Kinematic evidence of magnetospheric accretion for Herbig Ae stars with JWST NIRSpec
Ciarán Rogers, Bernhard Brandl, Guido de Marchi · 2024
Read Kinematic evidence of magnetospheric accretion for Herbig Ae stars with JWST NIRSpec by Ciarán Rogers, Bernhard Brandl, Guido de Marchi (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05668.txt.
Introduction
Ciarán Rogers, Bernhard Brandl, and Guido de Marchi study how young stars pull in gas in a 2024 paper. Hydrogen emission lines have long been used to weigh this inflow, yet the lines' physical source stayed unclear. Two rival mechanisms, magnetic funnels and magnetized winds, predict different line shapes.
New spectra from the James Webb telescope covered five Herbig Ae stars in a massive star-forming region. Fitting the stars' light set their sizes and temperatures. Line widths and depths across three hydrogen series were then compared with each mechanism's forecast. The motion evidence favors the magnetic funnel picture, sharpening a tool used across star formation research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ciarán Rogers, Bernhard Brandl, Guido de Marchi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 82 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05668
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Kinematic evidence of magnetospheric accretion for Herbig Ae stars with JWST NIRSpec Ciarán Rogers, Bernhard Brandl, Guido de Marchi Abstract Context. Hydrogen emission lines have been used to estimate the mass accretion rate of pre-main-sequence stars for over 25 25 years. Despite the clear correlation between the accretion luminosity of a star and hydrogen line luminosities, the physical origin of these lines is still unclear. Magnetospheric accretion (MA) and magneto-centrifugal winds are the two most often invoked mechanisms. Aims. Using a combination of HST photometry and new JWST NIRSpec spectra in the range 1.66 − 3.2 μ m 1.66-3.2\;\mu m , we analysed the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) and emission line spectra of five sources in order to determine their underlying photospheric properties and attempt to reveal the physical origin of their hydrogen emission lines. These sources reside in NGC 3603, a Galactic massive star forming region. Methods. We performed fits of the SEDs of the five sources employing a Markov chain Monte Carlo exploration to estimate T e f f T_{eff} , R ∗ R_{*} , M ∗ M_{*} , and A ( V ) A(V) for each source. We performed a kinematic analysis across three spectral series of hydrogen lines (Paschen, Brackett, and Pfund), totalling ≥ 15 \geq 15 lines per source. We studied the full width at half maximum (FWHM) and optical depth of the spectrally resolved lines in order to constrain the emission origin. We calculated the expected velocities from MA as well as gas in Keplerian orbit for our sources. Results. All five sources have SEDs consistent with young intermediate-mass stars. We classified three of these sources as Herbig Ae type stars based on their T e f f T_{eff} . Their hydrogen lines show broad profiles with FWHMs ≥ 200 \geq 200 km s -1 . Hydrogen lines with high upper energy levels n u p n_{up} tend to be significantly broader than lines with a lower n u p n_{up} . The optical depth of the emission lines is also highest for the high-velocity component of each line, and it becomes optically thin in the low-velocity component. Three sources show FWHMs that are too broad to originate from Keplerian rotation, but they are consistent with MA. The remaining two sources have FWHMs that are consistent with both MA and Keplerian rotation. Conclusions. The highest excitation lines have the largest FWHM for a given series. The highest-velocity component of the lines is also the most optically thick. This is consistent with emission from MA or a Keplerian disc, but it cannot be explained as originating in a magneto-centrifugal wind. Based on the expected velocities from MA and a Keplerian disc, we favour MA for three of the five sources. We cannot rule out Keplerian disc emission for the remaining two sources. In the future, this approach can be applied to more statistically significant samples of Herbig AeBe spectra, including existing archival observations. 1 Introduction Protoplanetary discs around young stars are the site of numerous highly studied astronomical phenomena, including magnetospheric accretion and accelerating disc winds powered by magneto-centrifugal forces, and as the name suggests, they are the formation sites of planets. Understanding the evolution of protoplanetary discs is crucial in both the context of star formation and planet formation. A fundamental push and pull that regulates the lifetime of protoplanetary discs is the balance between mass-loss through winds and mass accretion onto the central star. Accretion rates of stars were originally measured by fitting shock models to the near-ultraviolet (NUV) spectra of young low-mass stars, known as Classical T Tauri Stars (CTTSs) ( Gullbring et al. 1998 ) . The physical picture assumed here is centred around a magnetically driven accretion paradigm in which the star’s strong magnetic field pushes against and truncates the protoplanetary disc out to a few stellar radii ( Hartmann et al. 2016 , e.g.) . Material at the disc’s surface is channelled along magnetic field lines from the disc to the central star. During its near free-fall towards the star, the supersonic material shocks the stellar surface and releases its gravitational potential energy as radiation. Initially this is primarily in the form of X-rays, which are quickly absorbed by the stellar surface and re-radiated at longer wavelengths in the NUV and blue-optical. This additional source of NUV light on top of the intrinsic photospheric contribution can be observed and measured, and from this so-called accretion luminosity, the mass accretion rate can be determined. This is the only direct method of measuring the accretion luminosity, and while it unambiguously probes the accretion shock, the reliance on NUV wavelengths makes this approach impractical for sources that are deeply embedded or located at great distances due to high levels of extinction. An invaluable calibration was discovered by Muzerolle et al. (1998b) , who showed that the line luminosity of the relatively bright near-infrared (NIR) hydrogen line Br_{7} scales tightly with the accretion luminosity for a sample of 19 CTTSs. With extinction more than ten times lower in the NIR compared to the NUV and without the need for shock modelling, this line luminosity calibration opened the floodgates for the efficient and straightforward estimate of accretion rates for large samples of sources. These calibrations have since been updated and expanded, most notably by Herczeg & Hillenbrand (2008) ; Alcalá et al. (2014) ; Alcalá et al. (2017) . We also showed in an earlier work that these calibrations could be extended towards the brightest NIR line - Pa_{\alpha} ( Rogers et al. 2024b ) , thus making estimating the accretion rate highly accessible in the era of JWST for extremely distant and embedded sources. All of this work relies on the assumption that accretion is driven magnetically. First theorised by Koenigl (1991) and unambiguously confirmed observationally by Bouvier et al. (2007) for CTTSs, the MA paradigm for Herbig AeBe stars has not reached the same consensus. Unlike CTTSs (spectral types M through G), stars of spectral type A and earlier are not expected to possess a convective envelope, which is thought to be the source of the strong and ordered magnetic fields present around a CTTS ( Kageyama & Sato 1997 ; Johns-Krull 2007 , e.g.) . Despite lingering questions over their origin, magnetic fields have been measured towards dozens of Herbig AeBe stars, albeit with significantly lower field strengths compared to CTTSs ( Mendigutía 2020 ) . Other spectroscopic signatures of infalling matter have also been seen towards Herbig AeBe stars, such as red-shifted absorption profiles in He I and H I lines ( Cauley & Johns-Krull 2015 ) , though they are less prevalent compared to the occurrence rate in CTTSs. In general, magnetospheres, if present, are expected to be smaller in Herbig Ae stars compared to CTTSs and may be entirely absent for early Be stars ( Wichittanakom et al. 2020 ; Vioque et al. 2022 ) . Disc winds are ubiquitous around young stars. However, as with accretion, less is known about winds from Herbig AeBe stars compared to CTTSs. Powerful collimated jets and outflows have been spatially resolved for many nearby sources, with large-scale jets being the defining physical