Revisiting Stellar Systems J0946 and V723 Monocerotis: A Study of Mass Gap Black Hole Candidates
Ajla Trumic 1 , Aneya Sobalkar 2 , Efe Tandırlı 3 , Nishka Yadav 4 , Isabelle Culinco 5 , Shriya Nedumaran 6 , Kaylee Liu 7 , Phiet Tran 8 , Aadhya Pai 9 , Robert Downing 10 1 University of California, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA 2 California High School, San Ramon, CA, 94583, USA 3 Eindhoven Technical · 2024
Read Revisiting Stellar Systems J0946 and V723 Monocerotis: A Study of Mass Gap Black Hole Candidates by Ajla Trumic 1 , Aneya Sobalkar 2 , Efe Tandırlı 3 , Nishka Yadav 4 , Isabelle Culinco 5 , Shriya Nedumaran 6 , Kaylee Liu 7 , Phiet Tran 8 , Aadhya Pai 9 , Robert Downing 10 1 University of California, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA 2 California High School, San Ramon, CA, 94583, USA 3 Eindhoven Technical (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-06130.txt.
Introduction
Ajla Trumic and co-authors revisit two star systems once tipped to hold black holes in the puzzling mass gap. One system, J0946, gained a black hole claim in 2023, while V723 Monocerotis lost a similar claim after a misreading. The team re-derived the stars' traits with Bayesian modeling tools and two software packages.
For J0946 they found a steeper orbital tilt and a companion mass of just under three suns, below the earlier estimate. For V723 Mon, their tilt and a mass near two and a half suns matched the newest published values. They also ran the method on stars from two big catalogs. Neither catalog showed strong signs of hidden stellar-mass black holes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ajla Trumic 1 , Aneya Sobalkar 2 , Efe Tandırlı 3 , Nishka Yadav 4 , Isabelle Culinco 5 , Shriya Nedumaran 6 , Kaylee Liu 7 , Phiet Tran 8 , Aadhya Pai 9 , Robert Downing 10 1 University of California, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA 2 California High School, San Ramon, CA, 94583, USA 3 Eindhoven Technical |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-06130
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Revisiting Stellar Systems J0946 and V723 Monocerotis: A Study of Mass Gap Black Hole Candidates Ajla Trumic 1 , Aneya Sobalkar 2 , Efe Tandırlı 3 , Nishka Yadav 4 , Isabelle Culinco 5 , Shriya Nedumaran 6 , Kaylee Liu 7 , Phiet Tran 8 , Aadhya Pai 9 , Robert Downing 10 1 University of California, Berkeley, CA, 94720, USA 2 California High School, San Ramon, CA, 94583, USA 3 Eindhoven Technical University, Eindhoven, North Brabant, 5612, Netherlands 4 Monta Vista High School, Cupertino, CA, 95014, USA 5 Campolindo High School, Moraga, CA, 94556, USA 6 Leigh High School, San Jose, CA, 95124, USA 7 Mission San Jose High School, Fremont, CA, 94539, USA 8 Santa Clara High School, Santa Clara, CA, 95051, USA 9 Amador Valley High School, Pleasanton, CA, 94566, USA 10 Aspiring Scholars Directed Research Program, Fremont, CA, 94539, USA Abstract In 2023, Rowan et al. 8 reported the discovery of a black hole (BH) companion to J0946, following the misidentification of V723 Mon by Jayasinghe et al. 5 as containing a “mass-gap” BH. This article reproduced Rowan and Jayasinghe’s results on these systems by estimating stellar parameters via Markov Chain Monte Carlo solvers. We implemented Bayesian statistical modeling through software ExoFit 3 and PHysics of the Eclipsing Binaries (PHOEBE) 7 . For J0946, we found a higher inclination ( i ≈ 72 ∘ i\approx 72^{\circ} ) and a companion mass of 2.78 M ⊙ M_{\odot} , lower than what Rowan estimated. V723 Mon’s results aligned with recent estimates by El Badry et al. 4 , yielding an inclination of i ≈ 74 ∘ i\approx 74^{\circ} and a mass of 2.56 M ⊙ M_{\odot} . We tested this method on stars from Gaia DR2 11, 12 and NASA Exoplanet Archive, agreeing with previous findings that these datasets do not exhibit strong indications of stellar-mass black hole systems. 10 Keywords — mass gap, black holes, PHOEBE, ExoFit, Markov Chain Monte Carlo 1 Introduction The discovery of neutron stars and black holes (BHs) in the Milky Way galaxy is essential to understanding the end states of stellar evolution. Current mass measurements of neutron stars and black holes are predominantly derived from X-ray detection methodology 2 . However, only a small percentage of these compact objects are detectable through X-ray methodologies, so these interacting systems are not representative of the total population. To gain a more accurate understanding of how these massive objects form, a more complete census is required. Research into non-interacting binary systems has been crucial in identifying massive companions in the Milky Way galaxy that are indetectable directly by their electromagnetic signatures. The characterization of galactic BH binaries would help bridge the mass gap, defined by the ambiguity between the most