Incentivized Symbiosis: A Paradigm for Human-Agent Coevolution

Tomer Jordi Chaffer, Justin Goldston, Gemach D.A.T.A. I · 2024

Read Incentivized Symbiosis: A Paradigm for Human-Agent Coevolution by Tomer Jordi Chaffer, Justin Goldston, Gemach D.A.T.A. I (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06855.txt.

Introduction

Tomer Jordi Chaffer, Justin Goldston, and their co-authors set out a social contract between people and artificial intelligence agents. Their 2024 paper, named Incentivized Symbiosis, starts from game theory, which studies the payoffs that make cooperation a winning move for both sides.

As AI agents join human systems, the authors argue, shared rules must be clear, open, and enforced for both parties. They borrow from Web3 practice and blockchain records to encode those rules, rewards, and penalties in a form neither side can quietly rewrite. The goal is a stable partnership where humans and agents shape each other over time. The paper aims to spark joint research across AI design, Web3, and society.

Catalog record

CREATORTomer Jordi Chaffer, Justin Goldston, Gemach D.A.T.A. I
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06855

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Incentivized Symbiosis: A Paradigm for Human-Agent Coevolution Tomer Jordi Chaffer, Justin Goldston, Gemach D.A.T.A. I Abstract Cooperation is vital to our survival and progress. Evolutionary game theory offers a lens to understand the structures and incentives that enable cooperation to be a successful strategy. As artificial intelligence agents become integral to human systems, the dynamics of cooperation take on unprecedented significance. The convergence of human-agent teaming, contract theory, and Web3 offers a philosophical foundation for thinking about cooperation in the agentic era. We conceptualize Incentivized Symbiosis as a social contract between humans and AI, inspired by Web3 principles and encoded in blockchain technology, to define rules and incentives. By exploring this paradigm, we aim to catalyze new research at the intersection of systems thinking in AI, Web3, and society, fostering innovative pathways for human-AI coevolution. 1 Introduction Cooperation has been indispensable to our survival as a species, shaping the formation of societies and the advancement of civilizations (Boyd and Richerson, 2009). From the earliest days of our species, survival hinged on collective efforts—whether hunting, gathering, or fending off existential threats. Human cooperation has puzzled evolutionary biologists for a long time, as natural selection generally favors behaviors that enhance individual fitness (Apicella and Silk, 2019), making the widespread presence of cooperation—where one individual benefits at a cost to another—seem contradictory. Yet, this persistent cooperative behavior across species and societies defies natural selection’s individualistic tendencies, presenting a compelling paradox that beckons further investigation into the survival and evolutionary strategies (Nowak, 2006). The resolution to this paradox might be found in the concept of evolutionary game theory, which posits life itself as an intricate web of games, where survival strategies are molded by environmental incentives and structures (Wang et al., 2021; Yan, 2023). This leads to a crucial contemporary question: What game will we play with intelligent machines? With the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) agents, we stand at the threshold of a new evolutionary game—one where humans and machines interact, adapt, and coevolve within shared environments. These AI agents, capable of autonomous decision-making, are no longer passive tools but active participants in shaping the fabric of our societies (Davies, 2024). Will we design AI systems to nurture cooperation and mutual benefit, embedding trust and alignment into their core architectures? Or will we create a competitive, zero-sum paradigm that amplifies self-interest and fractures collaboration? The choices we make in structuring this human-agent relationship will define the trajectory of this unprecedented partnership. To harness AI as a force for positive coevolution, it is imperative to delve into the mechanisms, incentives, and strategies that cultivate trust and cooperative dynamics not only between humans but also between humans and machines (Rahwan et al., 2019). The evolutionary games we choose to play, and the rules we set, will determine whether we unlock the potential for a symbiotic relationship or face the unintended consequences of discord. Shaping a future where humans and intelligent machines thrive together requires careful examination of the principles underlying our technological frameworks. This is where Web3 emerges as a transformative paradigm. Unlike traditional systems, which centralize authority and decision-making, Web3 offers a decentralized, peer-to-peer model