Spatially modulated plasma profile for turbulence and instabilities mitigation in fusion plasma.
Ilya Shesterikov · 2024
Read Spatially modulated plasma profile for turbulence and instabilities mitigation in fusion plasma. by Ilya Shesterikov (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05310.txt.
Introduction
Ilya Shesterikov, writing alone in a 2024 paper, proposes a way to calm turbulence in fusion plasma. Turbulence and large waves carry heat out of the hot fuel, spoiling confinement in fusion devices. His idea imposes a regular, repeating variation on the plasma's profile, much as layered crystals block certain light and sound frequencies.
The math mirrors a driven oscillator near resonance. By shaping how fast turbulent waves travel at each point, the pattern can weaken them in chosen bands. He suggests three ways to impose the pattern: radio waves, fixed magnetic tweaks, or shaped density profiles. If it works in hardware, the method could add a tunable knob for stability across many fusion designs, rather than a fix tied to one machine.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ilya Shesterikov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 23 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05310
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Spatially modulated plasma profile for turbulence and instabilities mitigation in fusion plasma. Ilya Shesterikov Abstract This work explores a novel approach to mitigating turbulence in fusion plasmas through spatially modulated plasma profiles. By imposing a harmonic modulation on plasma parameters, we introduce conditions that alter the propagation characteristics of turbulent and MHD waves, a primary source of transport and instabilities in fusion devices. This modulation approach resembles bandgap formation in solid-state and photonic crystals, where spatial periodicity suppresses wave propagation within specific frequency bands. The mathematical framework developed here essentially resembles the parametric resonance of the harmonic oscillator. It reveals how a controlled spatial variation of turbulent wave phase velocity can effectively attenuate turbulence and instabilities. Several methods for implementing this modulation in plasma, including RF waves, static magnetic field perturbations, and modulated density profiles, are proposed as potential paths for achieving stable confinement. This concept could provide a versatile and potentially more controllable alternative to existing turbulence suppression techniques, with the goal of improving stability and confinement across a variety of magnetized fusion configurations. Email: [email protected] The purpose of this work is to demonstrate the potential and new prospects that open up for fusion research through the creation of a spatially modulated plasma profile. These emerging opportunities can be used for suppressing instabilities and plasma turbulence (and actually plasma heating). In this work, we will focus primarily on using the proposed concept to suppress turbulence in plasma. Rather than providing a ready solution, this work aims to identify potential research directions and introduces a conceptual framework for mitigating plasma turbulence and instabilities. The formation of turbulence and plasma instabilities is one of the fundamental problems of nuclear fusion. Drift and interchange turbulence, electron-temperature and ion-temperature turbulence are the main causes of transport in fusion devices. Along with turbulence, there are also MHD instabilities that cause transport and loss of stability in toroidal devices. Methods for suppressing or reducing turbulence already exist, such as • formation of transport barriers based on plasma rotation shear, leading to improved confinement modes • plasma shaping and magnetic field configuration optimization However, the formation of transport barriers is a self-organizing process, not always well-controllable and manageable, and not implementable in all devices. Moreover, transport barriers are fairly localized in the radial direction—they do not suppress turbulence over a broad radial range. Plasma shape and magnetic topology optimization is the subject of another constraints, as improper configurations could lead to new instability modes. In other words, finding alternative approaches of turbulence and instabilities mitigation that are more universal, controllable, and comprehensive is very important. This is especially important considering the variety of magnetic confinement fusion devices that have emerged recently. Let’s consider various types of devices that utilize magnetic fields to confine hot plasma, such as tokamaks, stellarators, pinches, and linear machines. The following sections will explore strategies for suppressing drift wave turbulence. While the specific details may vary, the core principles of the proposed concept can be extended to other types of wave-like turbulence, such as interchange turbulence or MHD instabilities. The time-averaged spatial scale of plasma parameters in fusion plasmas has typically the scale of the confinement device, i.e. on the spatial scale of plasma turbulence (which is typically \approx 1-2~cm ) all plasma parameters appear