On the shape of ice stalagmites

Daniel Papa, Christophe Josserand, Caroline Cohen · 2024

Read On the shape of ice stalagmites by Daniel Papa, Christophe Josserand, Caroline Cohen (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07654.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Papa, Christophe Josserand, and Caroline Cohen study how ice stalagmites grow in a 2024 paper. Unlike cave forms built over centuries, theirs grow in the lab as droplets freeze on a chilled plate. Substrate temperatures ranged far below freezing, and the drip rate could be tuned.

The team finds that whatever the settings, growth changes character past a certain height. Liquid water pools at the tip, spills, and freezes into fingers that give the spike a star shape from above. They explain the upward growth with the classic math of moving freeze fronts, and the sideways spread with simple mass scaling. A final diagram maps the spike's proportions against the control settings. The work speaks to icing on aircraft and cables as well as to pure physics.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Papa, Christophe Josserand, Caroline Cohen
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE19 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07654

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the shape of ice stalagmites Preprint: APS/123-QED Daniel Papa, Christophe Josserand, Caroline Cohen Abstract The growth of ice stalagmites obtained by the solidification of impacting droplets on a cooled substrate ( − 50 ∘ -50^{\circ} C to − 140 ∘ -140^{\circ} C) is investigated experimentally. It is shown that for any combination of substrate temperature and drop discharge, there is a critical height above which unfrozen water accumulates at the stalagmite’s tip, drips and develops into fingers that give a star-shape to the stalagmite. Both the vertical growth and the radial growth of the stalagmite are discussed through the Stefan problem and mass scaling arguments respectively. Finally, a phase diagram that presents the stalagmite aspect ratio in function of the main control parameters is proposed. Speleothems are morphological patterns commonly observed in caves where mineral deposits accumulate over time to form a wide variety of shapes, among which draperies, flowstones, helictites, stalactites and stalagmites Meakin and Jamtveit 2010 . These geological patterns are the result of a complex interaction of hydrodynamics, chemical processes, erosional and depositional forces and interestingly some of them have an ice counterpart, such as ice pinnacles or scallops for instance, carved by water melting Weady et al. 2022 . Man-made artificial glaciers, like ice stupas used as a water storage device, are very similar in shape with these peleothems Clouse 2017 . Stalactites are long and slender patterns that form from a fluid layer that controls precipitation of calcite while flowing down the surface Short et al. 2005 . They have also their ice equivalent in icicles Short et al. 2006 where contrary to stalactites the growth is controlled by the solidification of the water layer through the removal of the latent heat heat by both convection and diffusion in air Pegler and Davies Wykes 2021 . Similarly, stalagmites are long and slender vertical structures, but they grow from a calcite supersaturated solution that sits on its surface, either when a new drop of solution arrives or when a thin continuous water film spreads out radially down the stalagmite at sufficiently high discharge Romanov et al. 2008 . To the best of our knowledge, few studies have focused on their ice counterpart, ice stalagmites, in part because they seldom occur in nature and also because the condition for their appearance is quite rare: a continuous flow of droplets impacting on a sufficiently cold substrate (below freezing point). Another interesting features of stalagmites that has not been investigate is their radial growth. Here again, its seldom appearance in nature is due to the high feed rate needed to achieve both vertical and radial growth, even though this have been observed for granular towers Chopin and Kudrolli 2011 . In this letter we study the growth of ice stalagmites by an experimental investigation. We delve into both the vertical and radial growths of the ice structure and propose a general explanation for their behaviour. Experiments consists of releasing drops of water, of volume V_{d}=9.2\times 10^{-3} ml corresponding to a radius r_{0}=1.3 mm, with a period t_{d}=V_{d}/Q for a given discharge Q , on a cold brass substrate. The discharge is imposed by a syringe pump and the substrate is cooled down by a bath of liquid nitrogen ( -196^{\circ} C). By adjusting the level of liquid nitrogen, we are able to maintain a constant temperature of the substrate T_{s} and impose a fixed temperature boundary condition between -50^{\circ} C and -140^{\circ} C. The system is located in a box where the air humidity is reduced to limit frost formation on both the stalagmite and the substrate. The falling height of the drops is kept at H=15 cm for all experiments, leading to an impact velocity of U_{0}\sim\sqrt{gH}=1.4 m/s. The evolution of the stalagmites is monitored with two Nikon D800 camera, one in front of the setup and one above, to visualize the vertical and radial growth of the stalagmites. Figure 1: (a) Chronophotography of the stalagmite growth for a total time of 15 minutes and pictures taken at a regular time interval ( \Delta t=20 s), a flow discharge of Q=0.1 ml/min at -120^{\circ} C. (b) Chronophotography of the star-shaped stalagmite growth for a total time of 6 minutes for a flow discharge of Q=1.0 ml/min at -120^{\circ} C. Times are indicated below each picture. Figure 1 shows the chronophotographies of two experiments at the same substrate temperature T_{s}=-120^{\circ} C for two discharges, Q=0.1 ml/min and Q=1.0 ml/min corresponding to a period of 5.5 s and 0.55 s between two drop releases (figure 1 (a) and (b) respectively). At early times, each drop immediately solidifies in a pancake shape of radius r_{max} close to the maximal spreading radius of the impacted drop on the cold substrate Josserand and Thoroddsen 2016 . Experimentally we determined r_{max}=3.8 mm. The stalagmite’s shape can be thus firstly assimilated to a cylinder of radius r_{max} , of height z(t) , increasing linearly with time and with a rounded top, very similar to stalagmites commonly observed in caves formed by the precipitation kinetics of calcite Romanov et al. 2008 . This first regime of linear growth is expected to last until the tip of the stalagmite starts inflating when water accumulates on the tip (stalagmite 7, 8 on figure 1 (a)). The overflow of non-solidified liquid at the top of the stalagmite has also been observed for the growth of granular towers Chopin and Kudrolli 2011 . From this critical height z_{c} upwards, water accumulates and spills over the tip and forms successive radial protrusions that we call fingers. The early stage of the first finger is illustrated on the last six stalagmites in figure 1 (a). At higher discharges ( Q=1.0 ml/min), fingers develop quasi instantaneously (see figure 1 (b)). Each finger grows as a flowing rivulet on the cold substrate. After reaching a certain length ( \sim 3\, cm), the finger stops growing: an another finger is initiated and tends to grow in its vicinity at an angle generally lower than 90 ∘ (see top view on figure 1 (b)). Some fingers were observed to grow at larger angles, typically around 180^{\circ} but these cases were seldomly observed experimentally. When the substrate has been covered with fingers ( t=320 s on figure 1 (b)), fingers flow and grow on top of the previous ones. The overall shape of the stalagmite is broadly conical ( t=320 s and t=360 s on side view on figure 1 (b)) and reminiscent of volcanic cones which result from a roughly similar dynamic: a warm liquid flowing on a cold substrate that undergoes solidification while flowing downstream Griffiths 2000 . To summarize this qualitative discussion, stalagmites growth can be separated into two dynamical regimes: a regime where the growth is purely vertical and a regime where both vertical and radial growth coexist and where the stalagmite develops its star-shape. To understand the transition between these two regimes, we have to investigate how the liquid of an impacting drop solidifies. To freeze an incoming droplet, the stalagmite has to remove the latent heat released by its solidification E_{s}=\rho_{i}LV_{d} via the diffusive heat flux through its top surface \Phi_{\Delta T}=k_{i}\pi r_{max}^{2}\Delta T/z where \rho_{i} , L , k_{i}

Read the complete text