Modern Hopfield Networks Require Chain-of-Thought to Solve ๐–ญ๐–ข 1 \mathsf{NC}^{1} -Hard Problems

Yang Cao and Xiaoyu Li and Yuanpeng Li and Yingyu Liang and Zhenmei Shi and Zhao Song ยท 2024

Read Modern Hopfield Networks Require Chain-of-Thought to Solve ๐–ญ๐–ข 1 \mathsf{NC}^{1} -Hard Problems by Yang Cao and Xiaoyu Li and Yuanpeng Li and Yingyu Liang and Zhenmei Shi and Zhao Song (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05562.txt.

Introduction

Yang Cao and co-authors draw a hard line around what modern Hopfield networks can compute on their own, in a paper from 2024. These networks now serve inside deep learning as memory and attention stand ins. The team measured their power with circuit complexity tools.

Bounded versions of the networks fall inside a low parallel complexity class. On standard assumptions, that bars them from problems like graph connectivity and tree matching that need serial steps. The same limits cover a kernel based variant. Adding step by step reasoning text breaks the barrier, letting the networks solve a classic serial word problem. The authors map exactly where the added reasoning power begins.

Catalog record

CREATORYang Cao and Xiaoyu Li and Yuanpeng Li and Yingyu Liang and Zhenmei Shi and Zhao Song
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE55 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05562

