Run 3 performance and advances in heavy-flavor jet tagging in CMS
* · 2024
Read Run 3 performance and advances in heavy-flavor jet tagging in CMS by * (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05863.txt.
Introduction
Telling a jet of heavy-quark spray from a jet of light quarks is a daily necessity at the Large Hadron Collider. Uttiya Sarkar reports how well the CMS experiment does it in the collider's current Run 3, in a 2024 paper.
The tags feed studies of the top quark and the Higgs boson and searches for new physics. Modern taggers are deep neural networks, graph and transformer designs, trained to spot the displaced decay signatures of charm and bottom quarks. Their accuracy has reached levels earlier methods could not touch. New calibration methods, built on collision samples enriched in each flavor, let physicists measure the tagging performance on real data rather than trusting simulation. Sarkar reviews the algorithms' advances and the early Run 3 performance numbers.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | * |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05863
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Run 3 performance and advances in heavy-flavor jet tagging in CMS * Abstract Identification of hadronic jets originating from heavy-flavor quarks is extremely important to several physics analyses in High Energy Physics, such as studies of the properties of the top quark and the Higgs boson, and searches for new physics. Recent algorithms used in the CMS experiment were developed using state-of-the-art machine-learning techniques to distinguish jets emerging from the decay of heavy flavour (charm and bottom) quarks from those arising from light-flavor (udsg) ones. Increasingly complex deep neural network architectures, such as graphs and transformers, have helped achieve unprecedented accuracies in jet tagging. New advances in tagging algorithms, along with new calibration methods using flavour-enriched selections of proton-proton collision events, allow us to estimate flavour tagging performances with the CMS detector during early Run 3 of the LHC. [a]Uttiya Sarkar on behalf of the CMS collaboration 1 Introduction Heavy flavour tagging is of utmost importance in the CMS experiment [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) for identifying jets originating from heavy quarks, particularly bottom (b) and charm (c) quarks. This method plays a pivotal role in various physics analyses, including those focused on the Standard Model (SM), top quark physics, Higgs boson production, and Beyond the Standard Model (BSM) searches, such as Supersymmetry (SUSY) processes. To differentiate heavy-flavor jets from light-flavor quark or gluon jets, standard methods make use of detector inputs from reconstructed charged particle tracks and information about secondary vertices reconstructed within jets. The jet-related data is incorporated into advanced machine-learning techniques. Although there is a rapid improvement in tagging methods, it is essential to ensure the consistency between data and simulations since the detector conditions change over time and simulations are often imperfect. This proceeding briefly discusses about the various tagging strategies that are used in CMS focusing on the most recently developed tagging algorithm, namely UnifiedParticleTransformer (UParT) [ 4 ] . It then presents a comparison of data and simulation and derived scale factors using the proton-proton collision data collected by the CMS detector at \sqrt{s} =13.6 TeV during 2022-2023 data-taking periods [ 5 ] . Then it shows the performance and validation results for large-radius jets. Finally, it concludes by discussing the two modern computing frameworks used for training and commissioning purposes. 2 Heavy-flavor tagging in CMS Heavy-flavor jet tagging depends on variables related to the characteristics of heavy-flavor hadrons within jets, such as the presence of secondary vertices, higher track multiplicities, and more tracks with positively signed impact parameters. The historical evolution of flavor taggers in the CMS experiment reflects significant advancements in machine learning techniques and algorithms over the past decade. Starting with the combined secondary vertex (CSV) [ 6 ] method, which relied on a likelihood ratio during Run 1, CMS transitioned to more sophisticated models, such as CSVv2 (Multi-Layer-Percrepton) during early Run 2. By 2017, CMS introduced DeepCSV [ 7 ] , utilizing deep neural networks (DNN), followed by DeepJet [ 8 ] in late Run 2, which combined