Isochronous and period-doubling diagrams for symplectic maps of the plane

T. Zolkin, S. Nagaitsev, I. Morozov, S. Kladov, Y-K. Kim · 2024

Read Isochronous and period-doubling diagrams for symplectic maps of the plane by T. Zolkin, S. Nagaitsev, I. Morozov, S. Kladov, Y-K. Kim (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05541.txt.

Introduction

Tim Zolkin and co-authors chart the stability landscape of a classic chaotic map, in this 2024 paper. Area-preserving maps of the plane model how nonlinear systems behave, and the quadratic Hénon map is the test case. Earlier pictures flattened the two-dimensional space into one, losing key features. The team revisits symmetry ideas going back to Birkhoff to rebuild the picture properly.

They add a period-doubling diagram beside the classic equal-period diagram. Together the charts show how the fixed point splits and which families of symmetric orbits appear. Modern chaos gauges separate tidy motion from chaos and spot twistless orbits. The bounded-motion region gets both a qualitative and quantitative account. The method extends to other maps, including ones with several symmetries.

Catalog record

CREATORT. Zolkin, S. Nagaitsev, I. Morozov, S. Kladov, Y-K. Kim
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE99 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05541

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Isochronous and period-doubling diagrams for symplectic maps of the plane T. Zolkin, S. Nagaitsev, I. Morozov, S. Kladov, Y-K. Kim Abstract Symplectic mappings of the plane serve as key models for exploring the fundamental nature of complex behavior in nonlinear systems. Central to this exploration is the effective visualization of stability regimes, which enables the interpretation of how systems evolve under varying conditions. While the area-preserving quadratic Hénon map has received significant theoretical attention, a comprehensive description of its mixed parameter-space dynamics remain lacking. This limitation arises from early attempts to reduce the full two-dimensional phase space to a one-dimensional projection, a simplification that resulted in the loss of important dynamical features. Consequently, there is a clear need for a more thorough understanding of the underlying qualitative aspects. This paper aims to address this gap by revisiting the foundational concepts of reversibility and associated symmetries, first explored in the early works of G.D. Birkhoff. We extend the original framework proposed by Hénon by adding a period-doubling diagram to his isochronous diagram, which allows to represents the system’s bifurcations and the groups of symmetric periodic orbits that emerge in typical bifurcations of the fixed point. A qualitative and quantitative explanation of the main features of the region of parameters with bounded motion is provided, along with the application of this technique to other symplectic mappings, including cases of multiple reversibility. Modern chaos indicators, such as the Reversibility Error Method (REM) and the Generalized Alignment Index (GALI), are employed to distinguish between various dynamical regimes in the mixed space of variables and parameters. These tools prove effective in differentiating regular and chaotic dynamics, as well as in identifying twistless orbits and their associated bifurcations. Additionally, we discuss the application of these methods to real-world problems, such as visualizing dynamic aperture in accelerator physics, where our findings have direct relevance. I Introduction The study of dynamical systems often reveals intricate structures and behaviors, bridging mathematics, physics, and computational science. By iterating discrete-time mappings or solving differential equations, we uncover regimes of motion that can be stable or unstable, periodic or quasiperiodic, regular or chaotic, or, let say, converge to an attractor. Domains corresponding to different regimes of motion for various dynamical systems are known to present complex shapes in the space of both phase-space variables and the system’s parameters. A cornerstone of exploring complex dynamical systems lies in the visualization and classification of stability regimes. These visual tools, such as bifurcation diagrams and control plots, form the foundation for understanding transitions and behaviors within these systems. By offering a visual language, they allow researchers to interpret how systems evolve under varying parameters and initial conditions. Among the most famous examples of such visualizations are the Mandelbrot-Brooks-Matelski (MBM), Julia, and Fatou sets. These sets collectively serve as a powerful framework for analyzing