Challenges and Opportunities for Visual Analytics in Jurisprudence

Daniel Fürst 0000-0002-0407-2867, Mennatallah El-Assady 0000-0001-8526-2613, Daniel A. Keim 0000-0001-7966-9740, Maximilian T. Fischer 0000-0001-8076-1376 · 2024

Read Challenges and Opportunities for Visual Analytics in Jurisprudence by Daniel Fürst 0000-0002-0407-2867, Mennatallah El-Assady 0000-0001-8526-2613, Daniel A. Keim 0000-0001-7966-9740, Maximilian T. Fischer 0000-0001-8076-1376 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06543.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Fürst and co-authors map how visual analytics could serve legal scholarship in a 2024 paper. Lawyers and legal scholars wrestle with dense texts, hidden concepts, and deliberate ambiguity. Visual analytics, which pairs interactive graphics with data analysis, has helped in other text-heavy fields. Law, though, has formal structure and reasoning steps that current tools rarely honor.

Interviews with nine legal experts showed that search tools do not match how law is navigated. Experts fall back on knowledge in their own heads. The authors trace a three-phase workflow in expert work. They spot where graphics could help: drawing knowledge out into view, tracking how a conclusion was reached, and using tree, graph, and hierarchy views. They set a research agenda for tools built around tacit legal knowledge.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel Fürst 0000-0002-0407-2867, Mennatallah El-Assady 0000-0001-8526-2613, Daniel A. Keim 0000-0001-7966-9740, Maximilian T. Fischer 0000-0001-8076-1376
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06543

