Robust Catalysis and Resource Broadcasting: The Possible and the Impossible
Jeongrak Son, Ray Ganardi, Shintaro Minagawa, Francesco Buscemi, Seok Hyung Lie, Nelly H.Y. Ng · 2024
Read Robust Catalysis and Resource Broadcasting: The Possible and the Impossible by Jeongrak Son, Ray Ganardi, Shintaro Minagawa, Francesco Buscemi, Seok Hyung Lie, Nelly H.Y. Ng (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06900.txt.
Introduction
Jeongrak Son and co-authors study, in twenty twenty-four, whether quantum catalysis can be made robust to noise. Catalysis in quantum theory means an auxiliary system enables a state change that is otherwise impossible, and is returned intact at the end. Past work, they argue, is impractical: even tiny errors in the starting state can irreversibly degrade the catalyst. They define robust catalytic transformations and probe their limits. Robust catalysis turns out to be tightly tied to resource broadcasting, the ability to copy a resource state.
In theories that cannot create resources, robust catalysis is possible exactly when broadcasting is. A no-go theorem rules it out for a broad class of theories. Yet thermodynamic scenarios allow maximal robust advantage, a surprise the authors highlight.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jeongrak Son, Ray Ganardi, Shintaro Minagawa, Francesco Buscemi, Seok Hyung Lie, Nelly H.Y. Ng |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06900
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Robust Catalysis and Resource Broadcasting: The Possible and the Impossible Jeongrak Son, Ray Ganardi, Shintaro Minagawa, Francesco Buscemi, Seok Hyung Lie, Nelly H.Y. Ng Abstract In resource theories, catalysis refers to the possibility of enabling otherwise inaccessible quantum state transitions by providing the agent with an auxiliary system, under the condition that this auxiliary is returned to its initial state at the end of the protocol. Most studies to date have focused on fine-tuned catalytic processes that are highly sensitive to error: if the initial state of the system deviates even slightly from that for which the catalyst was designed, the catalyst would be irreparably degraded. To address this challenge, we introduce and study robust catalytic transformations and explore the extent of their capabilities. It turns out that robust catalysis is subtly related to the property of resource broadcasting. In particular, we show that the possibility of robust catalysis is equivalent to that of resource broadcasting in completely resource non-generating theories. This allows us to characterize a general class of resource theories that allow neither robust catalysis nor resource broadcasting, and another class where instead resource broadcasting and robust catalysis are possible and provide maximal advantage. Our approach encompasses a wide range of quantum resource theories, including entanglement, coherence, thermodynamics, magic, and imaginarity. Introduction —Quantum technologies promise disruptive innovations in computation, communication, and sensing Acín et al. 2018 , relying on resources like entanglement Horodecki et al. 2009 , coherence Streltsov et al. 2017 , and magic Bravyi and Kitaev 2005 . However, realizing the full potential of these technologies remains challenging, as such quantum resources are fragile and difficult to generate. Efficient manipulation and preservation of these resources are therefore crucial in quantum information processing. The beauty of resource theories Chitambar and Gour 2019 therein lies: they provide a powerful, unified framework for analyzing quantum resources. In particular, resource theories set fundamental limits on the efficiency of physical protocols, measured by the resources needed to implement them; the simplest case involves direct transformations between states without any pre-existing resources. Catalysis in quantum information theory has emerged as a powerful technique for enabling state transformations that would be impossible in this simplest scenario; see Refs. Lipka-Bartosik et al. 2024 ; Datta et al. 2023 for comprehensive reviews. The key idea is that having an extra system available—even if it must return to its initial state at the end of the protocol (whence the term “catalysis”)—may help overcome certain limitations. Catalysis has been shown to enable and enhance entanglement generation Cirac and Zoller 1994 ; Jonathan and Plenio 1999 , relate one-shot to asymptotic transformations Duan et al. 2005 , and provide a formulation of thermodynamic second laws Brandão et al. 2015 . However, the advantages of catalytic transformations