A Bayesian Mixture Model Approach to Examining Neighborhood Social Determinants of Health Disparities in Endometrial Cancer Care in Massachusetts

Carmen B. Rodríguez, Stephanie M. Wu, Stephanie Alimena, Alecia JMcGregor, Briana JK Stephenson · 2024

Read A Bayesian Mixture Model Approach to Examining Neighborhood Social Determinants of Health Disparities in Endometrial Cancer Care in Massachusetts by Carmen B. Rodríguez, Stephanie M. Wu, Stephanie Alimena, Alecia JMcGregor, Briana JK Stephenson (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-07134.txt.

Introduction

Where a woman lives shapes the cancer care she gets, and Carmen Rodriguez and four co-authors built a map of that shaping in Massachusetts in a 2024 study. Instead of scoring neighborhoods one hardship at a time, they let a Bayesian mixture model sort census areas into profiles of joint social conditions.

Five profiles emerged, from an advantaged, mostly white profile to renter-heavy, linguistically isolated ones, plus a working-class profile and a diverse but secure one. The team then attached profiles to endometrial cancer patients in the state registry and modeled the odds of receiving optimal care for each. The headline result is a null with texture. The neighborhood profiles were not significantly tied to optimal care once patient traits were counted. That finding redirects the disparity hunt toward other levels.

Catalog record

CREATORCarmen B. Rodríguez, Stephanie M. Wu, Stephanie Alimena, Alecia JMcGregor, Briana JK Stephenson
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-07134