uniform. Consequently, parameters such as the phase velocity of waves, pressure gradient, and other quantities that influence the development of turbulence also appear uniform on these small turbulent scales. Let us now consider a scenario where the turbulent wave phase velocity along the direction of turbulence propagation is spatially modulated but constant in time. In other words, we superimpose a harmonically varying profile with a wavelength comparable to the turbulence scale onto a smooth, homogeneous plasma profile. The presence of such a modulation significantly alters the nature of wave propagation and turbulence development. For instance, taking the drift wave as an example, the spatial modulation of the plasma density or magnetic field is equivalent to modulating the phase velocity of drift waves, as their phase velocity is described by the electron diamagnetic drift velocity. 0.1 Analogies to other physical systems Suppressing waves by spatial modulation of their phase velocity is not a new phenomenon in general physics. This principle is similar to the existence of forbidden energy bands in the crystal lattice of a solid state [1]. Forbidden electron energy bands are formed due to the spatial periodicity of the potential energy field created by the crystal lattice. Solving the Schrödinger equation for the electron wave function in a periodic potential field gives us the band structure of energy. Another example is optical photonic crystals [2,3,4] . The propagation of light in a medium with a spatially periodic refractive index leads to the formation of the so-called optical band structure, zones of forbidden and allowed EM wave frequencies that either can or cannot propagate in the crystal. This is also easily reproduced if we look at the solution of the wave equation in a medium with a spatially varying refractive index. In the field of mechanics, this phenomenon is commonly referred to as parametric instability [5,6,7,8,9,10]. Depending on specific resonant conditions, it can cause mechanical oscillations to either amplify or diminish. 1 Mathematical formalism Let us consider the mathematical formalism of this process. As a test-bed in our discussion we choose drift waves, although on the place of drift waves can be any other type of plasma waves (interchange-type turbulence or MHD waves). Without delving into details, we write the wave equation for drift waves. The phase velocity of these waves, as can be seen, is determined by the electron diamagnetic drift velocity, i.e., it is inversely proportional to the magnetic field strength and plasma density. Thus, a spatial periodic variation of these quantities is equivalent to a spatial variation of the phase velocity. The equation descibing the propagation of the drift wave in the magnetized plasma can be written as follows: \dfrac{d^{2}\textbf{n}}{dt^{2}}=u_{p}^{2}\dfrac{d^{2}\textbf{n}}{dx^{2}} (1) here u_{p} is the wave phase velocity. The drift wave phase velocity represent the electron diamagnetic drift velocity: u_{p}=\dfrac{\nabla p\times\textbf{B}}{ne\textbf{B}^{2}}, where p=nT_{e} is the plasma pressure. First, we take the time Fourier transform of both sides of the Eq. 1 . \mathcal{F}\left\{\frac{\partial^{2}\mathbf{n}}{\partial x^{2}}\right\}=\frac{\partial^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega}(x)}{\partial x^{2}} (2) \mathcal{F}\left\{\dfrac{d^{2}\textbf{n}}{dt^{2}}\right\}=-\omega^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega} Combining both parts we rewrite the equation above in the Fourier space. u_{p}^{2}\frac{\partial^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega}(x)}{\partial x^{2}}=-\omega^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega} (3) Let us rewrite this equation as a traditional equation for a harmonic oscillator. \frac{\partial^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega}(x)}{\partial x^{2}}=-\dfrac{\omega^{2}}{u_{p}^{2}}\textbf{n}_{\omega}=-k^{2}\,\textbf{n}_{\omega} (4) The drift wave favorably develops in the conditions where u_{p} is constant on the wavelength scale. Let’s now consider the opposite situation, the development in the plasma where u_{p} has a periodical spatial dependence. Specifically, we will determine the conditions for wave development in a case where u_{p} slightly differs from some constant value and is a simple spatially periodic function u_{p}(x) . u_{p}(x)=u^{0}_{p}(1-\varepsilon\,\cos(\beta x)) (5) where the constant \varepsilon\ll 1 and \beta designates the wave number of the spatial modulation. The sign of \varepsilon is not that important since we can always change this sign by the corresponding choice of the reference frame. Substituting this expression ( 5 ) in the Eq. 4 gives \frac{\partial^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega}(x)}{\partial x^{2}}=-\dfrac{\omega^{2}}{{(u^{0}_{p}(1-\varepsilon\,\cos(\beta x)))}^{2}}\textbf{n}_{\omega}\approx-\bigl(\dfrac{\omega}{u^{0}_{p}}\bigl)^{2}(1+2\,\varepsilon\,\cos(\beta x))\,\textbf{n}_{\omega} (6) or, designating k_{0}=\dfrac{\omega}{u^{0}_{p}} (7) \frac{\partial^{2}\textbf{n}_{\omega}(x)}{\partial x^{2}}=-k_{0}^{2}(1+2\,\varepsilon\,\cos(\beta x))\,\textbf{n}_{\omega} (8) We will see later that the effect of