Trustworthy artificial intelligence in the energy sector: Landscape analysis and evaluation framework
Sotiris Pelekis 1 , Evangelos Karakolis 1 , George Lampropoulos 1 , Spiros Mouzakitis 1 , Ourania Markaki 1 , Christos Ntanos 1 , and Dimitris Askounis 1 · 2024
Read Trustworthy artificial intelligence in the energy sector: Landscape analysis and evaluation framework by Sotiris Pelekis 1 , Evangelos Karakolis 1 , George Lampropoulos 1 , Spiros Mouzakitis 1 , Ourania Markaki 1 , Christos Ntanos 1 , and Dimitris Askounis 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07782.txt.
Introduction
Sotiris Pelekis and co-authors mapped rules for trustworthy AI in the energy field in this 2024 study. They focus on the European Union, where laws, guides, and standards for safe and fair AI are still taking shape. Sources range from ethics guides and check lists to the AI Act and shared standards work.
From that map they built a frame called E-TAI for energy uses such as smart grids and smart buildings. The frame adapts broad ethics guides to power systems. It is meant for researchers, builders, and energy experts who work with grid operators and utilities. Users can apply it while they build AI services and again as they test and revise them over time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sotiris Pelekis 1 , Evangelos Karakolis 1 , George Lampropoulos 1 , Spiros Mouzakitis 1 , Ourania Markaki 1 , Christos Ntanos 1 , and Dimitris Askounis 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07782
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Trustworthy artificial intelligence in the energy sector: Landscape analysis and evaluation framework Sotiris Pelekis 1 , Evangelos Karakolis 1 , George Lampropoulos 1 , Spiros Mouzakitis 1 , Ourania Markaki 1 , Christos Ntanos 1 , and Dimitris Askounis 1 Abstract The present study aims to evaluate the current fuzzy landscape of Trustworthy AI (TAI) within the European Union (EU), with a specific focus on the energy sector. The analysis encompasses legal frameworks, directives, initiatives, and standards like the AI Ethics Guidelines for Trustworthy AI (EGTAI), the Assessment List for Trustworthy AI (ALTAI), the AI act, and relevant CEN-CENELEC standardization efforts, as well as EU-funded projects such as AI4EU and SHERPA. Subsequently, we introduce a new TAI application framework, called E-TAI, tailored for energy applications, including smart grid and smart building systems. This framework draws inspiration from EGTAI but is customized for AI systems in the energy domain. It is designed for stakeholders in electrical power and energy systems (EPES), including researchers, developers, and energy experts linked to transmission system operators, distribution system operators, utilities, and aggregators. These stakeholders can utilize E-TAI to develop and evaluate AI services for the energy sector with a focus on ensuring trustworthiness throughout their development and iterative assessment processes. I Introduction The energy sector in Europe is undergoing a notable transformation with the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies [ 1 ] . AI is being applied in various fields including demand forecasting [ 2 , 3 , 4 ] , flexibility management [ 5 ] , demand response [ 3 ] , EV charging optimization [ 6 ] , load dissagregation [ 7 ] , and predictive maintenance [ 8 ] , presenting various implications and ethical considerations as most of them treat personal data or personally identifiable data (PII) collected from smart meters. Specifically, the integration of AI in the energy sector brings about various potential dangers that need to be addressed. These dangers entail the following: i) Cybersecurity risks: the increased use of AI in energy systems exposes vulnerabilities to cyberattacks [ 9 , 10 ] , which have surged significantly in recent years. These attacks, leveraging AI, pose a threat to the security and stability of energy infrastructure [ 11 ] ii) Data management risks: AI applications in energy systems can lead to challenges related to data management, including data privacy, integrity, and accessibility [ 12 ] . Ensuring secure and efficient data handling becomes crucial to prevent potential risks associated with AI deployment. iii) Loss of human oversight [ 13 ] : overreliance on AI systems without adequate human oversight can result in errors or malfunctions that may have severe consequences in the energy sector. Maintaining a balance between automation and human control is essential to mitigate risks. iv) Environmental impact: the significant energy demand of AI technologies, particularly in data centers, raises concerns about environmental sustainability. The