period-luminosity relation (PLR), and those in host galaxies determine the distances to the type Ia supernovae. Specifically, we find that Cepheids with longer periods, predominantly in host galaxies, tend to yield higher H_{0} values, suggesting a possible systematic offset in the calibration. To mitigate this effect, we use two different approaches: 1. A matched-period resampling method, harmonizing the distribution of periods in the anchor and host galaxies. This leads to an additional -0.5\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} shift in H_{0} . The method also increases the uncertainty, from 0.9\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} to 1.8\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} , due to a reduced sample size. In conjunction with the renewed MW analysis, this leads to H_{0}=(72.18\pm 1.76)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} , to be compared with the SH0ES team’s H_{0}=(73.17\pm 0.86)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} . Thus, there is a reduction in the Hubble tension from 5.4\,\sigma to 2.4\,\sigma . 2. Another potential way of mitigating a bias due to the difference in the Cepheid periods is to generalize the single-linear PLR, allowing for different slopes in different period ranges. This is referred to as the broken PLR model. The data provides strong evidence against the single-linear PLR, favoring the broken PLR with a confidence level of >99.9\,\% . The broken PLR gives a -0.3\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} shift in H_{0} , thus pointing in the same direction as the resampling method. Since all Cepheids are retained in the generalized PLR fit, the uncertainty in H_{0} is roughly the same as that of the SH0ES team analysis. In conjunction with the renewed MW analysis, this method yields H_{0}=(72.35\pm 0.91)\,\mathrm{km/s/Mpc} corresponding to a reduction in the tension from 5.4\,\sigma to 4.4\,\sigma . Figure 1: Key results. The left shaded region represents the early-universe H_{0} estimate based on data from the Planck satellite, assuming a \Lambda CDM model ( Aghanim et al., 2020 ) and the right shaded region the most updated Cepheid-based local distance ladder value from the SH0ES team ( Breuval et al., 2024 ) . There is a 5.4\,\sigma tension between the two. The orange data point with error bars shows the Cepheid-based distance ladder result when using a resampling method to mitigate the period discrepancy between the anchor and host Cepheids, together with a renewed analysis of the Milky Way Cepheids. In this case, the tension is reduced to 2.4\,\sigma . The red data point with error bars shows the same when the single-linear period-luminosity relation is replaced with a PLR allowing for different slopes in different period ranges. In this case, the tension is reduced to 4.4\,\sigma . These findings are summarized in Fig. 1 and emphasize the need for careful consideration of Cepheid properties in resolving the ongoing Hubble tension. For the readers wanting to make their own recalibration of the Cepheid-based distance ladder, we have invested some effort into presenting the high-level SH0ES data in Riess et al. (2022a) in a transparent fashion. 1 1 1 Publicly available at https://github.com/marcushogas/Cepheid-Distance-Ladder-Data Notation. Galaxy names: N4258 stands for NGC 4258 and U9391 stands for UGC 9391, etc.