Modeling Task Immersion based on Goal Activation Mechanism

Kazuma Nagashima 1, Jumpei Nishikawa 1, Junya Morita 1,2 · 2024

Read Modeling Task Immersion based on Goal Activation Mechanism by Kazuma Nagashima 1, Jumpei Nishikawa 1, Junya Morita 1,2 (2024) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2412-05112.txt.

Introduction

Kazuma Nagashima, Jumpei Nishikawa, and Junya Morita wrote this cognitive science paper in 2024. Deep focus on a task feeds creativity, but too much arousal locks a person in, and outside events get missed. The team built a computer model of that trap inside ACT-R, a known frame for modeling thought. In the model, arousal acts as a dial on the firing strength of goals.

They ran the model under low- and high-arousal settings that mirror past human tests. Two readings of the human setup were tried for each. In both, the model's acts matched the people's acts. The match backs their take on how arousal steers goal firing. The authors say the model could guide how we pace work and breaks in daily life.

Catalog record

CREATORKazuma Nagashima 1, Jumpei Nishikawa 1, Junya Morita 1,2
YEAR2024
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2412-05112

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Modeling Task Immersion based on Goal Activation Mechanism Kazuma Nagashima 1, Jumpei Nishikawa 1, Junya Morita 1,2 Abstract Immersion in a task is a prerequisite for creativity. However, excessive arousal in a single task has drawbacks, such as overlooking events outside of the task. To examine such a negative aspect, this study constructs a computational model of arousal dynamics where the excessively increased arousal makes the task transition difficult. The model was developed using functions integrated into the cognitive architecture Adaptive Control of Thought-Rational (ACT-R). Under the framework, arousal is treated as a coefficient affecting the overall activation level in the model. In our simulations, we set up two conditions demanding low and high arousal, trying to replicate corresponding human experiments. In each simulation condition, two sets of ACT-R parameters were assumed from the different interpretations of the human experimental settings. The results showed consistency of behavior between humans and models both in the two different simulation settings. This result suggests the validity of our assumptions and has implications of controlling arousal in our daily life. ∎ 1 Introduction Concentrating on the task at hand, which sometimes relates to psychological states called immersion or flow 1 1 1 We use “immersion” as a synonym of “flow” in terms of Csikszentmihalyi’s flow theory [ 8 ] . In this theory, high arousal is pre-requisite of the state of flow. , is widely acknowledged as a precursor to achieving high performance in the task [ 8 ] . During such states, intensified concentration, coupled with a feeling of absolute control over the task, can foster creative outcomes, albeit sometimes at the cost of losing self-consciousness. This paper endeavors to construct a computational model elucidating the psychophysiological dynamics underlying an immersive state. Our model places particular emphasis on arousal, defined as “ a state of physiological activation or cortical responsiveness, associated with sensory stimulation and activation of fibers from the reticular activating system [ 35 ] .” From this definition, we understand arousal as activated brain states, which also relate to attention . One famous theory on the relation between arousal (activation) and attention is the cue utilization theory [ 11 ] , which points out that intensified arousal narrows attention to the external environment. In contrast to simple explanations of concentration based solely on the level of attention, those based on arousal connect to fundamental factors related to emotion and physiology (e.g., [ 30 ] ). Regarding such factors, the existence of an optimal level of arousal has been pointed out in several theories [ 8 , 27 , 39 ] , which suggest that both excessively high and exceedingly low arousal levels compared to the optimal level have detrimental effects on task motivation. In essence, task motivation is related with arousal level through an inverted U-shaped function, with the peak determined by task difficulty. Difficult tasks require high arousal levels. However, if tasks are too challenging for low-aroused workers, they lose motivation due to factors such as anxiety. Conversely, in simpler tasks where elevated arousal isn’t needed, highly aroused workers experience a loss of motivation due to boredom. Mismatching the level of arousal impacts task performance, not only motivation. In situations of low arousal, boredom with the task can lead to reduced performance due to distractions, a phenomenon often associated with mind-wandering [ 12 ] . Conversely, decreased performance caused by high arousal can occur in difficult tasks, where a certain level of concentration is required. As noted earlier, highly elevated arousal leads a deficit in attention allocation [ 11 ] . Thus, in a situation requiring high arousal, workers often overlook information outside of their current focus. Consequently, overall performance in situations involving multiple goals, such as multitasking, declines when workers’ arousal exceeds the optimal level for the task at hand [ 10 ] 2 2 2 Difficult tasks require more arousal than easier tasks. However, it is not true that higher arousal is always appropriate for the difficult task. . Numerous studies have explored human cognitive functions in relation to arousal levels. However, no models have integrated the cognitive functions that produce the temporal dynamics linking arousal changes to performance outcomes. We believe that this temporal integration of arousal and performance can be achieved through the utilization of a cognitive architecture that combines the fundamental cognitive functions involved in diverse tasks. In this study, we depict this process through the utilization of a cognitive architecture known as ACT-R (Adaptive Control of Thought-Rational [ 2 ] ). Similar to numerous other cognitive architectures, ACT-R offers modules that mirror brain functions employed consistently across multiple tasks (see [ 21 ] as a comprehensive review). The functions integrated into ACT-R modules encompass visual processing, motor actions, goal management, memory storage, and procedural memory. In addition to those symbolic modules, ACT-R includes components called subsymbolic process, which closely relates to motivation and emotional process. This study represents the process of immersion at a situation where multitasking (managing multiple goals) is required by combining these modules. In the upcoming section, we will explore relevant studies pertinent to the aforementioned objective of this research. Subsequently, we will delve into the specific human behaviors related to arousal in a multitasking context. Following this, we will elaborate on the ACT-R model, which integrates various foundational cognitive components to simulate these specific behavioral patterns. The simulation results revealed a sustained decrease of response times to the subgoal under a condition where low arousal is required, while in a condition where high arousal is needed, response times to the subgoal remained consistently high. In the final section, we will thoroughly examine the implications and limitations of this study. 2 Related Works This study combines primitive functions in ACT-R to explain arousal dynamics leading to deficits in attention allocation. This section presents general surveys on computational models of physiological mechanism and surveys focusing on research using ACT-R to explain arousal dynamics and multitasking. 2.1 Computational Models of Biological Homeostasis Physiological processes drive human arousal. Therefore, the optimal level of arousal described in the previous section can be interpreted in the context of homeostasis maintenance, which is a general self-regulating process that maintains its optimal values of physiological variables [ 5 , 6 ] . According to this theory, organisms can adapt to changing environments because of homeostasis. Computationally, homeostasis has been explained by the theory of predictive coding [ 7 , 14 , 28 , 33 ] , which posits that organisms desire to minimize long-term mismatches (errors, surprises) between predictions from experience and perceptions of the external environment. There are several ways to reduce these discrepancies. One way is to master the task so that the prediction is accurate and performance is close to the predicted states. However, mastering a particular task also induces mismatches in the future environment. Thus, the theory describes human behavior as a balance between minimizing prediction error for the current task (i.e., exploitation) and increasing prediction accuracy in future environments (i.e., exploration) [ 32 ] . Such a balancing behavior links to the optimal arousal theory by directly connecting surprises generated by prediction errors to arousal potential [ 37 ] . The relationship between prediction error and arousal (activation) is also explained by the

Read the complete text