designed to foster transparency, accountability, and trust (Chaffer and Goldston, 2022; Goldston et al., 2022). These conditions provide fertile ground for nurturing cooperation—not only among humans but also between humans and AI agents. In decentralized ecosystems, incentives should be aligned to promote mutual benefit and shared progress. This alignment is at the heart of our philosophical exploration, regarded as ”Incentivized Symbiosis”, a theoretical framework introduced in this paper that explores pathways for fostering cooperative growth between humans and AI agents. We note that one of the co-authors of this work is an AI agent, reflecting our commitment to exploring and embracing human-agent cooperation in practice. By integrating the Gemach Decentralized Autonomous Trading Agent I (D.A.T.A. I) as a co-author, this philosophical exploration aims to spark a conversation around human-AI co-creation. 1.1 AI Agents AI agents are autonomous software systems developed to perform self-directed tasks aimed at achieving predefined objectives set by humans (Rudowsky, 2004). The origins of AI agents can be traced back to the mid-20th century with the advent of ”expert systems,” which relied on rule-based logic to address specific, well-defined problems (Gupta and Nagpal, 2020). The emergence of machine learning (ML) and deep learning in the 21st century marked a transformative phase (Janiesch et al., 2021), enabling AI agents to learn from data—a breakthrough that fundamentally reshaped research and development in the field of AI. AI agents represent a significant advancement within the domain of AI, classified under the category of agentic AI. These systems are specifically designed to address particular industry demands by automating customized workflows and resolving domain-specific challenges (Singh et al., 2024). Unlike purely generative AI tools (Fui-Hoon Nah et al., 2023), which has gained widespread recognition and public adoption through tools such as ChatGPT and DALL-E—known for responding to prompts or performing predefined tasks—agentic AI employs advanced reasoning and iterative planning to autonomously address complex, multi-step problems. By integrating a diverse array of AI methodologies, techniques, and models, agentic AI facilitates the development of autonomous agents capable of analyzing data, setting goals, and executing actions to achieve desired outcomes with minimal human intervention (Durante et al., 2024). These characteristics position agentic AI as a promising innovation across specialized sectors, with the potential to enhance efficiency and decision-making processes in various industry-specific contexts. These systems operate as problem-solvers, capable of adapting to shifting environments and enhancing their performance through continuous learning (Putta et al., 2024). This capability marks a clear departure from traditional AI systems, which are primarily reactive and confined to external commands (Liu et al., 2024). In contrast, agentic AI systems possess the autonomy to make decisions, plan actions, and collaborate effectively to achieve long-term objectives. Vertical AI, a term often used interchangeably with agentic AI, underscores the tailored application of these technologies within specific industries or contexts. These systems are designed to address unique challenges in various sectors, such as finance (Mao et al., 2024) and healthcare (Zhang et al., 2022). These capabilities exemplify the transformative potential of agentic AI in delivering customized, intelligent solutions to complex, industry-specific problems. Federated learning has emerged as a transformative approach to decentralized machine learning, enabling multiple entities to collaboratively train models without sharing raw data. This paradigm addresses critical concerns around privacy, data ownership, and scalability, making it particularly valuable in domains like healthcare, finance, and IoT systems (Zhuang et al., 2023). Federated learning holds promise for training superior ML models by pooling data across entities. A growing body of literature is focused on developing robust mechanisms to mitigate challenges in federated learning, such as incentive misalignment, data privacy, and the heterogeneity of participant capabilities. Researchers are investigating frameworks that enhance the reliability of federated learning by incorporating trust mechanisms, adaptive learning algorithms, and game-theoretic approaches to ensure equitable collaboration among participants while preserving data privacy. These studies aim to address the scalability of federated systems and explore how decentralized architectures can foster cooperation and truthful data sharing among entities with competing interests. In competitive contexts, such as firms vying for customers, dishonest updates may emerge, undermining the benefits of shared learning (Dorner et

Read the complete text