Consistent Value Assignments Can Explain Classicality

Giuseppe Nisticò · 2024

Read Consistent Value Assignments Can Explain Classicality by Giuseppe Nisticò (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07453.txt.

Introduction

Giuseppe Nisticò offers a fresh route to explaining why big objects act classical in a 2024 paper. The quantum-to-classical puzzle asks why tables and planets show none of quantum theory's oddness. Standard accounts tweak parameters like Planck's constant until oddness fades.

Nisticò locates the oddness elsewhere: no consistent assignment of values to all quantum observables at once exists. He defines evaluations, a scheme that grants consistent values to even incompatible observables when set conditions hold. For a large rigid body, he shows such evaluations exist for the center's position and velocity together. That joint assignment yields a classical picture of the motion. The paper closes by urging wider tests of the scheme.

Catalog record

CREATORGiuseppe Nisticò
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07453

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Consistent Value Assignments Can Explain Classicality Giuseppe Nisticò Abstract The present work proposes an alternative approach to the problem of the emergence of classicality. Typical approaches developed in the literature derive the classical behaviour of a quantum system from conditions that concern the value of the parameters deemed responsible of non-classicality, like Planck constant. Our first step in addressing the problem is instead to identify the physical origin of non-classicality of quantum physics. Nowadays the deepest origin is identified in the impossibility of a simultaneous consistent value assignment to every set of quantum observables. To attack this impossibility a concept of “evaluation” is then introduced, which allows for a consistent value assignment to non-comeasurable observables whenever an established set of conditions is satisfied. It is shown that in the case of the motion of the center of mass of a large rigid body evaluations exist that realize a consistent value assignment to both the position and the velocity of the center of mass of the body. In so doing emergence of classicality is explained by overcoming the obstacles to the simultaneous value assignments that allow for a classical description of the phenomenon. This result prompts to search for extensions and generalization of the approach. 1 Introduction In the early twentieth century empirical failures of classical physical theories made necessary to replace them with new theories, quantum theories, empirically valid. One problem of these new theories is emergence of classicality, in rough synthesis the problem of explaining why at a macroscopic level world is classical – more generally, why quantum systems with “classical” features (e.g. being “macroscopic”) behave following classical laws, rather than quantum laws. The present work shows that the question can be addressed from a yet unexplored side, as we are going to explain. The very reason of the empirical failure of classical theories can be nowadays identified within their deepest conceptual basis. Let us be synthetically more explicit. The development of every classical theory requires that each specimen of the physical system is assigned a value v({\mathcal{A}}) for every physical magnitude \mathcal{A} of the physical system at every time, as an objective property of that specimen. In fact, no classical theory can be developed without the following assumption. ( \mathcal{CS} ) At any time every specimen of the physical system has a determined value v({\mathcal{A}}) of each of its magnitudes \mathcal{A} . An eventual measurement of \mathcal{A} , with outcome v_{0}({\mathcal{A}}) , just reveals this objective value. Now, in empirically ascertained phenomena any simultaneous value assignment turned out to be empirically inconsistent, as shown in appendix A. Therefore, alternative physical theories must be developed, consistent with the following statement. ( \mathcal{QS} ) A specimen of the physical system is not always endowed with a value of every magnitude as an objective property of the specimen. Quantum theories are consistent with ( \mathcal{QS} ); in fact they replaced classical theories. The present work shows how just the limitations to a simultaneous consistent value assignment can be outflanked according to quantum theory in some cases where the physical features of the system become “classical”: classicality emerges in virtue of a mechanism at the level of the deep roots of quantum physics. This approach is different from the past ones we briefly outline. The primary approach to the question involved the Planck constant \hbar (e.g. see [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] ); it aimed to formally identify the conditions, within the specific quantum theory of the involved system, such that in the limit \hbar\to 0 the physical system obeys classical laws. Another approach is based on the idea of decoherence (e.g. see [ 3 ] ), according to which the Hilbert space of the quantum theory must be enlarged to take into account the (albeit very weak) interaction with the environment; the conditions are then searched which imply the “collapse” of the wave function, i.e. loss of the superposition of quantum states, with respect to a reduced description that excludes the environment, so that a classical behaviour emerges at this level. A further idea pursued to solve the question is to investigate the consequences of the largeness of a system, i.e. of the fact that the system is composed by a very large number N of identical constituents [ 4 ] ; one result of this approach is that macro-observables , i.e. observables of a macroscopic system which are “symmetrized” averages of observables of the constiuents, turn out to commute in the limit N\to\infty , so that the class of these macroscopic observables is isomorphic to a class of classical magnitudes. These different lines of research are treated in great detail in the literature 1 1 1 A different interesting investigation has been pursued [ 5 ] , showing how the classical trajectories of a particle in a cloud chamber emerge without making resort to the idea of collapse of the wave function, but, instead, by a pure quantum theoretical treatment. [ 2 ] , [ 4 ] . In particular Landsman [ 4 ] provides us with a truly extended collection of references. In general these approaches aim to identify under which conditions of the specific quantum theory classicality can be derived when the features that exhibit non-classicality vanish; for instance, the primary approach investigates under which conditions the quantum theory of a system predicts a classical behaviour in the limit \hbar\to 0 . These features are themselves consequences of the theoretical re-development that leads to quantum theory coherently with ({\mathcal{Q}S} ). As concluded by Landsman himself, “none of these ideas in isolation is capable of explaining the classical world, but there is some hope that by combining […] them, one might do so in the future”. In our approach, instead, emergence of classicality stems from a mechanism that overcomes just the limitations to a simultaneous consistent value assignment, which are the roots of non-classicality. In so doing, emergence of classicality is explained at a deeper conceptual level. Let us describe the content of the work in more detail. The first task accomplished in Section 2 is to show how quantum theory reformulates the basic physical concepts to comply with ( \mathcal{QS} ). In particular, the classical concept of magnitude is replaced by the concept of quantum observable that does not necessitate a value assignment, unless it is actually measured. The standard formulation of quantum theory in Hilbert space is presented, where observables are identified with self-adjoint operators. Actually performed measurements of observables assign them the values obtained as outcomes, and therefore measurement determine value assignments empirical consistent. In quantum theory a law that rules over a kind of limitation to simultaneous value assignments to different observables is formally proved: two obervables A and B that do not commute cannot be measured together on the same specimen of the physical system. However, this limitation to similtaneous value assignment by measurements does not exclude the possibility of an otherwise obtained consistent value assignment to observables that are not co-measurable. In Section 2.2 the concept of evaluation is introduced. Let an observable A be assigned the value obtained as outcome of a measurement of another observable T . A consistency criterion is formally established in such a way that, when

Read the complete text