Temporal-Aware Evaluation and Learning for Temporal Graph Neural Networks
Junwei Su, Shan Wu · 2024
Read Temporal-Aware Evaluation and Learning for Temporal Graph Neural Networks by Junwei Su, Shan Wu (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07273.txt.
Introduction
Junwei Su and Shan Wu examine how neural networks for graphs that change over time should be scored, in a 2024 paper. Such networks learn from data like message streams or trade webs, where links form and fade. Most past work chased better designs, while the scoring rules got little care. The pair show that common scores can miss a key flaw: errors that bunch together in short bursts.
They write the common scores in exact math form and test them on set cases. The scores fail to flag burst-like errors, a flaw that matters for both design and use. The pair then offer a new score that tracks how errors cluster in time. They also turn that score into a training goal that spreads errors out. Tests across many models show burst errors are common, differ by design, and shrink under the new training goal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Junwei Su, Shan Wu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07273
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Temporal-Aware Evaluation and Learning for Temporal Graph Neural Networks Junwei Su, Shan Wu Abstract Temporal Graph Neural Networks (TGNNs) are a family of graph neural networks designed to model and learn dynamic information from temporal graphs. Given their substantial empirical success, there is an escalating interest in TGNNs within the research community. However, the majority of these efforts have been channelled towards algorithm and system design, with the evaluation metrics receiving comparatively less attention. Effective evaluation metrics are crucial for providing detailed performance insights, particularly in the temporal domain. This paper investigates the commonly used evaluation metrics for TGNNs and illustrates the failure mechanisms of these metrics in capturing essential temporal structures in the predictive behaviour of TGNNs. We provide a mathematical formulation of existing performance metrics and utilize an instance-based study to underscore their inadequacies in identifying volatility clustering (the occurrence of emerging errors within a brief interval). This phenomenon has profound implications for both algorithm and system design in the temporal domain. To address this deficiency, we introduce a new volatility-aware evaluation metric (termed volatility cluster statistics), designed for a more refined analysis of model temporal performance. Additionally, we demonstrate how this metric can serve as a temporal-volatility-aware training objective to alleviate the clustering of temporal errors. Through comprehensive experiments on various TGNN models, we validate our analysis and the proposed approach. The empirical results offer revealing insights: 1) existing TGNNs are prone to making errors with volatility clustering, and 2) TGNNs with different mechanisms to capture temporal information exhibit distinct volatility clustering patterns. Moreover, our empirical findings demonstrate that our proposed training objective effectively reduces volatility clusters in error. † † footnotetext: * corresponding author \ddagger School of Resources and Environmental Engineering, Hefei University of Technology \dagger School of Computing and Data Science, University of Hong Kong [email protected], [email protected] 1 Introduction Many real-world problems and systems are naturally modeled as temporal graphs (also referred to as dynamic graphs ), characterized by continuously changing relationships, nodes, and attributes. To address this temporal dynamic nature, Temporal Graph Neural Networks (TGNNs), the temporal counterparts to GNNs, have emerged as promising deep learning models capable of modelling time-varying graph structures ( Kazemi et al. 2020 ; Skarding, Gabrys, and Musial 2021 ; Zhang et al. 2023 ; Xu et al. 2020a ) . Unlike their static counterparts, TGNNs excel at capturing temporal dependencies and learning temporal representations within the context of temporal graphs. Consequently, they are widely employed in applications such as traffic prediction ( Zhao et al. 2019 ; Guo et al. 2019 ; Zhang et al. 2020 ) , financial analysis ( Wang et al. 2021a ; Su, Wu, and Li 2024 ) , social network ( Zhang et al. 2021b ) , recommender systems ( Kumar, Zhang, and Leskovec 2019 ) , and climate modeling ( Khodayar and Wang 2018 ) . Given their substantial empirical success, there is growing interest in TGNNs within the research community. However, most efforts have been concentrated on algorithm and system design, with various classes of TGNNs emerging based on their mechanisms for capturing temporal information (e.g., RNN-based, memory-based, and attention-based; see related work for more details). Conversely, the evaluation of TGNNs has received comparatively less attention. There are only a few benchmark studies on TGNNs that predominantly investigate how various combinations of learning settings and datasets impact the performance of TGNN models. Notably, these benchmarks typically utilize common instance-based evaluation metrics like Average Precision (AP) and Area Under the ROC Curve (AU-ROC), where each test sample is considered identically and independently . An intriguing finding from these benchmark studies is that almost all existing TGNNs demonstrate remarkable (and similar) performance when evaluated against these instance-based metrics. This uniformity in performance poses a significant challenge in model selection for practical applications, as distinguishing between models based on these metrics alone becomes difficult. Therefore, there is an urgent need to develop more nuanced evaluation metrics that can better capture the unique capabilities and efficiencies of different TGNN architectures. In addition to model selection, this paper argues that instance-based evaluation metrics are insufficient and ineffective at capturing the temporal structure of the predictive behavior of TGNNs. Data samples in temporal graphs could exhibit temporal correlation , impacting the predictions made by TGNNs and introducing patterns such as volatility clusters —periods where large fluctuations are grouped together. This aspect is crucial for the functionality of temporal algorithms and systems in TGNNs. For example, in financial trading algorithms or risk management systems, accurately measuring and predicting volatility clusters can be crucial for effective strategy deployment and risk assessment. Similarly, in fault-tolerant systems, understanding volatility clusters can aid in preemptively identifying periods of potential system stress or failure, thereby enabling proactive maintenance or system adjustments to prevent downtime. Adequate performance evaluation ensures that these systems are not only accurate but also robust and responsive under varying temporal dynamics. This, in turn, aids in optimizing operational efficiency, improving decision-making processes, and ensuring reliability in critical applications where timing and the evolution of data play a vital role. Therefore, developing and refining evaluation metrics that can effectively measure the performance of TGNNs is essential for advancing these technologies and their applications. Contribution. This paper aims to spotlight an under-explored aspect of TGNNs—the evaluation metrics. We examine and highlight the inadequacies of current evaluation metrics in capturing the temporal structures of TGNNs and propose a novel performance metric tailored to detect nuanced temporal information such as volatility clusters. The key contributions and findings of this paper are summarized and highlighted as follows 1. We present a mathematical formulation of existing evaluation metrics alongside a formal definition aimed at measuring the expressiveness of these metrics. This foundational framework is crucial for analyzing evaluation metrics comprehensively and formalizing the limitations inherent in current TGNN evaluation approaches. Utilizing this framework, we formally prove that instance-based evaluation metrics such as AP and AU-ROC resemble a simple counting process and fail to capture temporal structures (e.g., volatility clusters) in the predictions of TGNNs (Theorem 3.1 ). 2. Building on the insights from our analysis, we propose a novel evaluation metric, named v olatility- c luster s tatistics (VCS). Inspired by Hopkins statistics ( Hopkins and Skellam 1954 ) , VCS serves as a complementary evaluation metric designed to detect and evaluate volatility clusters in the prediction errors of TGNNs. VCS offers crucial insights into the temporal structure of the prediction errors (error pattern) of TGNNs and helps differentiate the performance of various TGNN models. 3. Beyond its use in evaluation, we demonstrate that the concept of VCS can also function effectively as a regularization technique to mitigate volatility clusters in errors with appropriate modifications. We introduce a method termed v olatility- c luster- a ware (VCA) learning, which is a smooth and differentiable extension of VCS. VCA helps mitigate volatility clusters in the prediction errors of TGNNs. This capability is particularly valuable in the design of systems and algorithms for critical areas such as fault-tolerant systems. 4. We validate our findings and the effectiveness of our metrics through extensive empirical studies consisting of five datasets and six SOTA methods. Our empirical results reveal several key insights: 1) existing TGNNs tend to produce volatility cluster in