Semi-analytical algorithms to study longitudinal beam instabilities in double rf systems

A. Gamelin, V. Gubaidulin, M. B. Alves, T. Olsson · 2024

Read Semi-analytical algorithms to study longitudinal beam instabilities in double rf systems by A. Gamelin, V. Gubaidulin, M. B. Alves, T. Olsson (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06539.txt.

Introduction

Gamelin and co-authors give fast formulas for beam stability in double radio-frequency systems. Their 2024 paper serves fourth-generation light sources, which pair main and harmonic cavities. The pairing calms some collective effects yet breeds new instabilities with names like Robinson and transient beam loading.

Their semi-analytical methods predict those instabilities with better accuracy and robustness than past tools. They also run far faster than full multibunch tracking simulations. A case study on the SOLEIL II project shows the methods tuning cavity settings across a wide space. The tuning aims to stretch a key beam lifetime as far as it will go. An open Python package ships with the work.

Catalog record

CREATORA. Gamelin, V. Gubaidulin, M. B. Alves, T. Olsson
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE81 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06539

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Semi-analytical algorithms to study longitudinal beam instabilities in double rf systems A. Gamelin, V. Gubaidulin, M. B. Alves, T. Olsson Abstract Double rf systems are critical for achieving the parameters of 4th-generation light sources. These systems, comprising both main and harmonic rf cavities, relax statistical collective effects but also introduce instabilities, such as Robinson and periodic transient beam loading (PTBL) instabilities. In this paper, we provide semi-analytical algorithms designed to predict and analyze these instabilities with improved accuracy and robustness. The algorithms leverage recent advancements in the field, offering a computationally efficient and accurate complement to multibunch tracking simulations. Using the SOLEIL II project as a case study, we demonstrate how these algorithms can optimize rf cavity parameters in high-dimensional parameter spaces, thereby maximizing the Touschek lifetime. An open-source Python package, ALBuMS (Algorithms for Longitudinal Multibunch Beam Stability), is provided as an accessible tool for double rf system stability analysis. I Introduction Double rf systems, including both main cavities (MCs) and harmonic cavities (HCs) , are becoming a de facto standard in storage-ring-based light sources. What was unusual in 2 nd -generation light sources, common in 3 rd -generation is now nearly mandatory with the advent of 4 th -generation synchrotron light sources. The advantages of such systems operated to flatten the rf potential have been demonstrated many times. The increased bunch length induced by the near flat potential increases the bunch volume density, which relaxes statistical collective effects [ 1 ] such as Touschek and intra-beam scattering (IBS) . This is especially important in current and future 4 th -generation synchrotron light sources in order to not spoil the ultra-low transverse emittances, which are reduced to hundreds or tens of \mathrm{pm}\text{\,}\mathrm{rad} . Other harmful consequences of collective effects, such as the additional energy spread induced by microwave instability, can also be significantly reduced or mitigated by the increased bunch length or the Landau damping generated by the increased synchrotron tune spread [ 2 ] . However, HCs come with their own set of longitudinal beam instabilities, which can prevent the achievement of large bunch lengthening factors. Double rf systems can drive “Robinson” instabilities [ 3 ] , generally defined as coupled-bunch instabilities (CBIs) of mode \ell=0 , for which all bunches oscillate in phase, driven by the fundamental mode of the cavities. Different kinds of Robinson instabilities exist, which can be driven by various mechanisms and can excite different azimuthal (i.e. synchrotron) modes m . The periodic transient beam loading (PTBL) instability, also called coupled-bunch mode \ell=1 instability, causes the beam to fall into a quasi-stable state, slowly drifting along the bunches with a rather long time period [ 4 , 5 ] . Instabilities usually observed in storage rings with a single rf system, such as CBI driven by cavity higher order modes (HOMs) [ 6 , 7 ] or equilibrium phase instability [ 8 ] , are still a concern for double rf systems. A very careful design of the double rf system is then needed to anticipate, characterize and possibly avoid such instabilities. The stability of double rf systems is often estimated using multibunch macro-particle tracking simulations where many effects (long-range wakes of MC and HC , broadband short-range wakes, non-uniform filling patterns, feedback loops, …) can be taken into account together [ 9 , 10 ] . Several open-source tracking codes are available [ 11 , 10 , 9 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] . However, such simulations are very computationally heavy and time-consuming, often requiring dedicated computing clusters and days of computation for a single parameter set. In addition, while tracking simulations are usually more accurate for real user cases, they often fail to provide a clear physical understanding, unless backed up by analytical models to explain the results. Simulations with high computational load can be a setback in the early phase of a project, when MC and HC parameters are still under specification. These constraints can lead to a reduction of the sampled parameter space and to the choice of sub-optimal solutions. In such cases, it is much more efficient to resort to theoretical and semi-analytical methods, which can be much faster than tracking simulation, to explore the parameter space. The first step in this direction is to compute the longitudinal equilibrium of the beam, by solving a system of coupled Haïssinski equations [ 15 ] . This step is crucial as it is a common basis needed for most theoretical analyses to estimate if the solution found might be stable or not. Furthermore, it is also a very good tool to have when doing tracking simulations as it gives a very fast estimate of what the simulation result is expected to be if the beam is stable. Therefore, it is not surprising that many recent developments have tackled this matter [ 4 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . The coupled Haïssinski equations can now be resolved with nonuniform filling patterns [ 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 ] , multiple passive or active cavities [ 21 ] and all the previous features with the addition of any arbitrary impedance [ 22 ] . A few open-source implementations of these methods are available [ 9 , 11 , 23 , 24 ] . Once the beam equilibrium is found, the usual next step is using it to evaluate a given instability. But to reach a similar level as in tracking simulation, i.e. to be able to replicate the driving mechanism of a large variety of instabilities, it is important to evaluate the overall stability of the Haïssinski solution with respect to different instability mechanisms. For example, this kind of algorithm was developed by Bosch et al. in a series of papers [ 25 , 3 , 6 ] . In this article, we propose a modernized algorithm based on the Bosch one. The main modifications make use of the advances which the field has seen since the Bosch study was conducted. The modifications allow for better convergence for the equilibrium calculation and improved instability predictions. Moreover, our approach considers an additional instability, the PTBL , and a different method to compute Robinson instabilities. The PTBL is considered in the algorithm using two different models. The limitations of the new algorithm are discussed, and this method is shown to be in good agreement when benchmarked against multibunch tracking simulation using mbtrack2 [ 10 ] . Then, using the context of the SOLEIL II project, we show how this method can be used to do large parameter scans and find optimal cavity parameters to maximize Touschek lifetime. Finally, we show how cavity and machine impedance short-range wakes can be partially included in the new algorithm. Their effects on the fast mode coupling instability are studied for the first time both using tracking and this semi-analytical method. In addition to this paper, a Python package named Algorithms for Longitudinal MultiBunch Beam Stability ( ALBuMS ) is provided as an open-source tool based on the semi-analytic methods explored here to study the longitudinal beam stability in double rf systems. Such a package can be helpful to guide cavity design, tracking simulations and experimental measurement

Read the complete text