Indigenous knowledges and kinship as a model for our future in outer space Journal: Astronomy in Focus, Volume 1
Hilding Neilson 1 · 2024
Read Indigenous knowledges and kinship as a model for our future in outer space Journal: Astronomy in Focus, Volume 1 by Hilding Neilson 1 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06669.txt.
Introduction
Hilding Neilson argues in a 2024 talk that views from Native peoples should shape how humans live and work in space. Firms have already harmed the bond between people and space, he notes. New accords will open the Moon to trade and may deepen that harm.
Neilson reviews Native ways of knowing and puts kinship at the center. Kinship treats the Moon and space as relations to care for, not things to use up. He draws lessons that could guide acts on Earth and in space alike. The talk asks readers to build a shared future in space on respect rather than profit alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hilding Neilson 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06669
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Indigenous knowledges and kinship as a model for our future in outer space Journal: Astronomy in Focus, Volume 1 Hilding Neilson 1 Abstract Commercial endeavours have already compromised our relationship with space. The Artemis Accords are creating a framework that will commercialize the Moon and further impact that relation. To confront that impact, a number of organizations have begun to develop new principles of sustainability in space, many of which are borne out of the capitalist and colonial frameworks that have harmed water, nature, peoples and more on Earth. Indigenous methodologies and ways of knowing offer different paths for living in relationship with space and the Moon. While Indigenous knowledges are not homogeneous, there are lessons we can use from some of common methods. In this talk we will review some Indigenous methodologies, including the concept of kinship and discuss how kinship can inform our actions both on Earth and in space. keywords Indigenous Methods, Indigenous Rights 1 Introduction The Outer Space Treaty ( 1 1 1 https://www.unoosa.org/oosa/en/ourwork/spacelaw/treaties/outerspacetreaty.html ) notes that activities in outer space should be for the “benefit of all mankind”. However, the current explosive growth of the private space industry has impacted the human relationship with the night sky, celestial objects such as the Moon, and outer space itself. In that sense, not all of humanity seems to benefit from these endeavours. In particular, a number of actors, including the International Astronomical Union, have been developing new reports and conferences with the aim of mitigating the impact of a minimally regulated space industry including the SATCON1 and SATCON2 reports led by the National Science Foundation’s National Optical-Infrared Astronomy Research Laboratory ( [ Walker et al. (2020b) , Hall et al. (2021) , Walker et al. 2020b, Hall et al. 2021] ) and the Dark & Quiet Skies for Science and Society conferences led by the International Astronomical Union (IAU) and the United Nations Office of Outer Space Affairs and others ( [ Walker et al. (2020a) , Walker et al. 2020a] ). In these reports, Indigenous peoples are treated as a stakeholder along with planetaria and amateur astronomy groups and in some of the reports as victims of this growing light and space pollution. In the latter sense arguments are made that light pollution will negatively impact ancient practices and connections with the night sky, usually without input from Indigenous peoples and ignoring that Indigenous peoples have modern cultures. In this presentation, I aim to consider the discussion of protecting the night sky and outer space through a lens of Indigenous methodologies as a third perspective from the current binary discussion that pits outer space as only an exploitable resource that benefits the growing space industrial complex against the argument led by astronomers that outer space must be treated as a natural environment that must be protected and be untouched (e.g., [ Lawrence et al.(2022) , Lawrence et al. 2022] ). This third method is motivated from the perspective that both sides of current discussion are colonial, and that both minimize the rights of Indigenous peoples with respect to outer space. To that end this presentation is designed to advocate for policy changes that centre and include Indigenous peoples, nations, and methods and moves beyond community engagement ( [ Barentine & Heim, (2023) , Barentine & Heim 2023] ). Before continuing the discussion, it is necessary to acknowledge that the author is Mi’kmaq and Settler and can only speak to that experience. Furthermore, as a professional astronomer the author acknowledges that the field of professional astronomy has benefited from past, current, and ongoing colonization, particularly in Chile 2 2 2 https://astrobites.org/2019/09/10/astronomical-observatories-and-indigenous-communities-in-chile/ , Hawai’i ( [ Salazar2014 , Salazar 2014] ), and elsewhere. There is an irony that the professional astronomy community seeks to engage with Indigenous peoples with respect to activities in outer space while ignoring and dismissing Indigenous peoples when building observatories. 2 The coloniality of space exploitation and space environmentalism Much of the current discourse in the current era of outer space exploration that has become a narrative of space exploitation. This narrative has been growing with the Artemis Accords 3 3 3 https://www.nasa.gov/artemis-accords/ that seek to provide a set of guidelines for resource extraction in outer space and on the Moon, with an eye to asteroid mining and Martian exploration. The Accords, while designed to not directly conflict with the Outer Space Treaty, allows for operators to remove material from bodies in outer space and not to be interfered with in locations where operators have equipment and satellites. The Accords claim that no private operator or nation state can claim territory in outer space, yet they allow for operators to remove material and effectively ’squat’. Even if this does not mean ownership in outer space, it follows a path of the 19th-century Gold Rush where prospectors staked claims and took whatever was considered valuable while often leaving nothing but waste. In that case, many of these gold rushes significantly harmed Indigenous peoples, stole Indigenous lands, and had significant negative impact on the local plants, animals, and waters that had been there since time immemorial. As such the Artemis Accords are colonial. That colonialism is not new. [ Trevño (2020) , Treviño (2020)] noted how the history of space exploration is part of a colonial narrative that has existed for centuries. From the first manual on the colonization of Mars by Werner Von Braun, the development of outer space activities have been justified by the same narrative that colonists used to settle the Americas: terra nullius, and Manifest Destiny. In many ways the growth of light pollution around the world is also part of this colonialism and terra nullius. [ Hamacher et al. (2020) , Hamacher et al. (2020)] wrote that "Light Pollution is Cultural Genocide" on the principle that many Indigenous nations and peoples write stories in their constellations (both star-based and “dark” constellations). These stories carry significant cultural, scientific and holistic knowledges that continue to be a crucial part of those cultures. In the same way that light pollution is colonisation, so too is light pollution from satellites. Whiles light pollution acts to erases Indigenous knowledges and stories, the growth of bright satellites aim to rewrite them. This, too, is a significant colonial problem. On the other hand, an increasingly commonly touted solution for regulation is to treat outer space as part of the environment. While this might appear to be a way to include Indigenous peoples and methods in the conversation about regulating outer space, much of the environmental movement has been colonial. One such example is the development of the National Park systems in Canada and the United States that stole land from Indigenous peoples in the name of conservationism. It is notable that the clause in the Artemis Accords citing the need to preserve sites of cultural importance will potentially act in the same manner, creating “National Parks” on the Moon based on the interests of Eurocentric cultures. Furthermore, how this outer space environmentalism will be implemented will arguably be centred on the interests of nation states, especially the richest states that can afford the investment necessary for outer space exploitation. Part of the space interests of these states is