Browse the full library ยท About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modern Hopfield Networks Require Chain-of-Thought to Solve ๐–ญ๐–ข 1 \mathsf{NC}^{1} -Hard Problems Yang Cao and Xiaoyu Li and Yuanpeng Li and Yingyu Liang and Zhenmei Shi and Zhao Song Abstract Modern Hopfield Networks (MHNs) have emerged as powerful components in deep learning, serving as effective replacements for pooling layers, LSTMs, and attention mechanisms. While recent advancements have significantly improved their storage capacity and retrieval efficiency, their fundamental theoretical boundaries remain underexplored. In this paper, we rigorously characterize the expressive power of MHNs through the lens of circuit complexity theory. We prove that poly โก ( n ) \mathrm{poly}(n) -precision MHNs with constant depth and linear hidden dimension fall within the ๐–ฃ๐–ซ๐–ฎ๐–ฆ๐–ณ๐–จ๐–ฌ๐–ค \mathsf{DLOGTIME} -uniform ๐–ณ๐–ข 0 \mathsf{TC}^{0} complexity class. Consequently, assuming ๐–ณ๐–ข 0 โ‰  ๐–ญ๐–ข 1 \mathsf{TC}^{0}\neq\mathsf{NC}^{1} , we demonstrate that these architectures are incapable of solving ๐–ญ๐–ข 1 \mathsf{NC}^{1} -hard problems, such as undirected graph connectivity and tree isomorphism. We further extend these impossibility results to Kernelized Hopfield Networks. However, we show that these limitations are not absolute: we prove that equipping MHNs with a Chain-of-Thought (CoT) mechanism enables them to transcend the ๐–ณ๐–ข 0 \mathsf{TC}^{0} barrier, allowing them to solve inherently serial problems like the word problem for the permutation group S 5 S_{5} . Collectively, our results delineate a fine-grained boundary between the capabilities of standard MHNs and those augmented with reasoning steps. 1 Introduction Hopfield networks [ 20 ] , initially introduced as associative memories capable of storing and retrieving patterns, have undergone significant advancements in recent years. These developments led to the emergence of Modern Hopfield Networks [ 40 ] . Modern Hopfield Networks (MHNs) address the limitations of their predecessors, particularly in terms of storage capacity, retrieval speed, and error rates. An important feature of MHNs is their ability to function as specialized components within deep networks, integrating memory capabilities and supporting diverse functionalities. For instance, MHNs can replace conventional layers such as pooling layers, permutation-equivariant layers [ 14 , 41 ] , GRU [ 10 ] , LSTM [ 19 , 22 ] , and attention mechanisms [ 46 , 4 ] . Their energy-based formulation allows for rapid and efficient pattern retrieval, making them a compelling alternative to traditional memory structures in deep learning. Understanding Modern Hopfield Networksโ€™ computational capabilities and limitations is critical for their effective application. Specifically, it is crucial to explore the computational operations these networks can implement and the complexity of the problems they can solve collectively. These investigations are vital not only for theoretical insights but also for guiding the development of more efficient and powerful models. While prior research has primarily focused on the dynamics and capacity of Modern Hopfield Networks [ 18 , 47 ] , their expressiveness from a circuit complexity perspective remains underexplored. This gap raises an important question: What are the fundamental limits of Modern Hopfield Networks in terms of circuit complexity? To address these questions, we turn to the framework of circuit complexity theory, which provides a robust method for analyzing the computational resources required to perform specific tasks. By mapping Modern Hopfield Networks to computational circuits, we can rigorously assess their capabilities and establish upper and lower bounds on the classes of problems they can solve. In this work, we present a comprehensive theoretical investigation into the circuit complexity bounds of MHNs. Our approach involves a detailed analysis of the MHN architecture and the computational complexity of its constituent components, such as the Hopfield layer. Consequently, we demonstrate that these models can be efficiently simulated by uniform \mathsf{TC}^{0} circuits. Our main contributions can be summarized as follows: โ€ข We establish that any \mathrm{poly}(n) -precision Modern Hopfield Network or Kernelized Hopfield Network with constant depth and O(n) hidden dimension resides within the \mathsf{DLOGTIME} -uniform \mathsf{TC}^{0} complexity class (Theorems 4.8 and 5.4 ). โ€ข We demonstrate that, assuming \mathsf{TC}^{0}\neq\mathsf{NC}^{1} , \mathrm{poly}(n) -precision Modern or Kernelized Hopfield Networks with constant layers and O(n) hidden dimension are fundamentally incapable of solving \mathsf{NC}^{1} -hard problems. We specifically identify undirected graph connectivity and tree isomorphism as problems beyond the reach of these architectures (Theorems 6.9 , 6.10 , 6.11 and 6.12 ). โ€ข We prove that these computational limitations are not absolute and can be overcome by the Chain-of-Thought (CoT) mechanism. Specifically, we show that a Modern Hopfield Network with n -step CoT can solve the word problem for the permutation group S_{5} (an \mathsf{NC}^{1} -complete problem), a task that is provably impossible for standard constant-depth MHNs (Theorem 7.4 ). Roadmap. In Section 2 , we provide an overview of the related works. In Section 3 , we introduce the notations and definitions needed for Modern Hopfield Networks. In Section 4 , we analyze the circuit complexity for Modern Hopfield Networks. In Section 5 , we focus on the circuit complexity results of Kernelized Hopfield Networks. In Section 6 , we discuss the hardness results of the Modern Hopfield Networks. In Section 7 , we provide our the results for Modern Hopfield Networks with Chain-of-Thought mechanism. Finally, in Section 8 , we summarize our theoretical results in the conclusion. 2 Related Works In this section, we introduce the related works of the Hopfield models and the complexity of Transformers. Theory of Modern Hopfield Networks The Hopfield network, introduced by John Hopfield [ 20 , 21 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] , was originally conceived as a model for content-addressable memory. This network operates by encoding patterns through the connections between neurons, enabling associative recall. By fixing specific inputs and allowing the network to evolve dynamically, it minimizes an energy function to retrieve stored patterns. A notable characteristic of Hopfield networks is the overlapping nature of different patterns, where many patterns share common neurons. Recent advancements in Modern Hopfield Networks have showcased both theoretical significance and practical applications. These models have proven instrumental in offering insights into transformer attention mechanisms and the architecture of Transformers. For instance, [ 24 , 47 ] introduced a comprehensive framework for analyzing and deriving modern Hopfield models, employing entropic regularizers to unify diverse variants. This framework encompasses sparse and generalized sparse models and includes the standard modern Hopfield network [ 40 ] as a particular instance. Moreover, contemporary research efforts [ 24 , 48 , 18 , 15 , 16 , 23 ] continue to explore innovative directions for improving the efficiency and scalability of Hopfield-based models. These studies underline the transformative potential of Hopfield-driven methodologies in shaping future designs, highlighting their adaptability to complex computational tasks and their integration into broader machine learning paradigms. Modern Hopfield Networks and Applications in Deep Learning. Classical Hopfield networks [ 20 , 21 , 28 , 29 , 30 ] have long been recognized for their ability to emulate human brain associative memory, primarily focusing on the storage and retrieval of memory patterns. Originally limited by linear memory capacity [ 28 ] , these networks now achieve exponential storage capabilities [ 11 ] and kernelized [ 47 ] , allowing for efficient handling of vast memory patterns. Architectural innovations [ 17 , 43 , 12 ] have integrated Hopfield networks into models like Transformers, serving as advanced attention mechanisms [ 46 ] . Their biological plausibility [ 31 , 30 ] has been

Read the complete text