Partial Wavefunction Collapse Under Repeated Weak Measurement of a Non-Conserved Observable
Carter J. Swift, Nandini Trivedi · 2024
Read Partial Wavefunction Collapse Under Repeated Weak Measurement of a Non-Conserved Observable by Carter J. Swift, Nandini Trivedi (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05226.txt.
Introduction
Carter Swift and Nandini Trivedi study what happens when a quantum system is weakly measured again and again for a trait that its own motion does not conserve, in a 2024 paper. In the standard gentle case, the measured trait settles and the system falls into one of its states. That needs the trait to commute with the system's energy rule.
Here that condition fails, so the measured trait cannot settle. Yet the authors find that a second trait, one that commutes with both the measured trait and the energy rule, does behave in that gentle way. Its average is conserved, and the system partly falls into its states. They work through an example showing how this surprise arises.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Carter J. Swift, Nandini Trivedi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05226
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Partial Wavefunction Collapse Under Repeated Weak Measurement of a Non-Conserved Observable Carter J. Swift, Nandini Trivedi Abstract Two hallmarks of quantum non-demolition (QND) measurement are the ensemble-level conservation of the expectation value of the measured observable A A and the eventual, inevitable collapse of the system into some eigenstate of A A . This requires that A A commutes with H H , the system’s Hamiltonian. In what we term “Auxiliary Observable QND” measurement, A A does not commute with H H and the above two characteristics clearly cannot be present as the system’s dynamics prevent ⟨ A ⟩ \langle A\rangle from reaching a definite value. However, in this paper we find that under such a measurement QND behavior still arises, but is seen in the behavior of a secondary “target” observable we call B B , with the condition that B B commutes with both A A and H H . In such cases, the expectation value of B B is conserved and the system at least partially collapses with respect to eigenstates of B B . We show as an example how this surprising result applies to a Heisenberg chain, where we demonstrate that local measurements on a single site can reveal information about the spectrum of an entire system, a finding which may be of practical use in experiments. I Introduction Timestep Meas. Result \langle\sigma^{z}\rangle (a) (a) Timestep \langle\sigma^{z}\rangle (b) (b) \langle\sigma^{z}\rangle Count (c) (c) (d) Frequency Amplitude (d) Figure 1: QND Weak Measurement of \sigma^{z} of a qubit initialized in \lvert\rightarrow\rangle . a) (Bottom) A series of weak measurement results from projection of the ancilla; (Top) The expectation value \langle\sigma^{z}\rangle of the qubit corresponding to the measurement record. Each result nudges the expectation value at the following timestep in the same direction as the result. b) Repeated weak measurement of the qubit leads to eventual collapse to an eigenstate of \sigma^{z} following some period of stochastic evolution. c) Distributions of \langle\sigma^{z}\rangle for 10^{5} simulated qubits subjected to repeated weak measurement, shown after certain numbers of measurements have been completed. It is seen that while each individual run collapses to an eigenstate, the ensemble-average expectation value of 0 is conserved. (d) Averaged pre-collapse noise spectrum of 100 runs shows 1/f behavior. An important concept in the theory of quantum measurements is the notion of wavefunction collapse, where following a projective measurement of a system prepared in a superposition of eigenstates, any subsequent measurements of the same observable on the same system yield the same eigenvalue as the first measurement. Weak measurement is a type of measurement in which the system of interest is not directly projected in order to avoid this immediate collapse. This can be achieved by entangling the system with an ancillary degree of freedom which is itself then projectively measured. In this way, controlling the parameters coupling the ancilla to the system results in a tunable trade-off between the amount of information obtained and the degree to which the original system state is disturbed (for an overview of weak measurement, see [ 1 ] ). When the observable to be measured commutes with the system Hamiltonian this produces a quantum non-demolition (QND) measurement [ 2 ] . Importantly, non-demolition does not mean that the system is unchanged, just that the ensemble average of the expectation value of the measured observable is unchanged by the measurement. It has been shown that repeated QND weak measurements converge to an eigenstate of the measured observable, asymptotically reproducing a projective measurement and the associated wavefunction collapse [ 3 ] . In Fig. 1 , we illustrate this behavior in the example of QND weak measurement of a single qubit. In particular, panel (c) highlights the two important properties of eventual collapse and conservation of ensemble-average expectation value. These two properties have made QND weak measurement an appealing tool for experiment, as it behaves in a way that one expects measurements to behave, while giving the experimenter more control than can be achieved with only projective measurements. QND measurement has received significant attention over the years, particularly in the context of experiment. Early work on foundations and applications of QND measurements can be seen in [ 2 ] and [ 4 ] . More recently, QND weak measurement was used in a breakthrough experiment that was able to intercept and reverse individual quantum jumps as they happened [ 5 ] . QND has also featured heavily in the context of understanding wavefunction collapse and the “measurement problem” [ 6 , 7 ] . Collapse under weak measurement has also been examined by Korotkov in the context of continuous measurement of a double quantum dot [ 8 ] . In contrast to QND measurement, one might instead consider a case in which the measured operator does not commute with the system Hamiltonian. For reasons that will soon become clear, we call this situation Auxiliary Observable QND (AO-QND) measurement. In ordinary QND the measurement back-action accumulates uninterrupted by any system dynamics, culminating in eventual collapse to an eigenstate of the measured operator, yet in AO-QND sequential measurement the system dynamics do interfere with the back-action, clearly rendering it impossible for collapse to an eigenstate of the measured operator to occur. So, for the behavior of a system subjected to this type of measurement, we would perhaps expect something resembling the early-time behavior of the QND case, but with no eventual collapse. One would therefore expect that subjecting a system to such a measurement protocol would not reveal any useful information. Indeed, such a protocol has been determined to behave as if the measurement basis was chosen randomly for each measurement, making gleaning useful information a challenging task, although it has also been shown that the protocol could at least be used for quantum state tomography [ 9 ] . In this paper we examine the consequences of AO-QND measurement processes and present as an example a numerical simulation of such a process being applied to a particular system, the Heisenberg chain. Our results indicate that the naïve expectation of non-collapse does not fully reflect reality, as an AO-QND measurement process does indeed extract information from the system and lead to at least a partial collapse of the system state. In section II we approach the problem theoretically and prove that such collapse can be expected under general circumstances for any operator which commutes with both the system Hamiltonian and the measured operator. Then, in section III we treat the particular case of a Heisenberg chain, finding that repeatedly measuring the z-component of the spin on the end of the chain causes it to oscillate with sharp Fourier peaks that correspond to energy gaps in the spectrum of the chain. We show that these oscillations arise as a result of the chain collapsing into a sector with a definite total z-component, making contact with our general proof. Finally, we comment on how these findings indicate that AO-QND measurement protocols may be of practical use in experiment and should not be overlooked. II Repeated Weak Measurement We now provide a theoretical description of the weak measurement process, for general systems weakly measured by a sequence of qubit ancillas. We will derive all results