Different Theories of Parts
Andrzej Pietruszczak · 2024
Read Different Theories of Parts by Andrzej Pietruszczak (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06663.txt.
Introduction
Andrzej Pietruszczak compares theories of parts and wholes in a 2024 philosophy paper, an English version of a Polish article. The field, mereology, began with Leśniewski's system, which was framed in an unusual way. Modern writers recast it as an elementary theory or in the language of relational structures. Pietruszczak sorts theories by how much existence they assume.
Some theories postulate no collective sets beyond what the definition of a part and its basic rules deliver. Others, including Leśniewski's own and Grzegorczyk's version, assume more. A closing section questions a core principle, the transitivity of the part relation, which much literature treats as obvious. The paper serves readers of formal ontology who need the landscape of part theories in one place.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrzej Pietruszczak |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06663
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Different Theories of Parts Thanks: It is the English version of the article “Różne teorie części’, Przegląd Filozoficzny – Nowa Seria , 32 (1): 125–148 (2023; published 2024; https://doi.org/10.18778/0138-0680.2024.12 ). This research was funded in whole or in part by the National Science Centre (NCN), Poland, grant no. 2021/43/B/HS1/03187. For the purpose of Open Access, the author has applied a CC-BY public copyright licence to any Author Accepted Manuscript (AAM) version arising from this submission. Andrzej Pietruszczak Abstract . Stanisław Leśniewski’s mereology was formulated in a specific way, deviating from standard formalizations. Nowadays, Leśniewski’s theory is presented in the form of an elementary theory or translated into the language of the theory of relational structures. In this article, firstly, we look at <<existentially neutral>> theories, in which we do not postulate the existence of any other collective sets than those obtained from the definition and the basic properties of the relation of being a part. We also examine some <<existentially involved>> theories of parts. Among them, there is Grzegorczykian mereology and Leśniewskian mereology. One of the main principles of mereology is the transitivity of the concept of being a part of . This property is often questioned in the literature on the subject. In the final part, we present problems related to the transitivity of this concept. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 03-03 1. Introduction Mereology emerged as a theory of collective sets (or, in modern times, mereological sums). It was constructed by the Polish logician Stanisław Leśniewski ( 1916 , 1991a , 1927 – 1931 , 1991b ). Collective sets are certain wholes composed of parts and the very notion of being a collective set can be defined by means of the relational notion of being a part of . 1 1 1 Leśniewski is not the creator of the notion of a collective set or a collective class. They are discussed by, for example, Whitehead and Russell in their commentaries in Principia Mathematica ( 1910 ) . These sets were used by, among others, Whitehead in his considerations of the philosophy of spacetime ( 1929 , see, e.g.) . Leśniewski gave two formal definitions of collective sets (classes). In his theory, both definitions are equivalent. Therefore, mereology can be considered a theory of the “relation of parts to the whole” (from the Greek \mathord{\mu}\acute{\mathord{\varepsilon}}\!\mathord{\rho}\mathord{o}\mathord{\varsigma} means ‘part’). Leśniewski’s mereology was formulated in a specific way, differing from standard formulations. This theory was built on another system of Leśniewski’s, which he called “Ontology”. Nowadays, Leśniewski’s theory is presented in the form of a certain elementary theory or by translating it into the language of the theory of relational structures. It can also be analyzed using the so-called plural logic. Since the etymology of the word ‘mereology’ corresponds to the meaning of the phrase ‘theory of parts’, the former can be used to refer to any formal or semi-formal considerations of parts and not only to Leśniewski’s theory. We believe, however, that this may cause some terminological confusion. When considering theories weaker than Leśniewski’s theory, we should rather add appropriate qualifying adjectives, as Peter Simons (1987) did, for example, when he examined “Minimal Extensional Mereology”. In ( Pietruszczak, 2013 ; Pietruszczak, 2020 ) , various existentially neutral and existentially involved theories of parts are analyzed. In the former, we do not postulate the existence of any other collective sets than those that we obtain from the basic properties of the relation of being a part . 2 2 2 Note that collective sets composed of only physical (material) objects are to be objects of the same kind. For example, in such theories, we will not obtain the existence of a collective set formed from two objects that are parts of a third one. We do not, therefore, postulate the existence of a collective set consisting of the right and left hands of a given person. Leśniewski’s mereology is classified as an existentially involved theory. Their existential involvement consists in the fact that they have additional axioms postulating the existence of collective sets of various groups of objects. Some of such sets can be considered as objects obtained ad hoc , which is therefore controversial. For example, it is difficult to accept that there is a material object that would be a collective set consisting of the Moon and the heart of a given person ( Pietruszczak, 2000a ; Pietruszczak, 2000b ; Pietruszczak, 2005 ; Pietruszczak, 2018 ) . What is more, the existence of a separate object that would be a collective set of the right and left hands of a given person is even problematic. In Leśniewski’s theory, on the other hand, the unlimited existence of collective sets for all (non-empty) groups of objects (including infinite ones) is postulated. It seems that such a solution is only admissible in pointless geometry and pointless topology, which concern spatial regions or space-time events. 3 3 3 Let us add that in these pointless theories, we have points. However, they are not assumed as primitive. They are defined on the basis of primitive concepts such as spheres, solids, or regions, using the relation of being of a part of ( Tarski, 1929 ; Tarski, 1956 ; Grzegorczyk, 1960 ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2008 ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2009 ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2018a ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2018b ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2019 ; Gruszczyński & Pietruszczak, 2023 , see, e.g.,) . In Section 2 , we will present the basic concepts of mereology. In Section 3 , we will deal with mereological sums as collective classes of a given group of objects. In Section 4 , we will present existentially neutral theories. Theories that are existentially involved will be presented in Section 5 . Among them will be the strongest of them—Leśniewskian mereology and two theories proposed by Andrzej Grzegorczyk (1955) . In the final section, we will sketch a problem related to the transitivity of the concept of being a part of . This property is often called into question in the literature. We present an analysis without the assumed transitivity. 2. Basic concepts of mereology In this section, we will present the basic concepts of the theory of parthood and their fundamental formal properties. We will assume that the relational concept of being a part of should create a strict partial order in any universe of considerations, i.e., it should be transitive and irreflexive, which also gives asymmetry. Moreover, in all non-degenerate universes (i.e. those that have at least two elements), there should be no smallest object (zero), and instead, there should be two objects that have no common part. 2.1. Parts as fragments In everyday speech, the expression ‘part’ is usually understood as having the sense of the expressions ‘fragment’, ‘bit’ and ‘piece’ when we relate them to spatial objects (regions) or spatiotemporal events. Thus understood, the relation of a part to the whole has two properties: (a) no object is its own part; (b) there are not two objects such that the first could be a part of the second and the second a part of the first. Thanks to condition ( a ), we have no difficulty in interpreting the phrase ‘two objects’ in condition ( b