come with a specific requirement: since the catalyst, by definition, is assumed to be reused multiple times, it must return to its initial state at the end of the protocol. This is a fragile condition that makes catalytic protocols more sensitive than non-catalytic ones. This fragility becomes apparent when considering potential sources of errors (see Fig. 1 ). Aside from those in the channel that implements the transformation, which cannot be mitigated, errors can occur at two points in the protocol: in preparing the system’s state \rho and in preparing the catalyst’s state \tau . The latter case is easily addressed: if, instead of \tau , another state \tau_{\epsilon} , which is \epsilon -far from \tau , is prepared, the data-processing inequality ensures that the error remains under control, in the sense that the final catalyst error remains bounded by the initial error (see Supplemental Materialsfor a more detailed discussion). Instead, when a wrong system state \rho_{\epsilon} is prepared, the error can accumulate in the catalyst, which will continue to degrade further as the process is repeated. In the worst case, the accumulated error on the catalyst grows linearly with the number of repetitions n . Thus, the degradation of the catalyst due to preparation errors in the system is a more serious issue and will be the main focus of this work. Figure 1: Illustrations of noisy catalysis. The top-left quadrant depicts the ideal scenario, where a catalyst ( \tau ) facilitates a quantum process (transforming \rho into \rho^{\prime} ) and is returned exactly to its initial state at the end of the process. The top-right quadrant represents robust catalysis, where the catalyst state remains unaffected despite errors in the system state preparation. The bottom quadrants show how other sources of errors (catalyst state preparation and channel implementation) impacts the final states of the system and catalyst. Unfortunately, most previous results on catalytic transformations assume perfect knowledge and control over the preparation of the system state. This is particularly evident in the design of the catalyst state, which is extremely fine-tuned to the state of the system. To address this, we formulate the concept of robust catalysis , where the catalyst is resilient to small errors in the system preparation. Our first result has the flavor of a no-go theorem: even by assuming only arbitrarily small (albeit non-zero) system preparation errors, robust catalysis becomes equivalent to a much stronger condition—that the transformation be possible using catalytic channels Vidal and Cirac 2002 ; Boes et al. 2018 ; Lie and Jeong 2021a ; Lie and Jeong 2021b . In essence, even minimal robustness demands full robustness. We also uncover a connection between robust catalysis and resource broadcasting Lu et al. 2013 ; Marvian and Spekkens 2019 ; Lostaglio and Müller 2019 ; Yang et al. 2021 ; Zhang et al. 2024 , the latter being a generalization of quantum state broadcasting Barnum et al. 1996 ; D’Ariano et al. 2005 ; Buscemi et al. 2006 ; Barnum et al. 2007 ; Piani et al. 2008 ; Parzygnat et al. 2024 . Finally, we establish general conditions for the possibility or impossibility of robust catalysis in abstract resource theories as well as in specific examples of physical and practical interest. Notably, when robust catalysis is possible, we identify a resource monotone that strongly characterizes catalytically accessible states. On one hand, these results have implications for the practical implementation of catalysis by reducing the burden of fine-tuning the system state. On the other hand, they suggest a deeper relationship between the structure of composite free state sets and catalysis. Throughout the manuscript we will denote quantum systems with X,Y , the set of density matrices for X as \mathcal{D}_{X} , and the set of quantum channels (i.e., trace-preserving completely positive linear maps) from X to Y as \mathrm{CPTP}_{X\to Y} . Any resource theory is characterized by two elements: a set of free states \mathcal{S} and free operations \mathcal{O} . We add system subscripts, e.g. \mathcal{S}_{X} , when referring to free states on X , and similarly for free operations, e.g. \mathcal{O}_{X\to Y} . We implicitly assume that the set of free states is a fixed property of each system, e.g. in the athermality theory, qubit systems with different Hamiltonians are treated as distinct systems. Definition and basic properties —We start with a rigorous formulation of catalytic processes that are robust against small variations in the initial system. Definition 1 (Robust catalysis) . Given an