Framework to coordinate ubiquitous devices with SOA standards
Oscar A. Testa 1 , Efraín R. Fonseca C. 2 , Germán Montejano 3 , and Oscar Dieste 4 · 2024
Read Framework to coordinate ubiquitous devices with SOA standards by Oscar A. Testa 1 , Efraín R. Fonseca C. 2 , Germán Montejano 3 , and Oscar Dieste 4 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06908.txt.
Introduction
Oscar Testa, Efraín Fonseca, Germán Montejano, and Oscar Dieste build a framework for coordinating smart devices in a 2024 paper. Homes and offices brim with gadgets, but most talk only through each maker's own tools, which keeps them from working as one system. Web services, by contrast, have standard rules for composing services. The team ask whether those service-oriented rules can run device teamwork too.
Using a design science method, the team built the framework in rounds of building and testing, with a proof of concept at its core. The running system coordinates devices through a standard choreography language for web services. The work aims to move device coordination from maker silos toward open standards, much as the web did for documents.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Oscar A. Testa 1 , Efraín R. Fonseca C. 2 , Germán Montejano 3 , and Oscar Dieste 4 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 70 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06908
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Framework to coordinate ubiquitous devices with SOA standards Oscar A. Testa 1 , Efraín R. Fonseca C. 2 , Germán Montejano 3 , and Oscar Dieste 4 Abstract Context: Ubiquitous devices and pervasive environments are in permanent interaction in people’s daily lives. In today’s hyper-connected environments, it is necessary for these devices to interact with each other, transparently to the users. The problem is analyzed from the different perspectives that compose it: SOA, service composition, interaction, and the capabilities of ubiquitous devices. Problem: Currently, ubiquitous devices can interact in a limited way due to the proprietary mechanisms and protocols available on the market. The few proposals from academia have hardly achieved an impact in practice. This is not in harmony with the situation of the Internet environment and web services, which have standardized mechanisms for service composition. Aim: Apply the principles of SOA, currently standardized and tested in the information systems industry, for the connectivity of ubiquitous devices in pervasive environments. For this, a coordination framework based on these technologies is proposed. Methodology: We apply an adaptation of Design Science in our environment to allow the iterative construction and evaluation of prototypes. For this, a proof of concept is developed on which this methodology and its cycles are based. Results: We built and put into operation a coordination framework for ubiquitous devices based on WS-CDL, along with a proof of concept. In addition, we contribute to the WS-CDL language in order to support the characteristics of specific ubiquitous devices. I Introduction Mark Weiser introduced the term ubiquitous computing (he also used the acronym ubicomp ) [ 1 ] in the late ’80s and early ’90s. Ubiquitous computing is a technology that claims computers are not seen as such so that they can be integrated into people’s lives in a transparent way [ 1 ] [ 2 ] . Ubiquitous devices are electronic devices with processing and communication capabilities and can be found anywhere: in the office, in the car, in the house, or even in the clothes we wear. Technological advances have allowed ubiquitous devices to be both generators and consumers of services [ 2 ] ;this results in an environment of inter-device cooperation, which allows for the composition of more complex functionalities. By composition, we understand how ubiquitous devices can be combined to perform a given task [ 3 ] . The composition implies that devices must communicate with each other to obtain a value-added service, which in turn brings challenges with it, such as heterogeneity, connectivity, fault tolerance, security, and customization of the devices, e.g., services provision according to user’s preferences. Since ubiquitous devices have resource limitations (e.g., limited memory and battery), special considerations should be made regarding the performance and efficiency of device composition. All these difficulties make the composition of ubiquitous devices an important area of research, where progress is not clear to this day [ 4 ] . The communication between ubiquitous devices is not usually carried out using standardized mechanisms; instead, most protocols are proprietary, e.g., alarm systems, communications between vehicles of a specific brand, household appliances, etc. This represents a significant limitation in the composition of ubiquitous devices [ 2 ] [ 4 ] , as it prevents devices from different manufacturers from interacting with each other or, alternatively, requires devices to implement multiple protocols (consider, for example, devices that simultaneously operate under Google Home 1 1 1 https://home.google.com/welcome/ and Alexa 2 2 2 https://www.alexa.com ), with the associated design complexities and costs this entails. In contrast to ubiquitous devices, other areas have standardized coordination mechanisms. An evident example is the Internet, where the TCP/IP protocol ensures communication between different nodes in the network. Other technologies that are de facto standards today The SOA (Service-Oriented Architecture) architecture represents a successful approach for creating applications through the composition of components that communicate with each other (using, in fact, the aforementioned technologies). The characteristics of SOA (heterogeneity and interoperability of services, hardware independence, flexible coupling, etc.) prompted us to bring together the existing specifications and standards in SOA for coordinating ubiquitous devices. If each ubiquitous device is considered as a provider or consumer of a service, ubiquitous devices fit perfectly into the SOA architecture. The advantages of adopting an SOA-like architecture in the ubiquitous world are numerous: standardization, transparency, and interoperability with other platforms. In contrast, the cost is quite low. We have verified that it is possible to execute WSCDL choreographies [ 5 ] [ 6 ] on ubiquitous devices with very limited resources. To achieve this, we have developed and adapted various existing mechanisms in SOA to be executable on low-performance devices, such as ubiquitous devices. Our contributions are as follows: • We have developed a framework (with versions in C++ and PHP) to coordinate ubiquitous devices using WSCDL choreographies. • We have made adaptations to the WSCDL standard to address common situations in ubiquitous devices, such as device disappearance and transaction handling. • We have implemented a proof of concept using devices with memory and processing limitations, such as Arduino boards and Raspberry Pi B+. The rest of the article is organized as follows: Section 2 describes the background and state of the art of ubiquitous systems, emphasizing coordination and SOA as a service coordination and composition mechanism. Section 3 details the selected research methodology and research aims. Section 4 describes the coordination framework developed. A concept test carried out to implement the developed framework is described in Section 5. Finally, Section 6 presents the conclusions and discussion. Section 7 presents the annexes, where the most important classes of both the framework and the proof of concept are shown. II Background II-A Ubiquitous computing Ubiquitous computing is a technological development aimed at making computers imperceptible in the environment as distinct objects, enabling their use by humans to be as transparent and convenient as possible, thereby facilitating integration into daily life. Ubiquitous devices are all those devices that can exist everywhere; in other words, they are electronic devices with processing and communication capabilities that can be found anywhere: the office, the car, or even the clothes we wear [ 1 ] . For several years, ubiquitous devices have gained importance in people’s daily lives, mainly because they feature different types of sensors (positioning, proximity, luminosity, temperature, etc.), facilitate connectivity even in areas with weak signal or limited network access, enable technological convergence (computing, media, telephony, etc.), and provide access to various services (maps, assistance, etc.) [ 7 ] . An example of everyday use is the ubiquitous devices available in a car, which II-B Pervasive systems The objective of ubiquitous computing is to allow users to access services and resources anytime, irrespective of their location. Pervasive computing is a related concept aiming to provide spontaneous services created on the fly [ 8 ] . Pervasive environments are characterized by being populated with numerous ubiquitous devices that, thanks to the extreme integration of electronic elements, are invisible to the user and constantly track human activity [ 7 ] [ 1 ] . An example of this is the use of location-based services, where areas of art, commerce, etc., are offered to us as we move through a given place. Pervasive systems are composed of