massive neutron stars and the least massive black holes in the range of 3-5 M_{\odot} 5 . One possible method of detection is through analyzing stellar radius measurements. Assuming that instrumentation improves over time, it should hold true that stellar radius error measurements will decrease, asymptotically approaching zero. However, in the case of an unseen massive companion in orbit about a common barycenter with the star, the companion’s gravitational attraction will cause tidal distortions that affect the star’s outer envelope. The constant stretching and contraction of the stellar envelope will affect the stellar radius error measurements. These cases, we propose, would present themselves as outliers in radius error measurements and could be filtered into an initial group of candidates. Measurements pertaining to stellar radius were gathered from the 2022 Planetary Systems dataset from the NASA Exoplanet Archive. An additional method of detection is proposed using radial velocity measurements. As the star and the unseen massive companion orbit their barycenter, the star will experience statistically significant deviations in its observed radial velocity and corresponding error measurements due to the influence of the companion. This method relies on the concept that the radial velocity data may reflect that the star is moving in an orbit, suggesting that there may be an unseen companion causing this motion. Gaia astrometry surveys from the European Space Agency provide data pertaining to radial velocity. We, specifically, make use of Gaia Data Release 2 (Gaia DR2) 11, 12 . We reproduced the results from D. M. Rowan et al. and Jayasinghe et al. on BH candidate J0946 and imposter V723 Mon, respectively. We test their datasets on the Markov Chain Monte Carlo modeling software, ExoFit, to extract values for period, eccentricity, and radial velocity semi-amplitude. We go on to extract the inclination values through reproducing Bayesian statistical modeling methods from D. M. Rowan et al. through an MCMC built in the PHysics of Eclipsing Binaries (PHOEBE) software. These methods were applied to binary systems identified in our study from the NASA and Gaia datasets. The mass of the unseen companion was then calculated using the binary mass function. The purpose of this study is to evaluate Rowan and Jayasinghe’s technique on single-lined spectroscopic binaries (SB1s) that could contain black holes that fit in the mass gap range, misidentified BHs, and candidates from our research. 2 Methodology 2.1 Filtering To identify any outliers in stellar radius from the NASA Archive, we analyzed parameters: stellar radius ( st_rad ), stellar radius error 1 ( st_raderr1 ), and stellar radius error 2 ( st_raderr2 ). Null values were replaced with the arithmetic mean of the respective attributes. We identified those stellar bodies whose parameters significantly deviate from the mean using the pandas and numpy libraries. If at least 2 of the 3 parameters described above were found to be statistical outliers, they were sorted into a separate data frame for future analysis. Through leveraging statistical significance and standard deviation thresholds, we identified our first list of potential black holes. Because Gaia does not include stellar radius measurements, the radial velocity process was applied to Gaia Data Release 2 (Gaia DR2). This dataset contains radial velocity ( radial_velocity ) and radial velocity error ( radial_velocity_error ) attributes. Null values were replaced with arithmetic means. We filtered stars that showed significant statistical deviations from their mean in radial velocity through use of the numpy and pandas Python libraries. Anomalous stellar systems were identified and sorted into their own dataset. To further filter the candidate lists, the datasets produced from the radial velocity and stellar radius methods were merged together into a single data frame using the pandas library. We used right ascension and declination as the shared attribute. The associated error bar was a reference to merge the two datasets. After completion of this process, we were left with a dataset that contained a total of 127 entries and 19 distinct stellar systems. We then employed the binary mass function to solve for the computed mass of our unseen companion. Eq. 1: Binary Mass Function f(M)=\frac{(M_{2}\sin i)^{3}}{(M_{1}+M_{2})^{2}}=\frac{P_{\text{orb}}K^{3}(1-e^{2})^{3/2}}{2\pi G} (1) P_{\text{orb}} is the orbital period, e is eccentricity, and K is radial velocity semi-amplitude. M_{1} and M_{2} are the masses of the star and the unseen companion, respectively. To estimate the parameters P orb , K, and e, we analyzed various radial velocity time series from a variety of publicly available spectroscopic and photometric datasets. 3 Data Sources and Processing The radial velocity time series was gathered