Metallicity Dependence of Giant Planets around M Dwarfs Facilities: IRTF/SpeX [ 85 ]
Tianjun Gan, Christopher A. Theissen, Sharon X. Wang, Adam J. Burgasser, Shude Mao · 2024
Read Metallicity Dependence of Giant Planets around M Dwarfs Facilities: IRTF/SpeX [ 85 ] by Tianjun Gan, Christopher A. Theissen, Sharon X. Wang, Adam J. Burgasser, Shude Mao (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06137.txt.
Introduction
Tianjun Gan and co-authors test, in a 2024 study, whether giant planets favor metal-rich small stars. M dwarfs are the most common stars, but gas giants around them are rare. For larger stars, giants clearly prefer hosts rich in heavy elements. The team read the metal content of seven hundred forty-six field M dwarfs with one telescope and method, and set them against twenty-two M dwarfs known to host giant planets.
The planet hosts were clearly richer in metals, a gap too wide to be chance. Hot and warm Jupiters around these stars shared the same metal pattern, which hints at a shared origin. Hosts with one giant or many looked alike in metals, and planet mass did not track host richness. The team reads the pattern as a sign that the same planet-building channel works across star sizes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tianjun Gan, Christopher A. Theissen, Sharon X. Wang, Adam J. Burgasser, Shude Mao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 49 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06137
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Metallicity Dependence of Giant Planets around M Dwarfs Facilities: IRTF/SpeX [ 85 ] Tianjun Gan, Christopher A. Theissen, Sharon X. Wang, Adam J. Burgasser, Shude Mao Abstract We investigate the stellar metallicity ([Fe/H] and [M/H]) dependence of giant planets around M dwarfs by comparing the metallicity distribution of 746 field M dwarfs without known giant planets with a sample of 22 M dwarfs hosting confirmed giant planets. All metallicity measurements are homogeneously obtained through the same methodology based on the near-infrared spectra collected with a single instrument SpeX mounted on the NASA Infrared Telescope Facility. We find that 1) giant planets favor metal-rich M dwarfs at a 4-5 σ \sigma confidence level, depending on the band of spectra used to derive metallicity; 2) hot ( a / R ∗ ≤ 20 a/R_{\ast}\leq 20 ) and warm ( a / R ∗ > 20 a/R_{\ast}>20 ) Jupiters do not show a significant difference in the metallicity distribution. Our results suggest that giant planets around M and FGK stars, which are already known to prefer metal-rich hosts, probably have a similar formation channel. In particular, hot and warm Jupiters around M dwarfs may have the same origin as they have indistinguishable metallicity distributions. With the refined stellar and planetary parameters, we examine the stellar metallicities and the masses of giant planets where we find no significant correlation. M dwarfs with multiple giant planets or with a single giant planet have similar stellar metallicities. Mid-to-late type M stars hosting gas giants do not show an apparent preference to higher metallicities compared with those early-M dwarfs with gas giants and field M dwarfs. metal [ 63 ] , SpeXtool [ 21 ] , SPLAT [ 14 ] I Introduction Since the first detection of a hot Jupiter around a solar-type star outside the Solar System [ 68 ] , the formation channel of giant planets has been under debate over the last two decades. One of the leading hypotheses is core accretion [ 82 , 45 , 71 , e.g.,] , a bottom-up mechanism starting with a massive solid core that eventually grows into a giant planet through runaway gas accretion before the disk dissipates. Several pieces of observational evidence have been put forward in support of such a scenario. For example, metal-rich stars appear to be more likely to host cold giant planets found by radial velocity (RV) surveys [ 33 , 94 , 26 , 50 , 69 , 1 , e.g,] , the so-called giant planet-metallicity correlation. Under the core accretion paradigm, as the bulk metallicity is supposed to reflect the amount of materials available in the protoplanetary disk, one would naturally expect that gas giants form more easily around stars with higher metallicity. [ 61 ] went a step further and compared the stellar metallicity preference of hot and