“It’s Always a Losing Game”: How Workers Understand and Resist Surveillance Technologies on the Job
Cella M. Sum, Caroline Shi, Sarah E. Fox · 2024
Read “It’s Always a Losing Game”: How Workers Understand and Resist Surveillance Technologies on the Job by Cella M. Sum, Caroline Shi, Sarah E. Fox (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06945.txt.
Introduction
Software that watches workers has spread with remote work, tracking screens, keys, and time. Cella Sum and two co-authors asked in 2024 how workers themselves read that watching and what they do about it. They studied posts on Reddit and long interviews with workers across many fields.
Workers told of worry for their health, safety, and privacy, and of rules they could neither see nor shape. In reply they leaned on each other for support and found small technical workarounds. Those moves show spirit, the authors say, but they cannot fix a lopsided setup on their own. The team urges worker led design and policy as the stronger path.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Cella M. Sum, Caroline Shi, Sarah E. Fox |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 98 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06945
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
“It’s Always a Losing Game”: How Workers Understand and Resist Surveillance Technologies on the Job Cella M. Sum, Caroline Shi, Sarah E. Fox Abstract . With the rise of remote work, a range of surveillance technologies are increasingly being used by business owners to track and monitor employees, raising concerns about worker rights and privacy. Through analysis of Reddit posts and in-depth semi-structured interviews, this paper seeks to understand how workers across a range of sectors make sense of and respond to layered forms of surveillance. While workers express concern about risks to their health, safety, and privacy, they also face a lack of transparency and autonomy around the use of these systems. In response, workers take up tactics of everyday resistance, such as commiserating with other workers or employing technological hacks. Although these tactics demonstrate workers’ ingenuity, they also show the limitations of existing approaches to protect workers against intrusive workplace monitoring. We argue that there is an opportunity for CSCW researchers to support these countermeasures through worker-led design and policy. Journal: PACMHCI Volume: 9 2 CSCW004 4 DOI: 10.1145/3710902 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing 1. Introduction “ What do warehouse workers, delivery workers, and call center workers have in common? Their productivity is tracked and compared to the average of other workers. When workers are slower than average, they face disciplinary action. This causes workers to sacrifice work quality and safety to improve their times. When everyone does this, they compete against more unrealistic expectations. It’s always a losing game. Anyone can make a tracking app, but in the end it’s poor management because it doesn’t take into account worker burnout and safety. This harms both worker and employer. ” --- Post on Reddit [R141] 1 1 1 Throughout this paper, Reddit posts have been paraphrased or slightly altered to protect anonymity. As the above Reddit post articulates, the current ubiquity of electronic monitoring, or Workplace Surveillance Technologies (WSTs), has transformed how workers are managed across industries. Often associated with blue-collar jobs in manufacturing and call centers since the 1990s, WSTs underwent a significant expansion in use during the COVID-19 pandemic ( Kantor and Sundaram, 2022 ) . This rise has seen these technologies flourish in previously unmonitored sectors, including higher-paying creative and technical professions. This shift has also ushered in an era of granular, real-time scrutiny for workers. A combination of “old” technologies like cameras and “new” technologies like artificial intelligence (AI) is now being deployed to track employee productivity, location, physical environment, biometrics, computer activity, and even personal data ( Hickok and Maslej, 2023 ) . Paralleling this rise, there has been an increasing interest within CSCW and related scholarly communities in how data are collected about workers’ performance, as well as how these evaluations affect pay structures and one’s ability to sustain employment ( Jarrahi et al., 2021 ; Lee et al., 2015 ) . Although initially deployed within the context of gig work, scholars have charted how algorithmic management techniques are now prevalent across traditional workplace settings and employment relationships ( Kellogg et al., 2020 ) . Research has also examined how these data-driven management strategies are combined with other forms of monitoring (e.g., customer ratings) to generate an ever more detailed assessment of workers’ activities ( Cameron, 2022 ; Rosenblat, 2016 ) . Scholars such as Sannon et al. ( Sannon et al., 2022 ) have documented how workers engage in risk mitigation strategies associated with such oversight, including self-protective surveillance behaviors, while others describe the potential for collective sensemaking as a strategy for worker contestation ( Holten Møller et al., 2021 ) . Building on this body of scholarship, our paper seeks to understand this growing trend of WSTs cross-sectorally, including impacts on those previously spared from such intrusive monitoring. In particular, we examine the following questions: (1) What are workers’ lived experiences with WSTs across sectors? (2) What tactics have workers developed to circumvent harmful forms of surveillance? (3) How do workers create avenues of peer support and information sharing around the use (and circumvention) of these technologies? To do so, we draw together content analysis of a set of 9 work-related subreddits and 10 in-depth, semi-structured interviews with employees and managers from a diverse set of industries who have experienced a variety of surveillance technologies. This includes those who have worked in operations, customer service, marketing, and food and beverage service. Workers across our study describe how WSTs contribute to a culture of distrust in the workplace that harms both workers and managers alike. Beyond privacy concerns, workers identify these technologies as causing significant stress, reducing their productivity, and increasing their risk of disciplinary action. At the same time, they see these technologies as fostering paranoia and distrust among managers toward their employees. In response, some workers employ various resistance tactics, such as commiseration, obfuscation, soldiering, and quitting to help protect them from intrusive monitoring. However, the reliance on these more individualized tactics points to the limited power and protections workers have when subjected to highly-surveilled and fissured workplaces ( Weil, 2014 ) . Our paper makes three contributions to the CSCW community. First, we offer an empirical study on how workers have been impacted by WSTs since COVID-19 and the rise of remote work across different sectors. Second, we broaden understanding of worker resistance by highlighting the myriad tactics workers employ to navigate and circumvent surveillance and its relationship to building worker power. Third, we identify opportunities for CSCW researchers to support workers in these countermeasures and to help bridge the gap toward more collective action. In what follows, we first describe the contemporary landscape of WSTs and their impacts on workers. We then discuss current understandings of worker resistance and how they build power in response to overt surveillance and poor working conditions, and the ways past HCI research has supported these efforts. Next, we detail the methods that guide our content analysis and interview process. Drawing on our findings that explore how workers experience and resist surveillance technologies, we demonstrate the need for HCI research to go beyond a focus on mitigating the risks of surveillance and to support efforts in resistance and refusal to its use. 2. Related Work 2.1. Workplace Surveillance Technologies Technological advancements since the late twentieth century have led to the age of digital surveillance, making it easier for employers to constantly monitor their workers both inside and outside the workplace ( Introna, 2000 ; Vitak and Zimmer, 2023a ; Ajunwa et al., 2017 ) . WSTs have the ability to track and even infer a worker’s productivity, behavior, and personal information through digital activity monitoring, camera and audio monitoring, and localization and biophysical monitoring ( Ajunwa et al., 2017 ; Ball, 2010 ; Cousineau et al., 2023 ) . As AI and sensing technologies become more affordable and accessible, workplaces have introduced more intrusive forms of surveillance that often involve an assemblage of networked devices to generate continuous fine-grained data about their workers ( Marx, 2002 ) . The responsibility of workplace monitoring has also become more distributed in nature, where employees are expected to aid in their own surveillance through participation in workplace wellness programs and