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Bayesian Mixture Model Approach to Examining Neighborhood Social Determinants of Health Disparities in Endometrial Cancer Care in Massachusetts Carmen B. Rodríguez, Stephanie M. Wu, Stephanie Alimena, Alecia JMcGregor, Briana JK Stephenson Abstract Many studies have examined social determinants of health (SDoH) independently, overlooking their interconnected nature. Our study uses a multidimensional approach to construct a neighborhood-level measure that explores how multiple SDoH jointly impact care received for endometrial cancer (EC) patients in Massachusetts (MA). Using 2015-2019 American Community Survey data, we implemented a Bayesian multivariate Bernoulli mixture model to identify neighborhoods with similar SDoH features in MA. Five neighborhood SDoH (NSDoH) profiles were derived and characterized: (1) advantaged non-Hispanic White; (2) disadvantaged racially/ethnically diverse, more renter-occupied housing with limited English proficiency;(3) working class, lower educational attainment; (4) racially/ethnically diverse and greater economic security and educational attainment; and (5) racially/ethnically diverse, more renter-occupied housing with limited English proficiency. Based on residential information, we assigned these profiles to EC patients in the Massachusetts Cancer Registry. We used these profile assignments as the primary exposure in a Bayesian logistic regression to estimate the odds of receiving optimal EC care, adjusting for patient-level sociodemographic and clinical characteristics. NSDoH profiles were not significantly associated with receiving optimal EC care. However, compared to patients assigned to Profile 1, patients in all other profiles had lower odds of receiving optimal care. Our findings demonstrate how a flexible model-based clustering approach can account for the interconnected and multidimensional nature of NSDoH in a practical and interpretable way. Deriving and geospatially mapping NSDoH profiles may allow for identifying areas of need and inform targeted public health interventions tailored to each neighborhood’s specific social determinants to improve healthcare delivery. keywords Bayesian clustering; Endometrial Cancer; National Comprehensive Cancer Network; Social Determinants of Health;disparities; neighborhoods 1 Background Social determinants of health (SDoH) are defined as the social or demographic components of one’s environment that shape health outcomes and can impact an individual’s access to care, treatment decisions, and overall patient experiences ( Cooper et al. 2024 ; Coughlin 2019 ; Kolak et al. 2020 ) . These determinants, including socioeconomic status, experiences of racism or discrimination, and neighborhood conditions, can introduce bias in the healthcare system, potentially leading to a lack of guideline-concordant treatment ( Gomez et al. 2015 ) , such as for endometrial cancer (EC), one of the most commonly occurring female cancers. Despite the existence of evidence-based treatment guidelines, disparities across the EC care continuum persist, particularly among ethnically and socioeconomically disadvantaged groups ( Paskett and Bernardo 2020 ; Doll 2023 ; Doll et al. 2018 ; Huang et al. 2020 ; Rodriguez et al. 2021 ; Eakin et al. 2023 ; Makker et al. 2021 ; Rodriguez et al. 2021 ; Karia et al. 2023 ) . This disparate relationship serves as our motivation to better understand how SDoH patterns are considered and characterized ( Makker et al. 2021 ; Eakin et al. 2023 ) . A comprehensive analysis of SDoH that transcends race and ethnicity would provide researchers and policymakers with a deeper understanding of how the social environment can influence a patient’s ability to engage with the healthcare system ( Rodriguez et al. 2021 ; Rodriguez et al. 2021 ) . Characterization of SDoH is often conducted using non-standardized composite scores of proxy variables that correspond to different domains, such as income, education, and employment ( Rethorn et al. 2020 ; Jonnalagadda et al. 2020 ) . At the geographic level, SDoH has been operationalized using area-based measures derived from publicly available data sources such as the United States (US) Census and the American Community Survey (ACS). Two commonly used measures are the Yost Index and the Area Deprivation Index (ADI) ( Yost et al. 2001 ; Singh 2003 ; Berg et al. 2021 ) . The Yost Index, typically used in national cancer surveillance, operates under the assumption that SDoH is one-dimensional. It inputs seven area-level variables (median household income, education, proportion of households below the 150% poverty line, median house value, median gross rent, unemployment rate, and working-class occupation). Summarized at the census tract or block level, these variables are clustered via a Principal Component Analysis (PCA), based on how much the respective variable explains the variation in the data ( Yost et al. 2001 ; LaFantasie and Boscoe 2022 ; Boscoe et al. 2021 ) . Referred to as the primary component, the socioeconomic status (SES) index is calculated for each areal unit based on the variable loadings on that component. Areal units are then ranked based on their SES scores and divided into quintiles, with quintile 1 representing the lowest SES and quintile 5 the highest. As a one-dimensional component for SES, a loss of information results because this measure focuses on the one or two variables that may be most relevant to classifying low or high SES, as opposed to considering the combination of the different variables and how their contributions may differ from one residential area to another. The ADI, originally developed in 2002 to study general mortality disparities and hospitalizations in the US, expands the set of census-derived SDoH variables to 17. Previously, it operated under the same one-dimensional assumption as Yost, but now incorporates a three-factor model to accommodate multi-dimensionality ( Kind and Buckingham 2018 ; Boscoe et al. 2021 ; Berg et al. 2021 ; Singh 2003 ) . Highly correlated variables are first clustered together and then defined along the following three domains: financial strength, economic hardship and inequality, and educational attainment ( Berg et al. 2021 ) . As in the Yost Index, areal units are indexed based on how high they load on the three-factor domains. Higher percentile ranks indicate greater socioeconomic disadvantage. A limitation of the ADI is that the derived domains are treated independently from one another without acknowledging the ways in which they intersect. Boscoe et al. compared the Yost and ADI indices and found that, despite being derived from the same data and heavily influenced by financial domains, they differ significantly in terms of transparency for reproducibility, distribution, and sensitivity to missing data ( Boscoe et al. 2021 ) . Methodologically, these approaches share similarities in their use of principal components or factor analysis to reduce the number of highly correlated SDoH variables, but the domains derived are treated independently from one another and fall short of acknowledging the ways in which they intersect. Recently, Kolak et al. introduced a new approach that further expands the list of census-derived SDoH variables for PCA, including variables like limited English proficiency ( Kolak et al. 2020 ) . These variables were reduced to four domains: socioeconomic advantage index, limited mobility index, urban core opportunity index, and mixed immigrant cohesion and accessibility index. Additionally, they clustered census tracts by characterizing them into profiles based on similar scoring across the four SDoH components using K-means clustering. While this approach does allow for clustering based on shared responses to the different domains, the clustering is based on a single summary score. Overlooking how each component-specific score contributes to the summary score ignores the heterogeneity present in area deprivation. Two neighborhoods could potentially be clustered together but experience different patterns of resource allocation, which alter

Read the complete text