Go-or-Grow Models in Biology: a Monster on a Leash

Ryan Thiessen, Martina Conte, Tracy L. Stepien, Thomas Hillen · 2024

Read Go-or-Grow Models in Biology: a Monster on a Leash by Ryan Thiessen, Martina Conte, Tracy L. Stepien, Thomas Hillen (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05191.txt.

Introduction

Thiessen and co-authors review a family of models where cells must choose: move or multiply, never both at once. Go-or-grow models, born for brain tumors that invade as they spread, pair migration with reproduction through reaction-diffusion equations. The switch gives the mathematics a wild streak that this survey tames and displays.

The authors tour the biology first, then the hard questions. When do solutions exist and stay unique? How do patterns form, and how fast do invasion fronts travel? They add fresh results on that critical domain size and on wave speeds. A warning closes the paper: the models are so unstable that no current numerical solver can be fully trusted, a monster that demands a short leash.

Catalog record

CREATORRyan Thiessen, Martina Conte, Tracy L. Stepien, Thomas Hillen
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Go-or-Grow Models in Biology: a Monster on a Leash Ryan Thiessen, Martina Conte, Tracy L. Stepien, Thomas Hillen Abstract Go-or-grow approaches represent a specific class of mathematical models used to describe populations where individuals either migrate or reproduce, but not both simultaneously. These models have a wide range of applications in biology and medicine, chiefly among those the modeling of brain cancer spread. The analysis of go-or-grow models has inspired new mathematics, and it is the purpose of this review to highlight interesting and challenging mathematical properties of reaction–diffusion models of the go-or-grow type. We provide a detailed review of biological and medical applications before focusing on key results concerning solution existence and uniqueness, pattern formation, critical domain size problems, and traveling waves. We present new general results related to the critical domain size and traveling wave problems, and we connect these findings to the existing literature. Moreover, we demonstrate the high level of instability inherent in go-or-grow models. We argue that there is currently no accurate numerical solver for these models, and emphasize that special care must be taken when dealing with the “monster on a leash”. Keywords – Go-or-grow dichotomy | Glioma | Traveling Waves | Instabilities and Patterns | Critical domain size MSC codes – 92B05, 35B36, 35M30 1 Introduction Various biological processes involve a dichotomy between proliferation and migration: individuals in a population either remain relatively stationary and reproduce, or they migrate with minimal reproduction. This phenomenon has been particularly emphasized in the study of glioma progression, where the “go-or-grow” hypothesis was coined to describe the behavior of brain tumor cells [ 48 ] . The seminal work by Murray et al. [ 88 ] laid the groundwork for much of the existing mathematical modeling of glioma spread, which is based on the classical Fisher–Kolmogorov–Petrovsky–Piskounov (FKPP) equation. This reaction–diffusion macroscopic mathematical framework has been termed as the proliferation–infiltration (PI) model, as it captures both the proliferative and invasive behaviors of glioma cells observed in experiments and clinical settings. The strength of the PI model lies in its simplicity, requiring only a small set of parameters, which facilitates its calibration to patient-specific data. Extensions of the PI model account for the influence of surrounding tissue, chemical signals, and/or vasculature on glioma cell density [ 115 , 62 , 103 , 53 , 114 , 116 , 20 , 25 , 26 ] . Advection bias in response to environmental cues has also been incorporated, either directly in the macroscopic model, based on mass/flux/momentum balance [ 18 , 65 ] , or through more detailed descriptions derived from lower-scale dynamics, as initially proposed in [ 93 ] and further developed in [ 19 , 31 , 22 , 32 , 33 , 113 , 21 ] . Many models have also been developed in (semi)discrete settings [ 7 , 48 , 66 ] . However, due to the complexity of glioma growth—spanning interactions between glioma cells, their microenvironment, immune cells, vasculature, and molecular signalling systems, all within the heterogeneous landscape of brain tissue—an exhaustive model remains elusive. As a result, models typically focus on well-defined subprocesses. Among these, the phenotypic heterogeneity of glioma cells plays a central role. While there are numerous reviews of mathematical modeling of gliomas [ 49 , 84 , 1 , 64 ] , this paper specifically focuses on a family of reaction–diffusion models of the go-or-grow type. In these models, a distinct separation between proliferating and migrating cells leads to systems of two coupled reaction–diffusion equations. We will focus our attention on a minimal go-or-grow model consisting of two coupled differential equations for the evolution of a moving subpopulation and a resting and proliferating subpopulation of cells. We assume linear diffusion for the moving population and neglect any small diffusivity in the resting population. Concerning the transition functions between the two subpopulations, we account for a general dependence on both subpopulation densities, defining this setting as the general go-or-grow model . As described above, there are several extensions of this framework that may include nonlinear diffusion of the moving compartment, general waiting time distributions, small diffusivity in the stationary compartment, or more complex population dynamics. Their analysis is rich, well-developed, and their analytical properties are vast [ 88 , 37 , 108 , 9 , 67 ] . 1.1 Paper outline We first provide in Section 2 a detailed overview of the use of go-or-grow models for describing glioma dynamics (Section 2.1 ), reviewing the biological evidence of the go-or-grow dichotomy in glioma (Section 2.1.1 ) and the mathematical literature of go-or-grow models formulated with discrete, continuous, deterministic and stochastic approaches (Section 2.2 ). We also discuss applications of the go-or-grow dichotomy in ecology and other biological settings (Section 2.3 ). In Section 3 , we first review the classical FKPP equation as a reference point for further modeling and analysis. We then introduce the main players of this review article, namely the general go-or-grow model and its simplifications, which we call the total population go-or-grow model , where the transition functions depend on the sum of the two subpopulation densities [ 97 , 111 , 121 , 117 , 8 , 34 , 48 ] , and the balanced go-or-grow model and constant rates go-or-grow model , which fit into the context analyzed in [ 41 , 42 , 37 , 34 , 8 , 97 , 117 ] . We show that for fast transition rates, a FKPP-type model can be found as the leading order approximation. After the models are defined, we focus on some mathematical properties. In Section 4 , we review a method by Rothe [ 101 ] to obtain a general local and global existence result. This does, however, not prevent strange behavior, as we show in Section 5 . Here we employ methods that were developed by Marciniak-Czochra et al. [ 82 , 47 ] , to find that high-frequency instabilities are possible, and in fact, likely to occur. Section 6 focuses on the classical ecological problem of a critical domain size, investigating what is the minimum size of a domain to support a go-or-grow population by reviewing previous results of Hadeler et al. [ 46 , 74 ] . Section 7 then focuses on the existence of invasion waves and the estimation of the invasion speeds. We review previous results by Hadeler et al. [ 46 ] , Pham et al. [ 97 ] , Stepien et al. [ 111 ] , and Falcó et al. [ 34 ] , and put them into an extended general framework. For this, we employ the general theory of invasion fronts of cooperative systems to generate a new result that applies in our more general framework. This section closes with a comparison of the wave speeds of the go-or-grow models to the FKPP wave speed. This paper is rounded off with a discussion (Section 8 ) of the relevance of these models to both biology and mathematics and the mathematical challenges that are still open. The biological applications are manifold, and the mathematical problems are interesting and challenging. 2 Biological background and previous mathematical models 2.1 Motivation: glioma dynamics Gliomas are the most frequent type of primary brain

Read the complete text