Harmonic Mean Density Fusion in Distributed Tracking: Performance and Comparison
Nikhil Sharma, Ratnasingham Tharmarasa, Thiagalingam Kirubarajan · 2024
Read Harmonic Mean Density Fusion in Distributed Tracking: Performance and Comparison by Nikhil Sharma, Ratnasingham Tharmarasa, Thiagalingam Kirubarajan (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06725.txt.
Introduction
Sharma, Tharmarasa, and Kirubarajan weigh a mean fuse way for spread track work. Spread sense webs beat one-hub webs on load, fail grace, and growth. Tracks, not raw reads, get fused in such webs by plan. Yet tracks share dim ties that break plain fuse tools cold. A stock fix gives near-best marks but with plump doubt spans. Those plump spans slow the shrink of miss marks in runs.
A mean fuse way, called HMD, is set out in the work. It seems to bear both the tie snag and mix-shape tracks. The team shows the way stems from a least-mean split rule. That rule uses the Pearson split as its loss mark. A step plan for the fuse joins the proof work.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nikhil Sharma, Ratnasingham Tharmarasa, Thiagalingam Kirubarajan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06725
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Harmonic Mean Density Fusion in Distributed Tracking: Performance and Comparison Nikhil Sharma, Ratnasingham Tharmarasa, Thiagalingam Kirubarajan Abstract A distributed sensor fusion architecture is preferred in a real target-tracking scenario as compared to a centralized scheme since it provides many practical advantages in terms of computation load, communication bandwidth, fault-tolerance, and scalability. In multi-sensor target-tracking literature, such systems are better known by the pseudonym—track fusion, since processed tracks are fused instead of raw measurements. A fundamental problem, however, in such systems is the presence of unknown correlations between the tracks, which renders a standard Kalman filter (naive fusion) useless. A widely-accepted solution is covariance intersection (CI) which provides near-optimal estimates but at the cost of a conservative covariance. Thus, the estimates are pessimistic, which might result in a delayed error convergence. Also, fusion of Gaussian mixture densities is an active area of research where standard methods of track fusion cannot be used. In this article, harmonic mean density (HMD) based fusion is discussed, which seems to handle both of these issues. We present insights on HMD fusion and prove that the method is a result of minimizing average Pearson divergence. This article also provides an alternative and easy implementation based on an importance-sampling-like method without the requirement of a proposal density. Similarity of HMD with inverse covariance intersection is an interesting find, and has been discussed in detail. Results based on a real-world multi-target multi-sensor scenario show that the proposed approach converges quickly than existing track fusion algorithms while also being consistent, as evident from the normalized estimation-error squared (NEES) plots. Journal: Signal Processing 1 Introduction Even though sensor technologies are reaching new heights in terms of accuracy, size, processing time, and portability, it is still not prudent to depend on a single sensor for large-scale systems. A multi-sensor system provides unmatched benefits, including accuracy, fault tolerance, scalability, and, in some cases, observability. In the widely researched domain of multiple target tracking, the employed sensors have a limited field of view (FOV), which constrains their applicability. Thus, to scale the area of observation, multiple sensors are deployed, which transmit their observations either in the form of raw measurements (centralized) or process the raw data before sending the resulting processed observations (tracks) to a fusion facility. Such networked architectures are highly employed in systems such as simultaneous localization and mapping (SLAM), autonomous vehicles, air traffic control, adversary interception, underwater surveillance, and others. The architecture wherein raw observations are processed locally using standard techniques like a Kalman filter and sent to the nearest fusion center is the focus of this article. Such an architecture is better suited to cater multi-sensor target tracking problems since it offers numerous advantages in comparison to a centralized mechanism. These include, (i) Clutter management at the local node level, thus reducing link bandwidth requirements. (ii) Homogeneity of track state space, which eases track association. (iii) Fault-tolerance due to the existence of multiple local fusion centers. (iv) Near optimal performance. (v) Full communication rate is not required, as the local node has the ease to transmit tracks only when they are confirmed by the local track-management scheme. Since the local node is assumed to employ a Kalman filter like estimator, the processed observations that are transmitted to the fusion center are generally parameters of the posterior density of the target state conditioned upon measurements. Due to such reasons, distributed systems in the target-tracking domain are termed track-to-track fusion (T2TF) or simply track-fusion. Since a standard Kalman filter assumes independence between measurements and target-state errors, it cannot be used to fuse tracks as they are correlated, primarily due to the following three reasons, (i) Due to the presence of common process noise in tracks originating from the same target. (ii) Correlation due to the same statistics used in track initialization among local nodes. (iii) Correlation between a global (fused) and a local track due to the presence of a common history of measurements. This occurs in fusion centers with memory and can be removed by restarting global track periodically. There are two major classes of solution preferred for the case of track-fusion – 1. Bayesian methods, 2. Pooling methods . The Bayesian methods refer to the solution where Bayes’ theorem is employed in some sense either after decorrelating the local tracks, or by computing a globalized likelihood function using local node parameters. It is also possible to compute the exact value of cross-correlation between any two local tracks using the recursion provided in [ 1 ] , but this would require knowledge of the local Kalman gain at each fusion instant and also memory for storing {}^{n}C_{2} number of cross-correlations at the fusion center, for n nodes. Such methods includes the optimal T2TF algorithm, information matrix fusion, and, tracklet-fusion. Using a standard Kalman filter by ignoring cross-correlation is usually termed as naive fusion. The pooling methods combine probability density functions directly using mixing weights such that some criteria is minimized. Under the target-tracking domain, such methods include the famous covariance intersection and its variants, and also its generalized form known as the geometric mean density (GMD) fusion. These methods are preferred due to their relative ease of implementation in the Gaussian case. The ease of implementation stems from the fact that these methods do not inquire into the nature of cross-correlation. Thus, extra information from the local node viz. Kalman gain, local prior estimates since last fusion or sensor characteristics are not required for fusion (at least for the ideal case). Such methods include the covariance intersection (CI) and its variants. A new class of pooling method known as harmonic mean density (HMD) based track fusion was introduced by the authors in [ 2 ] , which is also the focus of this article. 1.1 Covariance Intersection and Variants For a known cross-covariance, the resulting fused covariance ellipsoid can be shown to lie in the intersection between the local covariance ellipsoids [ 3 , 4 ] . Thus, a convex combination of the covariance and mean of the estimates should yield a consistent fused estimate [ 3 ] , which was utilized in the formulation of the original covariance intersection algorithm. In the presence of unknown cross-correlations, CI constitutes an upper bound on the cross-correlation, which makes it conservative. Later, many variants have been proposed to increase the tightness of this upper bound. One such variant is the split-covariance intersection filter (SCIF), which assumes that a single local track is a package consisting of independent and dependent estimates separately, such that the local estimate is a weighted sum of independent and dependent estimates. The algorithm then operates on these components in a way similar to the covariance intersection algorithm. The result is the fused estimates with their dependent and correlated components. The existence of a correlation such that independent and dependent components sum up to form a track is, however, vague. Also, the independent parts of a track are impossible to identify. If both components are available explicitly at the fusion center, then an optimal algorithm could be possible, according to the author’s knowledge. The ellipsoidal intersection (EI) in [ 5 ] aims to separate the mutual and exclusive information contents from a local estimate and fuse them such that