“If it has an exclamation point, I step away from it, I need facts, not excited feelings ’ ’: Technologically Mediated Parental COVID Uncertainty
Karen Joy, Michelle Liang, Tawfiq Ammari · 2024
Read “If it has an exclamation point, I step away from it, I need facts, not excited feelings ’ ’: Technologically Mediated Parental COVID Uncertainty by Karen Joy, Michelle Liang, Tawfiq Ammari (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05181.txt.
Introduction
Karen Joy, Michelle Liang, and Tawfiq Ammari study how parents coped with doubt when their child caught COVID-19, in a 2024 paper. A new virus left parents unsure of signs, outlook, and shot choices. Many turned to social feeds for help, with mixed gain.
The team held deep talks with more than twenty such parents. They framed the tales with a known theory of doubt in ill health, then stretched it for the feed age. One parent line gives the flavor: heat and hype push her away, facts draw her in. The team closes with design tips to make feeds kinder to scared parents.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Karen Joy, Michelle Liang, Tawfiq Ammari |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2024 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 107 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05181
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
“If it has an exclamation point, I step away from it, I need facts, not excited feelings ’ ’: Technologically Mediated Parental COVID Uncertainty Karen Joy, Michelle Liang, Tawfiq Ammari Abstract . As a novel virus, COVID introduced considerable uncertainty into the daily lives of people all over the globe since late 2019. Relying on twenty-three semi-structured interviews with parents whose children contracted COVID, we analyzed how the use of social media moderated parental uncertainty about the symptoms, prognosis, long-term potential health ramifications of infection, vaccination, and other issues. We framed our findings using Mishel’s Uncertainty in Illness theory. We propose new components to the theory that account for technological mediation in uncertainty. We also propose design recommendations to help parents cope with health uncertainty using social media. DOI: XXXXXXX.XXXXXXX Conference: conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; Nov 9–13, 2024; San José, Costa Rica ISBN: 978-1-4503-XXXX-X/18/06 CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) 1. Introduction Uncertainty in the context of illnesses is a multifaceted experience that individuals and their families often encounter in healthcare ( Mast, 1995 ; Mishel, 1999 ) . It involves the lack of predictability and clarity across various dimensions of an illness. This uncertainty emerges from factors such as the diagnosis, prognosis, severity, and progression of the condition, presenting emotional challenges ( Moos and Schaefer, 1984 ) . The concept of uncertainty is defined as the inability to determine the meaning of illness-related events in situations where decisive values cannot be assigned, and outcomes are unpredictable due to insufficient cues ( Mishel, 1981 ; Mishel, 1990 ; Mishel, 1999 ; Mishel, 1988 ) . For parents especially, when it comes to their child’s health, uncertainty leads to heightened anxiety levels, impacting various aspects of life ( Michelson et al., 2021 ; Nelson, 2010 ) . The highest levels of uncertainty are found in sudden and novel illness events or in chronic conditions where the disease course is unpredictable ( Wright et al., 2009 ; Pehora et al., 2015 ) . COVID was one such novel and unprecedented “illness”. A prevalent theory regarding uncertainty is the Uncertainty in Illness theory (UIT) ( Mishel, 1981 ; Mishel, 1988 ; Mishel, 1999 ; Mishel, 1990 ) , initially proposed for acute illnesses and later re-conceptualized to encompass chronic illnesses, highlighting how uncertainty extends beyond medical aspects to impact personal and social dimensions of daily life ( Zhang, 2017 ; Wright et al., 2009 ) . Lack of comprehensive information regarding COVID, especially COVID in children, contributed to uncertainty among parents, new parents, and parents whose children had medical complexities where they brought about changes in daily life, adding another layer of uncertainty. For this reason, parents took to online sources to find adequate support and navigate challenges effectively ( Richards et al., 2022 ) . Given the importance of online communities for parents as they make sense of an uncertain situation, we ask: RQ: How is parental COVID uncertainty mediated through social media? Analyzing twenty-three semi-structured interviews with parents using a socio-technical lens, we examined how parents used social media to find information and social support as they tried to make sense of and manage uncertainties they felt about COVID. This included searching for a sense of the prognosis of the disease when contracted by their children, especially if they had special needs. Parents were also unsure about the efficacy of COVID vaccines and how or if they might have any negative effects on their children. While we found that various social media sites were sources of evidence-based and experiential information, online communities were not always a safe space or a site of support for their uncertainties. For example, some of our parents felt they were being led “down a rabbit hole.” Others thought that platform-level moderation choices limited or improved their access to information. Some parents felt that they were engaged in challenging conversations with family members because of online information influences. Finally, the deluge of contradictory information increased parents’ uncertainty instead of reducing it. In this study, we focused on how the socio-technical nature of online communities factored into how parents managed their uncertainty. Specifically, we studied the following properties of social media sites used by parents: (1) algorithmic recommendations; (2) moderation governance; and (3) the nature of online communities (e.g., hyper-localized communities, etc). Based on this analysis, we proposed two new components to Mishel’s Uncertainty in Illness theory. Our first component is a socio-technical antecedent factor to be added to the existing biological, psychological, and social factors. Based on the appraisal of information through social media, we also propose a new negative adaptation component. While the original theory did not account for a negative adaptation, we found that when parents are “burned out” of their online interaction, they infact do not manage their COVID uncertainty at all. 2. Related Work Following the review of the Uncertainty in Illness theory (UIT), we review parents’ social media use. Finally, we analyze how COVID has affected people’s use of online communities. 2.1. Uncertainty in Illness Theory (UIT) Uncertainty is a fundamental aspect of the human journey. Uncertainty has been defined in several ways: a complex cognitive stressor, a sense of loss of control, and a perceptual state or attitude of doubt or not knowing that changes over time ( Mast, 1995 ; Penrod, 2001 ; Wiener and Dodd, 1993 ) . It becomes particularly prominent when individuals face a life-threatening or chronic illness ( Wright et al., 2009 ; Mast, 1995 ; Mishel, 1999 ) . The theory of uncertainty in illness (UIT) was first proposed by Mishel as a way to understand adjustment to acute illness ( Mishel, 1981 ; Mishel, 1990 ; Mishel, 1999 ; Mishel, 1988 ) . The theory was then re-conceptualized specifically looking at chronic illnesses and novel diseases in which uncertainty likely evolves progressively ( Wright et al., 2009 ; Mishel, 1990 ; Clayton et al., 2018 ; Bailey and Stewart, 2017 ) . UIT has its strongest support among subjects who are experiencing the acute phase of illness or are in a downward illness trajectory ( Mishel, 1981 ; Mishel, 1990 ; Mishel, 1999 ; Mishel, 1988 ) . UIT, in its original theory, as well as its adaptations by various studies, is illustrated over 3 main segments: (a) Antecedents, (b) Appraisal, and (c) Adaptation. The theory is presented in Figure 1 . Please note that we are modifying the theory in this study. Our modifications are highlighted with dotted outlines. They will be described in detail in § 5.1 . 2.1.1. Antecedents Antecedents are factors that contribute to the experience of uncertainty – factors such as the complexity of the illness, lack of information, and the unpredictability of the disease course ( Mishel, 1981 ; Mishel, 1990 ; Mishel, 1999 ; Mishel, 1988 ) . Studies claim that for uncertainty to predict the outcomes of individuals coping with illness, it is imperative to understand the antecedents of the same ( Wallace, 2005 ; Kang, 2011 ) . Antecedents have three components: (1) Biological factors; (2) Psychological factors; and (3) Social factors, as proposed in the readaptation of Mishel’s theory 1988 ( Mishel, 1988 ) by Wright et al., 2009 (