power consumption of AI systems, especially GPUs used for processing, contributes to increased energy consumption and water usage, impacting the overall environmental footprint of the energy sector [ 14 ] . vi) Safety concerns: faulty predictions or malfunctions in AI systems used for energy management can pose safety risks, potentially leading to accidents or failures in critical infrastructure [ 15 ] . Ensuring the reliability and accuracy of AI applications is crucial to prevent safety hazards within the energy sector. vii) Discrimination and promotion of energy inequality against justice: AI systems are prone to erroneous decisions influenced by biased or poisoned datasets, hence producing results that are unfair and promote societal inequality [ 16 ] (e.g. demand response schemes that favor high-income consumers, against low-income ones that cannot afford smart meters). Addressing these dangers requires a comprehensive approach that combines robust cybersecurity measures [ 17 , 18 ] , effective data management strategies, human oversight mechanisms, adaptable technology solutions, sustainable energy practices, and a focus on safety and reliability in AI deployment within the energy industry. Towards this direction, trustworthy AI (TAI) is crucial in ensuring the responsible and ethical deployment of AI systems within the energy domain. In the context of the energy sector, the European Commission (EC) emphasizes the critical importance of TAI to drive innovation while ensuring ethical and responsible AI deployment. The EC’s Ethics guidelines for TAI (EGTAI) [ 19 ] , alongside the White Paper on Artificial Intelligence [ 20 ] outline key strategies to promote TAI, focusing on fundamental rights, safety, and transparency, explainability, and robustness. This commitment to ethical AI aligns with the European Union’s (EU) broader efforts to establish clear guidelines and regulations for AI technologies, emphasizing the need for transparency, accountability, and human oversight in AI applications within various sectors, including energy. By prioritizing TAI principles, the European Commission aims to foster a regulatory environment that supports innovation while safeguarding ethical standards and legal compliance in the energy domain. In the same direction, the EC has issue the Artificial Intelligence ACT, which has already been decided to be adopted as an EU law, also resulting to its final draft in 2024 [ 21 ] . The I-NERGY project [ 22 ] is an EU-funded project focused on advancing AI in the energy sector through innovative services [ 2 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 4 ] . By deepening AI research, deploying decentralized governance for energy data, and providing technology enablers for advanced AI-based solutions, I-NERGY demonstrated a strong commitment to innovation and sustainability. The project’s emphasis on AI interaction and TAI showcases its dedication to ensuring responsible and ethical AI deployment in the energy sector. Through its efforts to empower European AI innovation and reinforce the service layer of the AI-on-demand platform [ 26 ] , I-NERGY has been at the forefront of driving advancements in TAI applications for the energy industry also extending its impact beyond the energy sectors to new coming projects such as EnerShare [ 27 ] and iTrust6G [ 28 ] that aim to put it in practice to new applications and domains respectively. The present work, which has initially been introduced in the I-NERGY project, aims at the following: i) provide an overview of regulatory frameworks and initiatives in the context TAI; ii) identify possible implications and ethical issues of AI systems within applications of the electrical energy sector including smart power grid and smart buildings. Therefore, it can provide guidance for the instantiation of AI systems in the energy domain and facilitate the compliance with the ethical and legislative requirements. Ethical considerations often underlie the law and represent the common rationale, and thus overlap with the law to a certain degree. As such, they may serve as guidance where the law is not entirely adapted to new phenomena, e.g., where technology enables practices, which the legislator had not anticipated. In newly emerging fields, such as AI, legislation may indeed not cover sufficiently all ethical implications or may have not clear rules on them, thus hampering compliance. In this context, the contributions of this paper are as follows: • a concise analysis of the research landscape and regulatory framework related to the energy domain within the EU. To the best of our knowledge no previous work has attempted such a focused analysis of TAI frameworks