convolutional neural networks (CNN) and recurrent neural networks (RNN) for enhanced performance. The introduction of ParticleNet [ 9 ] in early Run 3 further improved tagging capabilities by treating particles as unordered clouds, using the dynamic graph convolutional neural network (DGCNN) architecture. The latest advancements in Run 3, such as RobustParticleTransformer (RobustParT) [ 10 , 11 ] and UParT [ 4 ] , leverage transformer-based architectures — a multi-head attention mechanism with pairwise interaction features between all input jet constituents and secondary vertices [ 12 ] . These models also incorporate input feature distortions (adversarial attacks) to enhance robustness. Overall, the evolution of these algorithms has led to substantial improvements in tagging efficiency, as demonstrated in figure 1 showing reduced light-flavour mistagging rates at different b-jet tagging efficiencies (left) and improved light or c-jet rejection at a fixed b-jet tagging efficiency of 70% (right). The last generation models not only tag b and c jets but are also capable of tagging strange (s) and hadronic \tau ( \tau_{h} ) jets. To evaluate the performance of b-jets and c-jets, several discriminators—such as BvsAll, BvsL, CvL, and CvB—are defined based on the probability of identifying different jet types. These transformations allow discriminating specifically between bottom (b), charm (c), strange (s), light (ud), and gluon jets. The definitions are: BvsAll = prob(b) / [1-prob(b)], BvsL = prob(b) / [prob(b) + prob(udsg)], CvsL = prob(c) / [prob(c) + prob(udsg)], and CvsB = prob(c) / [prob(c) + prob(b)] For s and \tau_{h} tagging, a broader classification is used, defined as: svsX = [prob(s)] / [prob(s) + prob(X)] \tau_{h} vsX = [prob( \tau_{h} )] / [prob( \tau_{h} ) + prob(X)] where X is any other jet type. Figure 1: Evolution of the b-tagging performance for jet flavor identification algorithms used in CMS from Run 1 to Run 3. Left plot shows the increase in tagging performance follows the progression in machine learning whereas the right plot shows that the light- (udsg, yellow bars) and c-jet (red bars) rejection for a fixed b-jet identification efficiency of 70\% for taggers from Run 1 to Run 3. 3 UParT UParT is based on the ParticleTransformer architecture [ 12 ] specifically designed for AK4 jets (anti- k_{T} jets with a cone radius of 0.4). It integrates heavy-flavor identification with flavor-aware jet energy regression and jet energy resolution estimation in a comprehensive manner. The model introduces pairwise interaction features between jet constituents and secondary vertices, enhancing its capability to capture complex internal jet relationships. A key advancement in UParT is the use of a novel Adversarial Training approach. This enables the model to learn from input feature distortions, significantly improving its robustness against mismodeling in simulations. Furthermore, UParT preserves feature importance mapping through adversarial attack gradients, highlighting critical features for jet classification, ensuring both high performance and robustness in heavy-flavor tagging. The left plot in figure 2 shows the c/udsg jet misidentification rate vs. the b-jet tagging efficiency for jets with \mathrm{p_{T}}>30 GeV and |{\eta}|<2.5 taken from a simulated ttbar sample. Whereas, the right plot in figure 2 shows the b/udsg jet misidentification efficiency versus the c-jet tagging efficiency for different tagging algorithms in the same jet selection. A consistent improvement in the tagging performance is observed with UParT being the most performing model so far in c-jet identification. Additionally, UParT extends its capabilities by introducing an s-jet classifier, making it the first attempt to identify jets originating from s-quarks within the CMS experiment. The left plot in figure 3 shows the s-jet tagging efficiency against the misidentification rate of other jets. It can already achieve 20% tagging efficiency for a mididentification probability of 10^{-3} . In addition, UParT extends its capabilities to include hadronic tau classification, as demonstrated in the right plot of figure 3 , further enhancing its versatility across a wide range of particle tagging tasks. Figure 2: Left: ROC curves of post-training reweighted discriminators for b-tagging. Both BvsL and BvsC shows the best rejection against their specific flavor but fail to achieve a good rejection for the other. The different weighted BvsAll show a trade-off for BvsC and BvsL showing a significant improvement in BvsL for a limited impact on BvsC