New calculation of the geo-neutrino energy spectrum and its implication

Yu-Feng Li, Zhao Xin · 2024

Read New calculation of the geo-neutrino energy spectrum and its implication by Yu-Feng Li, Zhao Xin (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07711.txt.

Introduction

Yu-Feng Li and Zhao Xin present a 2024 calculation of the energy spectrum of geo-neutrinos, faint particles sent out by radioactive decay deep inside Earth. Detectors catch these particles to learn about the planet's inner heat and makeup. Reading the signals well depends on knowing the exact shape of the spectrum.

Their calculation uses the newest nuclear data, adds decay paths that earlier work had skipped, and applies refined corrections to the decay maths. Compared with the standard older estimate, the new spectrum has a clearly different shape. Predicted detection counts shift by several percent for the two main decay chains. The authors note that past results from two large detectors could shift by up to a fifth when the new model is used, which sets a fresh benchmark for the field.

Catalog record

CREATORYu-Feng Li, Zhao Xin
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07711

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

New calculation of the geo-neutrino energy spectrum and its implication Yu-Feng Li, Zhao Xin Abstract The energy spectrum of geo-neutrinos plays a vital role in the experimental measurement of geo-neutrinos that have profound implications for both particle physics and earth sciences. In this letter, we present a state-of-the-art calculation of the energy spectrum of geo-neutrinos originating from the beta decay of Uranium-238 and Thorium-232. Our calculation is underpinned by the latest updates in the nuclear database, accounts for previously overlooked forbidden transitions, and incorporates advanced corrections for the beta decay. This brand new geo-neutrino flux model, compared to the widely-used estimates from Enomoto [ 1 ] , reveals notable distinction in the energy spectrum shape because of our comprehensive approach. When considering the inverse beta decay (IBD) detection process, our findings show a significant deviation in the predicted IBD yield of around 4% for Uranium-238 and 9% for Thorium-232 decay chains. The implications of using the new geo-neutrino flux model for the experimental analysis are substantial, potentially affecting the analysis results of geo-neutrino measurements of KamLAND and Borexino by around 10% to 20%. Our study represents a significant advancement in geo-neutrino research, establishing a new benchmark for accuracy and reliability in the field. Geo-neutrinos generated from the beta decay chains of the nuclear isotopes with long half-lives such as {}^{238}\text{U} , {}^{232}\text{Th} , and {}^{40}\text{K} carry the Earth’s internal information which helps us to understand key problems of the geophysical and geochemical sciences [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . During these decay processes, both antineutrinos and energies are released, with the latter known as radiogenic heat, which contributes to the Earth’s overall heat production. Thus these elements are commonly known as Heat-Producing Elements (HPEs) [ 7 ] . The production of antineutrinos and radiogenic heat is intrinsically linked, enabling the use of geo-neutrino measurements as a tool for estimating the Earth’s inaccessible radiogenic heat production [ 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . The detection of geo-neutrinos has implications for geosciences and particle physics collectively and individually [ 12 ] . Particle physicists are interested in understanding the nature of these particles, while the geological community seeks transformational insights from the detection of geo-neutrinos, particularly in accurately determining the global inventory of HPEs [ 7 ] , and these elements account for over 99\% of the radiogenic heat production in the Earth and, together with the primordial energy of accretion and core segregation, define the total power budget of the planet [ 13 ] . Current and future liquid-scintillator detectors will be able to directly measure the amount of geo-neutrinos from {}^{238}\text{U} and {}^{232}\text{Th} in the Earth [ 14 ] , but not the signal from {}^{40}\text{K} , as the antineutrino energy from the beta decay of {}^{40}\text{K} is below the threshold energy of the inverse beta decay (IBD) reaction ( \bar{\nu}_{e}+p\to e^{+}+n ) [ 15 , 16 ] . The summation method, also known as the ab-initio method [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] , is often applied to the