the interplay between stability, chaos, and fractal geometries in the context of iterated complex functions. The story of these sets begins in the early 1900s with French mathematicians Gaston Julia [ 1 ] and Pierre Fatou [ 2 , 3 ] , who pioneered the study of iterations of complex functions. In 1978, Robert W. Brooks and Peter Matelski [ 4 ] were the first to depict these structures graphically, with their original plots reconstructed in pallettes (a.1) and (b.1) of Fig. 1 . Shortly after, Benoit Mandelbrot used the computational power of IBM’s Research Center to create high-resolution visualizations of the MBM set [ 5 ] , forever linking these fractal structures to the emerging field of chaos theory. Figure 1: Julia and MBM sets . The top row shows the Julia set (a.1) for f(z)=z^{2}+C with C=0.1+0.6\,i and the Mandelbrot-Brooks-Matelski (MBM) set (b.1) reproduced from the original work of Brooks and Matelski [ 4 ] . The bottom row presents high-resolution, colorized versions of these sets, generated using Wolfram Mathematica built-in functions. The red point in (b.2) corresponds to 0.1+0.6\,i . All three sets arise from iterating the quadratic map: z\mapsto z^{\prime}=z^{2}+C,\qquad\qquad z\in\mathbb{C}, with complex parameter C\in\mathbb{C}, but each set, however, explores a distinct aspect of the system. The MBM set identifies all complex values of C , for which the iteration, starting from z_{0}=0 remains bounded. Within the Mandelbrot set, the behavior of the system is stable. These stable regions correspond to black areas in visualizations, while points outside the set represent parameters where the orbit diverges. These diverging regions are often color-coded to reflect the rate of escape, see plot (b.2) in Fig. 1 . The boundary of the Mandelbrot set is a fractal, infinitely complex and self-similar, serving as a control plot for mapping stability. Each point in the Mandelbrot set corresponds to a unique Julia set, linking parameter space to phase space, for instance, the red point in plot (b.2) corresponds to the Julia set depicted in plot (a.2). Julia sets examine the dynamics for a fixed parameter C , focusing on the phase space of initial conditions z_{0} . These sets form the boundary between points that generate bounded orbits and those that escape to infinity. When C lies inside the Mandelbrot set, the corresponding Julia set is connected, resembling a cohesive fractal structure. Conversely, if C is outside the Mandelbrot set, the Julia set is a Cantor set, consisting of disconnected points scattered across the plane. The boundary of the Julia set is where chaotic dynamics dominate, with points neither escaping nor converging but instead forming fractal patterns. Fatou set complements this picture, representing regions of phase space where the dynamics are smooth and predictable, such as convergence to fixed points or periodic orbits. Real plane mappings provide two other prominent examples of quadratic iterations: the dissipative Hénon–Pomeau map [ 6 ] , characterized by its strange attractor and two parameters, and the area-preserving quadratic Hénon map [ 7 ] , which depends on a single parameter. Both are among the most extensively studied dynamical systems of the plane. We speculate that the Hénon–Pomeau attractor has garnered greater attention due to its broader range of applications. Notably, in 1993, a colored version of the control plot illustrating the structure of its parameter space was published in [ 8 ] . In contrast, the area-preserving Hénon map has received significant theoretical attention [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] , with its phase space diagrams setting the standard for illustrating chaotic dynamics. Yet, despite its theoretical prominence, comprehensive visualizations of its mixed variable-parameter space remain limited, even though this was originally attempted in Hénon’s seminal work. This set was intended to be a control plot, summarizing the continuum of two-dimensional phase space portraits into a two-dimensional representation of the mapping’s parameter and a coordinate along the symmetry line, Fig. 2 . However, much like the original image generated by Brooks and Matelski, which was limited to under 100 pixels in each dimension (approximately 1 kilopixel), the resolution of the Hénon set — restricted to 199\times 159 pixels (about 30,000 sample trajectories) — lacked the clarity needed to capture the full intricacy of the system’s dynamics. Modern computational tools, such as the built-in functions MandelbrotSetPlot[] and JuliaSetPlot[] introduced in Wolfram Mathematica 10.0 [ 12 ] , provide efficient visualization of the MBM set, enabling the creation

Read the complete text