Scale Separation, Strong Coupling UV Phases, and the Identification of the Edge of the Conformal Window
Anja Alfano, Nick Evans · 2024
Read Scale Separation, Strong Coupling UV Phases, and the Identification of the Edge of the Conformal Window by Anja Alfano, Nick Evans (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07309.txt.
Introduction
Anja Alfano and Nick Evans wrote this theoretical physics paper, published in two thousand twenty-four, on a trap in the hunt for new gauge theories. Some strongly coupled theories almost stop running at low energy, a state called the conformal window, and lattice simulations struggle to tell its edge from true symmetry breaking.
Using a simple holographic model, the authors show why. A walking theory can hold several scales apart: where it turns strong, where a key dimension crosses its critical value, and where the condensate forms. On a finite lattice with a weak starting coupling, those gaps can fake an answer. Running the coupling hot instead creates an artefact phase that breaks symmetry right at the cutoff, parked close to the fixed point. They test the lesson on recent ten-flavor lattice data and find its verdict sound.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anja Alfano, Nick Evans |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07309
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Scale Separation, Strong Coupling UV Phases, and the Identification of the Edge of the Conformal Window Anja Alfano, Nick Evans Abstract We use a simple holographic model to discuss approaching the edge of the conformal window in strongly coupled gauge theories to draw lessons for lattice studies. Walking gauge theories have a gap between the scale where they enter the strong coupling regime and the scale of chiral symmetry breaking. We highlight that there can also be a gap between the scale where the critical value of the quark anti-quark operator’s anomalous dimension is passed and the scale of the condensate. This potentially makes identifying the edge of the conformal window in a lattice simulation with UV bare coupling below the fixed point value on a finite lattice difficult. A resolution is to study the theory with a coupling above the fixed point value at the UV cut off. Here we show that an “artefact” phase with chiral symmetry breaking triggered at the UV cut off exists and lies arbitrarily close to the fixed point at the edge of the conformal window. We quantify the chance of a misidentification of a chiral symmetry breaking theory as IR conformal. We also quantify where the artefact phase lies, tuned to the fixed point value. We use the latest lattice results for SU(3) gauge theory with ten quark flavours in Hasenfratz:2023wbr as a test case; we conclude their identification that the theory is in the conformal window is reliable. I Introduction At large numbers of colours, N_{c} , and quark flavours, N_{f} , SU( N_{c} ) gauge theories are known to possess weakly coupled Banks Zak infra-red (IR) fixed points Banks:1981nn . These fixed points lie at N_{f} values just below where the theory gains asymptotic freedom at N_{f}=11N_{c}/2 and result from a cancellation between the one- and two-loop \beta function terms. A sensible story has been proposed for how these fixed points evolve into the strongly coupled regime and away from large N_{c} Appelquist:1996dq ; Dietrich:2006cm . That account says that the IR fixed point remains as N_{f} lowers until the fixed point is sufficiently strongly coupled that the anomalous dimension of the quark anti-quark bilinear operator has risen to one ( \gamma=1 ). This criteria is natural since it is when the mass and condensate are of equal dimension and emerges in both gap equation Cohen:1988sq and holographic analyses Jarvinen:2011qe ; Kutasov:2011fr ; Alvares:2012kr . A recent lattice study of SU(3) gauge theory with N_{f}=10 Hasenfratz:2023wbr appears to support this account, placing the theory in the conformal window. In Figure 1 we reproduce their result for the \beta function of the theory as a function of g^{2} . It shows a clear fixed point around g^{2}=15 . They compute that the theory has \gamma=0.6 . It is argued that this theory lies in the strongly coupled conformal window. Here, though, we want to play the role of devil’s advocate and use that example to discuss whether such an identification could go wrong? The lattice analysis was done on a lattice that had at most 28^{3}\times 56 sites and so the analysis might in principle miss large scale separations of thirty or more. We will show such a case by enacting the running that the lattice study finds in a simple holographic model of the chiral symmetry breaking. To allow ourselves a “parameter space” we relax the condition \gamma=1 which is sensibly argued for but not proven. Fig 1: The beta function plot taken from Hasenfratz:2023wbr ; our fit is overlaid in red. The resulting \alpha(\mu) , on integrating up the beta function, is plotted below, showing an IR fixed point at \alpha=15/4\pi . We show UV boundary conditions that approach the fixed point from above and below. In holograhy in AdS 5 space (with radius one) a quark condensate of dimension three, \Delta=3 , is described by a scalar in the bulk of mass squared -3 (as for example, in the D3/probe D7 system Karch:2002sh ; Kruczenski:2003be ; Erdmenger:2007cm ). This follows from the relation M^{2}=\Delta(\Delta-4) Witten:1998qj . In top down chiral symmetry breaking models (where supersymmetry is broken Babington:2003vm or with a magnetic field Albash:2007bk ) this mass squared becomes dependent on the radial (renormalization group flow) direction, decreasing into the IR Alvares:2012kr . When it passes through M^{2}=-4,\Delta=2,\gamma=1 the Breitenlohner-Freedman (BF) bound Breitenlohner:1982jf is violated and the scalar becomes unstable to acquiring a vacuum expectation value (vev), and chiral symmetry breaking is triggered. This discussion though is only strictly valid in AdS 5 , yet, generically, the space will be deformed by the relevant perturbation causing the chiral symmetry breaking. It is therefore not proven that when the BF bound is violated in a deformed space, that \gamma=1 . Thus below, although we will use a fixed AdS 5 geometry, we will only assume that the deviation of the scalar mass from -3 ( \Delta m^{2} ) is proportional to the running \alpha . We will study the behaviour of the theory as a function of the proportionality constant k . We will study the separation in scale between where the BF bound is violated and the chiral condensate forms. If a theory is sufficiently walking and just barely above the BF bound violation point in the IR then a big gap between these scales is possible. This is simply an energetic argument - if the energy cost of “living with” the instability is small it can take a spread of scales for the benefit of allowing condensation to be felt. We find a separation of scales greater than 35 if \Delta m^{2} lies between 1-1.3 of its critical value. So, do we trust the lattice assignment Hasenfratz:2023wbr of the N_{f}=10 theory to the conformal window? If the reader believes a strict \gamma=1 criteria, then yes. If one instead believes that the critical value might lie between \gamma=0.4 -1.4 then the measured value of 0.65 would be a concern if the true critical value were between 0.5-0.65, i.e. 15\% of the range. The lattice work Hasenfratz:2023wbr seeks to resolve this by studying the theory with a choice of bare coupling at the UV cut off (lattice scale) that lies above the fixed point value. These theories have a UV Landau pole in the continuum, but the lattice UV cut off can protect the IR from knowledge of its existence. They observed no chiral symmetry breaking even with the UV coupling 30% or so above the fixed point value, and this indeed suggests that the fixed point preserves chiral symmetry. This analysis is a crucial and convincing aspect of their work. The second part of our work is to ask: can this method of studying the theory at couplings above the critical coupling always be easily used? As the coupling is raised in the UV in the holographic model, it will at some point violate the BF bound at the UV scale. If it does, then there is no stable vacuum in the holographic model. We associate this phase to the “lattice artefact phase” often seen in lattice simulations if the bare coupling is taken too large Hasenfratz:2021zsl . It is associated with chiral symmetry breaking at the lattice scale