determination of the geo-neutrino energy spectrum. In this approach, the entire energy spectrum is calculated by directly adding up each individual beta branch, with each one being weighted according to its beta decay activity. The summation method, developed for the precision prediction of reactor antineutrino spectrum, was first introduced in Ref. [ 17 ] and subsequently underwent sequential refinements and revisions, as documented in Refs. [ 18 , 19 , 20 ] . This approach depends entirely on the available nuclear databases [ 21 , 22 , 23 ] . The currently widely used geo-neutrino energy spectrum is evaluated in 2005 in Ref. [ 1 ] . One may immediately question whether updates to the nuclear database over approximately 20 years would significantly impact the expected energy spectrum. Additionally, in Ref. [ 1 ] , all branches are treated as allowed transitions, and high-order corrections for each decay branch are not considered. Therefore, an updated calculation of the geo-neutrino energy spectrum, employing the latest database and an advanced description of the beta spectrum, is essential and will play a crucial role in the precision measurements of geo-neutrinos. In this Letter, we present a new assessment of individual geo-neutrino fluxes by using the summation method from the decay chains of two dominant isotopes with long half-lives, namely, i.e., {}^{238}\text{U} and {}^{232}\text{Th} . The integration of the updated nuclear database, consideration of forbidden transitions, and inclusion of higher-order corrections yield significant spectral deviation compared to the currently commonly used fluxes in Ref. [ 1 ] . This update significantly influences the expected geo-neutrino event rates in liquid-scintillator detectors, resulting in relative differences of approximately 4% and 9% for the {}^{238}\text{U} and {}^{232}\text{Th} decay chains, respectively. Very recently, the KamLAND [ 24 ] and Borexino [ 25 ] collaborations have published their latest results on the geo-neutrino observation, with data collected over approximately 5227 and 3263 days, respectively. In the analysis of geo-neutrino measurements conducted by both collaborations, the fluxes reported by Enomoto have been utilized to present their fitting results. To assess the impact of the newly developed geo-neutrino flux model, we incorporate these updated fluxes into the analysis of data published by both collaborations, which result in substantial effects on the fit results. The remainder of this letter will outline the principal findings of the new geo-neutrino flux model and its implications for data analysis. More technical details are provided in the Appendix. The geo-neutrino flux and energy spectrum are calculated using the summation method, which involves evaluating the energy spectrum of a single beta decay along with the relevant information from nuclear database. For the single beta decay calculation, a universal description is employed, as outlined in Ref. [ 26 ] , and can be expressed as follows: \displaystyle S_{\nu}(E_{\nu})= \displaystyle Kp_{\nu}E_{\nu}(E_{0}-E_{\nu})^{2}F(Z,E_{\nu}) \displaystyle C(Z,E_{\nu})\left[1+\delta(Z,A,E_{\nu})\right], (1) where K is the normalization factor, and F(Z,E_{\nu}) is the Fermi function that accounts for the Coulomb interactions between between the emitted electron and daughter nucleus. The shape factor C(Z,E_{\nu}) characterizes the distortion in the forbidden decay relative to the allowed Gamow-Teller (GT) transition. The form of this function is based on the description provided in Ref. [ 27 ] and is presented in Table 3 . The additional higher-order corrections \delta(Z,A,E_{\nu}) can be broken down into three components: the radiative correction (RC) \delta_{\rm{RC}} [ 28 , 29 ] , the finite size (FS) correction \delta_{\rm{FS}} [ 30 , 31 ] , and the weak magnetism (WM) correction \delta_{\rm WM} [ 30 ] . More detailed information regarding the calculation of the beta decay spectrum is provided in the Appendix. Using data from the Evaluated Nuclear Structure Data Files (ENSDF) [ 23 ] related to the decay chain of a specific nuclide, we can directly calculate the total neutrino spectrum for this decay chain as follows: \displaystyle S_{X}=\sum_{ij}R_{ij}\sum_{k}I_{ij,k}S_{\nu}^{ij,k}, (2) where S_{X} represents the geo-neutrino spectrum arising from the decay chain of the nuclide X ( X={}^{238}\text{U}\,\mathrm{or}\,{}^{232}\text{Th} ), R_{ij} denotes the weight of the branching ratio in the decay process from isotope i to isotope j , and I_{ij,k} refers to the k -th branch ratio for the transition from isotope i to isotope

Read the complete text