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Challenges and Opportunities for Visual Analytics in Jurisprudence Daniel Fürst 0000-0002-0407-2867, Mennatallah El-Assady 0000-0001-8526-2613, Daniel A. Keim 0000-0001-7966-9740, Maximilian T. Fischer 0000-0001-8076-1376 Abstract Legal exploration, analysis, and interpretation remain complex and demanding tasks, even for experienced legal scholars, due to the domain-specific language, tacit legal concepts, and intentional ambiguities embedded in legal texts. In related, text-based domains, Visual Analytics (VA) and Large Language Models (LLMs) have become indispensable tools for navigating documents, representing knowledge, and supporting analytical reasoning. However, legal scholarship presents distinct challenges: it requires managing formal legal structure, drawing on tacit domain knowledge, and documenting intricate and accurate reasoning processes – needs that current VA systems designs and LLMs fail to address adequately. We identify previously unexamined key challenges and underexplored opportunities in applying VA to jurisprudence to explore how these technologies might better serve the legal domain. Based on semi-structured interviews with nine legal experts, we find a significant gap in tools and means that can externalize tacit legal knowledge in a form that is both explicit and machine-interpretable. Hence, we propose leveraging interactive visualization for this articulation, teaching the machine relevant semantic relationships between legal documents that inform the predictions of LLMs, facilitating the enhanced navigation between hierarchies of legal collections. This work introduces a user-centered VA workflow to the jurisprudential context, recognizing tacit legal knowledge and expert experience as vital components in deriving legal insight, comparing it with established practices in other text-based domains, and outlining a research agenda that offers future guidance for researchers in Visual Analytics for law and beyond. keywords Visual Analytics, Large Language Models, Tacit Knowledge, Jurisprudence 1 Introduction Legal text data is vast Fobbe ; Fobbe ; Fobbe but inherently structured ( Rüthers et al. , pp. 92–93) . It combines domain-specific language ( Rüthers et al. , p. 123) and precise phraseology with intentional ambiguity at times ( Rüthers et al. , p. 128) . This ambiguity allows for statutory interpretation ( Rüthers et al. , p. 22) , enabling laws to evolve alongside societal norms and values. For instance, in 2018, the German Federal Constitutional Court interpreted the protection of life and physical integrity according to Art. 2 Abs. 2 Satz 1 GG to include protection against the dangers of climate change Bundesverfassungsgericht . The legal text merely states that “every person shall have the right to life and physical integrity. Freedom of the person shall be inviolable.” This interpretation underscores that considering legal norms in isolation is insufficient; comprehensive statutory interpretation also relies on an extensive understanding of fundamental and specific legal principles ( Rüthers et al. , pp. 92–93, 460) . These legal principles are formed and conceived within individual jurisdictions and a legal system. Several legal systems co-exist in our world, where common law and civil law are predominant Glenn , the latter being the most widespread. While the Anglo-American common law system relies on judicial precedents and case law, the civil law system, rooted in codes and statutes, lends itself to more structured analysis. These differences are the focus of comparative law studies, reaching back centuries Schmitthoff ; Zimmermann . Seminal work Fikentscher ; David and Brierley has analyzed how methodologies and approaches are comparable. Nevertheless, legal practices can differ between jurisdictions, even within the same legal system. In particular, with more tight integrations in, for example, the European Union, flushing out the differences and similarities is crucial Schadbach . While differences remain, recent research has shown that broader concepts like goals, methods, and structures remain similar across countries within one legal system Rossi and Sacco ; Reimann and Zimmermann ; Zweigert and Kötz . These similarities provide a foundational starting point for examining how the concept of Visual Analytics (VA) Keim et al. from computer science can enhance legal research practices. We use the German legal system as an example for our initial analysis, leveraging the expertise of several domain experts available. At the same time, the findings can remain generalizable to at least civil law. To navigate the landscape of the legal domain, scholars have developed working methods to aid in the interpretation of legal materials, including implicit structures, schemata, and principles ( Rüthers et al. , p. 450) , which are trained and ingrained through years of studies. Visualizations can enhance these methods by improving comprehension and communicating mental models Passalacqua ; Brunschwig . While the legal domain usually employs visualization for a specific purpose on selected occasions Passalacqua ; Brunschwig , it is an integral part of human-centered and data-driven workflows Keim et al. in computer science. By utilizing computational methods and increasingly available machine-readable legal documents Vogel , data-driven jurisprudence can efficiently extract knowledge from legal data, complementing traditional doctrinal analysis Lettieri Nicola ; Vaciago Giuseppe . Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Artificial Intelligence (AI) have significantly advanced the efficiency and scalability of textual analysis in legal contexts, also driven by Large Language Models (LLMs) Brown et al. ; OpenAI et al. . Nevertheless, the transition from linguistic processing to a computational understanding of legal language remains incomplete Baker . Current NLP techniques and AI models frequently lack the nuanced legal comprehension Vaciago Giuseppe necessary to interpret legal material and infer legal concepts. At the same time, the digitization of law is fraught with challenges. Substantial portions of legal documents, such as law commentaries, remain restricted by license models and are rarely publicly available. Moreover, some countries lag in legislative efforts to make legal documents available in structured, digital formats Zander . In Germany, for example, less than 1% of associated legal texts are openly available LTO . Consequently, existing open German legal databases (refer to Table 1 ) offer limited functionality to improve efficiency. Interfaces are primarily keyword-based searches , which often lack context-awareness and fail to account for implicit meanings or relationships Verlag C.H.BECK oHG ; juris GmbH ; Vogel . To address these gaps, several commercial solutions have emerged beyond the two primary commercial German databases, beck-online Verlag C.H.BECK oHG and juris juris GmbH , similar to the Anglo-American Westlaw Thomson Reuters and LexisNexis LexisNexis Legal & Professional , which primarily feature keyword-search and backlinks. LEX AI offers tools for monitoring regulatory changes and curating personalized feeds with summaries and synopses of regulatory changes supported by AI LEX AI GmbH . LeReTo KG enriches documents with links to related materials LeReTo KG . Meanwhile, tools like JURA KI Assistent RA-MICRO Software AG and Justin Legal Justin LegalTech GmbH assist with tasks like legal drafting and management. The European Union (EU) offers several information retrieval tools for European and national law and jurisdiction, including EUR-Lex Publications Office of the European Union , N-Lex Publications Office of the European Union , and the e-Justice Portal Directorate-General for Justice and Consumers . Furthermore, the EU provides LEOS European Commission , a collaborative online software platform for drafting European legislation with version control. In line with these efforts, the EU advocates for the Interoperable Europe Act The European Parliament And The Council Of The European Union , which aims to enhance the interoperability of public administrations across its member states by implementing standardized technical solutions for digital services provided to EU citizens. This act also contributes to developing open legal

Read the complete text