cool Jupiter systems, where the authors pointed out a lower frequency of hot Jupiters than cool ones at low metallicities. Later work from [ 80 ] looked into the metallicity dependence of planet occurrence rate with a sample of Kepler targets [ 9 ] and reported a steeper trend towards short-period gas giants. With a larger sample, [ 72 ] studied the average metallicity of stars with planets in two period bins split at 10 days. Although stars with short-period small planets ( M_{p}\leq 50\ M_{\oplus} ) tend to be more metal-rich than those hosting longer period ones, such a trend is not significant when moving to the giant plant branch, which further complicates the picture. More recently, [ 75 ] revisited the planet–metallicity correlation for hot Jupiters by comparing the metallicity distribution of hot Jupiter hosts and that of a field star population simulated using the Besançon Galaxy model [ 89 ] . They confirmed that hot Jupiters prefer metal-rich stars but the correlation coefficient is roughly comparable with gas giant planets with longer periods, indicating a similar formation origin. However, most aforementioned efforts were made to FGK stars, equivalent relevant studies on giant planets around M dwarfs are still lacking so far even though M stars are the dominant stellar population in the solar neighborhood [ 41 , 86 ] . This is not only because of the difficulty in determining the M dwarf stellar properties but also due to the low occurrence rate of both hot and cold Jupiters around M dwarfs in contrast to other types of stars. [ 31 ] found a frequency of 0.27\pm 0.09 % for hot Jupiters around early-type M dwarfs and the number slightly decreases to 0.137\pm 0.097 % around late-type M stars [ 12 , 77 ] . Regarding cold Jupiters, [ 50 ] estimated 0.03\pm 0.02 giant planets per M star within 2.5 AU (see also Sabotta et al. 93 ). Nevertheless, a few such high-mass-ratio systems [ 70 , 32 , 39 , 13 , 99 , 43 , e.g.,] were found to stretch the core accretion theory and may favor the gravitational instability model [ 10 ] instead, making them particularly crucial to understand the giant planet formation. Plenty of techniques such as broadband photometry-based empirical relations [ 100 , 63 , 64 , 65 , 73 , 74 , e.g.,] and detailed spectroscopic analysis [ 104 , 67 , 79 , 6 , 47 , e.g.,] have been developed to determine the stellar parameters of M dwarfs, allowing for better characterizations for M dwarf planetary systems [ 34 ] . Based on photometric calibrations, early work from [ 48 ] found that M dwarfs with planets tend to have metallicities in excess of field M stars in the solar neighborhood. [ 90 ] later reported that M dwarfs hosting Jovian-like planets detected by RV surveys have higher metallicities than those with Neptune- or Earth-size planets but the sample size is limited. Using a sample of three M dwarfs with RV-detected giant planets, [ 28 ] found that they are not significantly more metal-rich than the average parent sample and the power-law index relating planet occurrence rate to stellar metallicity is consistent with Sun-like star counterparts within uncertainties. In terms of hot Jupiters, the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite [ 87 , TESS;] has been enlarging the number, where most of them were detected around high-metallicity M stars [ 30 , 54 , 53 , 36 , e.g.,] . In addition, [ 32 ] claimed a possible trend that hot Jupiters prefer more metal-rich M stars than warm Jupiters based on the literature metallicity measurements but the heterogeneous instruments and methodologies result in systematic biases, preventing a firm conclusion. In this manuscript, we compare the metallicity ([Fe/H] and [M/H]) distributions of 22 M dwarfs hosting confirmed giant planets (defined as planets with mass 0.2\ M_{\rm Jup}\leq M_{p}<13.6\ M_{\rm Jup} ) with a field M dwarf sample and investigate the difference between the hot and warm Jupiter groups. All metallicities are homogeneously measured using the near-infrared low-resolution spectra from a single instrument SpeX [ 85 ] mounted on the 3.2-m NASA Infrared Telescope Facility (IRTF), through the same method. Compared with previous works [ 48 , 90 , 29 ] , our giant planet sample is about four times larger and includes several short-period gas giants detected by the TESS